A Talaq To Reason

0
134

In an India of emotions, The Muslim Woman (Protection Of Rights On Marriage) Bill, 2017 did deserve all the drum beating it witnessed. With the exhilaration depicted by the ruling party in brazenly hurrying with this bill of pomp, it may well go down as another brownie point for chest thumping in political speeches and clap earning fact in media debates. However, as is often seen, a detailed insight into the proposed act seems to suggest an infirm law that has more scope for lapses, ambiguity and misuse rather than achieve the object for which the bill has apparently been tabled.

Firstly, the language put to ink while drafting the law is highly vague, cryptic and uncertain. It oozes with confusion right from the beginning. To begin with , the definition of talaq was given as follows

  • “talaq” means talaq-e-biddat or any other similar form of talaq having the effect of instantaneous and irrevocable divorce pronounced by a Muslim husband.

However there are various kinds of talaqs in the Islamic law. What made the makers skip emphasis and use the term talaq instead of talaq e biddat itself. This proposed law explains that the talaq should be instantaneous and irrevocable for it to invite penal provision. Since the definition included talaq e biddat or anyother similar form of talaq, it should be understood that there are quite a number of ways by which there can be separation between the spouses. Even in the most acceptable and prevalent form of practiced talaq, (Talaq e Ahsan) even the single talaq becomes irrevocable after some period of time not exceeding three months. Both the requisites of instantaneous and irrevocable are subjective notions. At no place is the definition of instantaneous given and absent is a mention on the kind of irrevocability. Is the maximum period of 90 days in talaq e Ahsan not instantaneous when juxtaposed to the years of struggle required to get a divorce decree in family courts all around? Is talaq e Ahsan, which becomes irrevocable after the stipulated timeline not covered under this section?

Moving ahead, Section 4 and 5 are the most disconcerting ones in this proposed act.

DECLARATIONOF TALAQ TO BE VOID AND ILLEGAL

  1. Any pronouncement of talaq by a person upon his wife, by words, either spoken or written or in electronic form or in any other manner whatsoever, shall be void and illegal.
  2. Whoever pronounces talaq referred to in section 3 upon his wife shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and fine.

To a sane man, what puzzles is that how can any law punish an act that has no ramification whatsoever? A murderer is punished for the killing of another human, a robber for the crime of stealing but in the present case there ring no bells. Consider a man pronouncing talaq e biddat, i.e pronouncing triple talaq in one go. After the supreme court ruling, which forms the base for the proposed law, the said triple talaq cannot be counted as three talaqs and is not instantaneously irrevocable. Hence, a man divorcing his wife through talaq either uttering it thrice or once, his talaq will be counted as only one. His talaq will not, under any circumstances, result in three talaqs. The question that arises then is- What does the act wish to punish? Be it noted that a single pronouncement of talaq is still valid and accepted to all Muslims as of this day. Hence, mere divorce by one talaq cannot be a ground to sentence someone for, let alone three years, even a day behind bars.

For an act to amount as a crime are some pre requisite elements that are to be satisfied. First and foremost is that the law of the land should consider it as a crime. That is to be followed by intent, motive and preparation in furtherance of crime. What the proposed law fails to convey on both the counts is simple logic. Firstly it is criminalising an action that cannot materialise. Secondly, it has no where brought mention as to how would this proposed crime be proved and evidenced in the courts of law. Consider a case that a husband utters a single talaq and the wife out of vengeance files a case under this law alleging triple talaq. In the absence of witnesses or written confirmation, will that allegation suffice to send the husband to jail for 3 years?

Section 5 then goes on to speak as if with sense

Without prejudice to the generality of the provisions contained in any other law for the time being in force, a married Muslim woman upon whom talaq is pronounced, shall be entitled to receive from her husband such amount of subsistence allowance for her and dependent children as may be determined by the Magistrate.

However what is being offered now was already provided for under section 125 of CrPc and confirmed by numerous Apex Court judgments. So, even this brings no new relief to the affected women.

The remainder, as can be seen, is boiler plate clauses.

Moreover, for the sake of argument, say a complaint has been registered and the same results in conviction. What it will pictorially end up looking like is as follows:

1) The pronouncement of triple talaq is illegal and void so there will not be any divorce in between the parties howsoever.

2) Despite that, the husband will be sentenced to three years in jail thereby depriving him conjugal company. The wife and husband both live in seclusion.

3) The husband may then also be liable to pay fine as well as maintenance to the wife.

Now, the bill amidst this hullabaloo, fails to convince on logical grounds why this law is nothing more than one intended to gain political mileage, rhetoric mongering and overzealous attitude intended to sober the ‘other’ section of the community rather than intended for betterment of the exploited section for which it is purported to materialize. The repeated comparison of other Muslim countries may not be wrong per SE. Many countries consider triple talaq invalid but in no country does one find penal attraction. Also marriage, being civil contract under Islamic law in particular and other laws in general, ought not have criminal laws to govern and penalize husbands for the dissolution of the same. It appears, so long as the government enjoys the narrow nationalistic frenzy and is driven by this wronged motive of reining in the ‘other’ section of the community; laws of this grade should not be nonplussing.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here