Fours Years Undergraduate Program (FYUP) is again in debate after UGC has rejected Delhi University’s proposal and demanded an immediate rollback. The worst sufferers of all these hasty decisions are the students who are studying at DU. Let us here from them what they have to tell about this change and backtracking…
FYUP is in the interest of students
Pranidhi Rawat, BA Economics (Hons), 2nd year, SRCC, DU
Why FYUP? It’s of no use! Undo this decision!’, this was the reaction of DU students prevailing all over Delhi which was initiated in the year 2013 when DU’s top academic body adopted a four-year undergraduate program (FYUP) and implemented it in July 2013. As compared to the earlier three-year program, FYUP had 8 semesters spread over 4 years with 2 discipline courses, applied courses and the “the cherry on top” was the additional Foundation Course (FC) aimed at enhancing student’s intellectual ability.
The first and the foremost consequence of FYUP was “Protest against FYUP”. Many teachers of the Delhi University Teacher’s Association (DUTA) along with DU students started organizing protest campaigns against FYUP called as “Save Delhi University”. FYUP freshers were made to fill ‘FYUP Feedback’ form, which clearly reflected the disappointment among students but what DU is aiming to achieve is also not wrong.
Personally as a student, I would consider FYUP as a ‘Good Decision’ in the interest of our future though it’s completely true that the schedule and the burden of presentations and projects made our lives little stressed but that is a part of learning only. Taking a four year degree brings us equal to international education standard (i.e. students who want to study in abroad need 16 years of schooling which the 10+2+4 system will provide) which will further help the Indian students to meet the requirements of the international education system. Companies themselves demand a four-year degree in order to provide a better job profile.
Some of the foundational courses were Science and Life, Business, Entrepreneurship and Management; History, IT, English and Hindi. Although some of the subjects seemed “not really important” but the daily discussions and debates on social issues helped building awareness and confidence and has definitely improved our intellectual ability. Earlier in school days, most of us generally feared giving presentations but FYUP made us do a lot presentations and field work; every teacher expected us to present original matter, something new and fascinating which ignited the fire in us to bring forth the best we can. Now we don’t really fear giving presentations anymore.
But the perennial controversial hustle over FYUP finally bore sour fruits on 28 June 2014, when DU officially scrapped FYUP after the order of UGC which stated that this program is against the official education standard of India, contradicting their own behavior before BJP government in 2013. What was most surprising was the protest done by people who weren’t even admitted in FYUP program. For a FYUP student like me it’s difficult to interpret such protest. There are many students like me who wanted FYUP to continue as it was beneficial but I guess the DUTA teachers still want to teach students in their old 60’s style and do not want to experiment something new.
Everyone has their own perception about FYUP and its merits and demerits and only the future results of this change could have proven whether the decision was right or not but, in India it has been a proven fact that change doesn’t come easy and so is the case with Delhi University.
FYUP – a fallen ‘hero’
Anjoom Amani, B.Com. (Hons), 3rd year, SRCC, DU
‘FYUP go back’, this was the first thing i heard about the new system which is going to be introduced in Delhi University for the batch right after mine. Media celebrated this by cutting and examining each of it’s pieces and bringing forward its demerits and irrelevance.
There were protests in large numbers throughout the DU, North Campus regarding this issue which was conducted by various student’s and teacher’s associations. But, the Vice Chancellor Dr. Dinesh Singh was not ready to change his decision and with this, it was decided that no more students are graduating from University of Delhi with an honors degree in 3 years. It is going to take a bit longer.i.e. 4 years.
This created a sense of insecurity among the students who already enrolled for a 3 year system because they feared the new system might overshadow the existing one and this may reduce the value of their degree. At the same time, there was a confusion among the students who were planning to build their career through a graduation from Delhi University and who were waiting for their 12th results. But, the Vice Chancellor found a solution for this. He made a video byte in which CBSE All India topper says his thumbs are high for FYUP. The media was not satisfied with this also. But, the Vice Chancellor had a solution for this too. In his interview to CNN he set forward many data which shows the rate of students who are not able to find a ‘decent’ job after their graduation which was considerably very low when compared to the leading universities of other nation and even less than some of the universities in India. The problem for which the VC was not able to find any solution for was, the system itself. The questions which were raised by students and teachers about the course structure and its details, the only answer V.C. had for those questions was “it’s a growing system”. We’ll find the answers eventually’. The fact was, he himself was not clear about the system which was
initiated by himself.
The course includes 11 papers which were called FCs (Foundation Courses) which were mandatory for all students under this system, irrespective of their courses. These Foundation Courses included papers from various streams like Mathematics to Psychology and the keen attraction of these FCs were, these FCs helped the students to go back to their school life because of its level and standard. A student, who decided to lead his life as a historian was also made to study Mathematics and Business. May be because, now he could calculate the years properly or could know the market value of an antique. Another main attraction of these FCs were ‘presentations’. Food, water, shelter, clothes etc., till that these were the basic requirements.
But, after these FCs introduced, there was a situation where no student in DU can survive without Microsoft Powerpoint. Even though it helped the students to bring out their communication skills, it took away more than half the time of a student and because of which students were not able to give time for their DCs (discipline courses). IMBH was another feature of FYUP. Interesting thing about IMBH is even now, nobody knows what it is and why is it included in the course.
With lots of problems and pressure, FYUP was working ‘smoothly’. By this time the organizations which were protesting against this with the slogan ‘FYUP go back’ came with their next step and new slogan ‘roll back FYUP’ and with the new government, they succeeded in rolling it back. The students were the ultimate sufferers. The experiment with 54000 ‘guinea pigs’ was unsuccessful. While introducing the system, may be the V.C. was unaware of the fact that he is playing with the lives and careers of a generation which may change the country’s position in near future. While coining them as ‘guinea pigs’, he forgot the fact, that they were not. By cancelling or rolling back FYUP, the burden on students in coming 2 years will be much more than that of a student in 3 years undergraduate program since they did not cover the portion of their major disciplines in their first year as much as a student in the previous system covered. The system which was introduced to reduce the work load of a student is now increasing them. The students were so optimistic when the V.C. claimed that it is them who will reap the fruits of this system and its success and also its rotten fruits. What worries them now, is the person who claimed this is no longer there in that position. But, it was never the Vice Chancellor or a particular system or a particular university which makes a student successful and extra ordinary. Its the students themself. And those who realise this fact, is not going to give up and for them, even this one year was also of a great experiance which may help them alot in their future. And, to know this, we should wait. Maybe 2 years, may be 3 and may be even longer.
Featured Image source: http://www.coolage.in/2013/08/21/vote-no-to-fyup-an-aisa-initiative/

