Boycotting Compulsory Attendance Is Not Boycotting Classes : JNU Students Question Compulsory Attendance Rule

0
135
PC: Samim Asgor Ali

A circular dated 22nd December 2017 issued by Jawaharlal Nehru University administration which enforces compulsory attendance from Winter Semester 2018 onward has sparked a debate around questions of learning and academics, both within the campus and beyond. Subsequent circulars have repeated and emphasized this new rule.

The student community of the campus has shown a great deal of resistance towards these circulars and the enforcement of such an arbitrary measure. Under the leadership of current students union (JNUSU), the student community has experimented with all possible modes of struggle to roll back the compulsory attendance policy. Apart from the sustained boycott of signing attendance registers, a form of protest which continues, student community undertook other forms of struggle as well, for example: visiting the administration block as a mass delegation to the Vice Chancellor with the slogan Hazir Janaab, a total university lock-down,various protest marches, school level strikes and even the blockade of the admin block. Meanwhile, another circular dated 10th Jan 2018 which mentions the modalities of signing the compulsory attendance register for BA, MA, M.Sc, M.Tech, MPH, PG Diploma and MPhil and PhD course work.

PC: Samim Asgor Ali

Consistently, students have shown resistance through boycotting attendance with a consistent demand of ‘roll-back compulsory attendance policy’. Many General Body Meetings (GBMs) happen at center and school level with the coordination of JNUSU SFCs (Student Faculty Committees) and Councillors of their respective schools. Many centers have unanimously resolved to boycott compulsory attendance by not signing in the attendance register. Observing this, the JNU admin came up with another circular dated 22nd Jan 2018, which expressed concern over the non-implementation of compulsory attendance in centers/schools/special centers. The circular ordered mandatory implementation of the circular related to compulsory attendance – every student and research scholar has to maintain 75% of attendance, and research scholars have to sign the attendance register every working day. The circular came with a warning about the consequences of not following this system: reduction in grades if any student/research scholar fails to achieve the 75% of attendance. On 8th February 2018, JNU admin came up with new sets of ‘threats’ for those who don’t fulfill the prescribed percentage of attendance like the stopping of non-net fellowships, scholarships, not allowing to write end-term exams and not allowing to register for next semester.

All the above mentioned circulars referred to a ‘committee constituted to frame the modalities for the attendance system of the students’ as a ‘competent authority’. As is well known and established, the Academic Council (AC) is the decision making body of the university, which has the authority to decide such issues, through a set procedure, series of meetings, and proper procedure. So, on what basis has such a ‘competent authority’ has been formed? As per the reporting of the JNUSU which is part of the AC, attendance was not even an agenda in the last AC meeting and Vice Chancellor of the University has bypassed the AC (which he has consistently done on previous accounts as well) to introduce compulsory attendance system for all the students. Apart from JNUSU, one of the AC members Madhu Purnima Kishwar[1] also tweeted on 17th Feb 2018, “I planned 2 raise this matter in #JNU Academic Council meeting of 23 Feb. But since VC has postponed it indefinitely, I may as well clarify that the AC DID NOT pass any resolution regarding compulsory attendance. This issue was not an agenda item. It cropped up accidentally[2]”. This shows how arbitrary the circular of compulsory attendance is. In a meeting with VC of JNU with the JNUSU, JNU VC stated the reasons: 1) compulsory attendance is a part of IIT and JNU should adopt their model 2) attendance is required to identity and help “weak” students[3].

Many questions have been raised in the public about this incessant demand of JNU students to oppose compulsory attendance. While some have yet again dismissed it as the whims and fancies of a group of people “living off tax payers” money, others have pointed to the apparent unwillingness of students to study, who are then deemed to be only interested in doing politics, living comfortably in this campus, and/or generally opposing any rule that emerges from the administration. This is not the case. In fact, the opposition against attendance is vital in order for us to understand what really constitutes education, learning and experience. It is not merely the improper implementation of a policy or the bypassing of laws and rules by the JNU Vice Chancellor. It is about a deeper rot in education which, instead of being addressed, is being papered over by such measures that do nothing to deepen the meaning of education itself, or address questions of equity, access and quality.

Does implementation of attendance policy enhance learning?

There are various studies which state how attending the classes enhances the learning of the student. But these studies do not seek repressive rules and punishments as an answer to abstenteeism. As Luca Stanca argues, a captive audience destroys the atmosphere of learning; similarly, compulsory attendance system would take away quality teaching. The solution to high levels of absenteeism is not compulsory attendance rather improvement of teaching, both in terms of content and format[1]. Attendance in the class is dependent on the motivation level of a student; the motivation can be enhanced by the teacher and ensuring positive contribution of a student in the class. Compulsory attendances without any motivation do more harm rather than good. Clair argues:

Attending class arises from a decision which is influenced by motivational beliefs and class context. By making class attendance compulsory, students can lose their feeling of control, begin to feel bad about their decision to enroll in college, and may decide there are more important things to do than attend class. There is limited opportunity, then, to even discover whether the context is enjoyable or not. An enjoyable class, however, does not guarantee high academic achievement because students may not feel capable of being successful. In addition, enjoyable does not mean the same as valuable. Under these circumstances, a compulsory attendance policy can do more harm than good[1].

MacFarlane moves beyond motivational factor for attending the class and argues in favour of academic freedom which is beyond class room and critical interaction with the text. He also argues that compulsory attendance policy infantilise the adults of the University. It is a culture which treats students of the university as children rather than adults. He argues:

The emphasis on attendance at class in modern university contexts risks hollowing out the importance of student rights as learners despite the rhetoric of modern learning theory adopted by most higher education institutions that more emphasis is placed on ‘learning’ rather than ‘teaching’[2].

Is ‘boycotting attendance’ = boycotting classes?

As I mentioned, on social media there is also a discourse that, these JNUites do not want to attend classes, and want to merely do politics while eating tax payers’ money. On the contrary, students are attending the classes, critically engaging with the teachers and proactively participating in the seminars, tutorials, writing term papers and writing sessionals. So, where does the problem lie? JNU has a system of continuous comprehensive evaluating system. Apart from these systems, students also participate in the various talks (including mess and dhabas) and centre-level weekly and fortnightly seminars delivered by the experts to enhance their intellect. So, the problem is not attending the classes. There is only this unsubstantiated and poorly backed up demand to make students sign daily registers, further increasing the surveillance levels on the campus, where the only ‘right’ kind of education students are accessing is the one decided by the administration. This is a multi-layered move to not just limit political engagement, field work, out-of-classroom spaces, and instead, create and establish a monolithic idea of what education looks like. Further, this is little to no conversation around the repercussions of such a move on certain groups of students. The move was apparently justified by pointing to ‘weak students’ – but this move will only further target the already marginalised groups on this campus. As women students of the campus have written, they will certainly be hard hit by this move. Many come to universities against the wishes of their families, stay outside campuses because of lack of hostels, and in some cases, are even bringing up their children (sometimes single-handedly) as they pursue their higher education. Pursing field work and archival research, merely travelling to campus everyday in order to sign a register is financially prohibitive and adds to the already difficult scenarios in the lives of many students as they try to reach these higher educational institutions and then survive in them all the way up to their PhDs. Similarly, differently able students will also be affected by this move. Many of our campuses are already exceedingly unfriendly to differently able students. Moreover, the demand to come mark your attendance every day, physically, is not something that can be taken on by everyone, and should not be taken on at all. Many students who live outside campus, are teaching in already insecure ad-hoc positions, while writing their theses, will also be forced to comply to this rule, adding further strain. Overall, the rule – backed by no real logic or discussion – only enhances the culture of policing and controlling, while putting at risk many groups of students and research scholars, who have with much difficulty and work reached this campus.

Prof. Rajat Datta[3] Says:

The fact is that students in JNU are expected to attend; and they do. In fact, students spilling out of classrooms, sitting on floors, or standing during lectures because all seats are occupied by their colleagues is a common sight in the campus. Come to any seminar or conference, and the most enthusiastic and informed participants there are the students who attend each and every session with almost religious fervour. Attending classes in JNU is participative, and it is this which makes it a self-enforced ‘compulsion’[4].

On the contrary to this professor Makarand Paranjpe argues there should be accountability and autonomy in the process of learning. He argues referring to Aurobindo:

“The mind has to be consulted in its own growth.” This injunction of Sri Aurobindo I have found not just useful, but accurate, especially as we get into the subtler dimensions of transformative learning[5].

Professor Paranjpe failed to understand is the present circular of attendance is not closely related to the ideals of Sri Aurobindo rather the circular is arbitrary and bypassed from AC members. Secondly, there is no such data related to absenteeism; rather, classes and seminar halls over flow with the students.

Conclusion

The prominent reasons presented for compulsory attendance by the administration is ‘supporting weak students’. Who are these weak students? As Prof. Kishwar says, Some teachers expressed concern about poor performance of SC/ST students despite special classes organised for them. In that context some teachers pointed out that poor performance was related to students not attending even regular classes, leave alone avail special coaching. What is the basis for this claim? Is there any data with the administration or those teachers who claims ‘poor performance of SC/ST’? If the JNU Administration is so concerned about marginalised students, then why did it implement UGC Gazette 2016 which scuttled reservation, introduced 100% Viva Voce, a massive seat cut and cancellation of deprivation points?

References:

[1] Kishwar was nominated by JNU Vice Chancellor M Jagadesh Kumar last year to represent the School of Arts and Aesthetics (SAA) as an expert from outside the varsity for two years.

https://www.indiatoday.in/pti-feed/story/jnu-academic-council-didnt-pass-compulsory-attendance-resolution-madhu-kishwar-1172008-2018-02-18

[2] https://twitter.com/madhukishwar

[3]Reporting by Shubhanshu Singh (Jt Sec JNUSU) https://www.facebook.com/subhanshu2106/posts/1686360771384149

[4] Stanca (2006)

[5] Clair (1999)

[6] MacFarlane (2013)

[7] Dr. Rajat Datta is a professor at Centre for Historical Studies, JNU

[8]https://thewire.in/224503/jnu-attempt-enforce-surveillance-students-teachers-alike/

[9]http://www.dnaindia.com/analysis/column-jnu-attendance-imbroglio-what-is-really-at-stake-2585403/amp?__twitter_impression=true

Other References:

https://www.indiatoday.in/pti-feed/story/jnu-academic-council-didnt-pass-compulsory-attendance-resolution-madhu-kishwar-1172008-2018-02-18

https://www.facebook.com/subhanshu2106/posts/1686360771384149

https://twitter.com/madhukishwar

https://thewire.in/224503/jnu-attempt-enforce-surveillance-students-teachers-alike/

http://www.dnaindia.com/analysis/column-jnu-attendance-imbroglio-what-is-really-at-stake-2585403/amp?__twitter_impression=true

Luca Stanca (2006), The Effects of Attendance on Academic performance, The Journal of Economic Education, Vol.37, No.3

Karen.L.St.Clair (1999), A case against compulsory class attendance policies in Higher Education, Innovative Higher Education, Vol.23, No.3

Bruce Macfarlane (2013), The surveillance of learning, Higher education Quaterly, Vol.10 No.11

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here