Growing up, secularism as a word always meant multiplicity; an open embracing of identities. Perhaps it was the pledge in school assembly that started with “All Indians are my brothers and sisters”; to be Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Sikh never seemed to conflict with the “Indian” in us; just like how brothers and sisters differ and quarrel yet find the greatest comfort in each other. Now this wasn’t because we just happened to find ourselves in the same landmass governed by the same state. Instead, secularism was to embrace the differences, without patronizing but appreciatively understanding each as rightly holding their own in a country whose special constitution gave them full legal charge. As children, surely we didn’t suddenly conjure into existence some textbook definition of a ‘citizen’ when we thought of ourselves as Indians; as a matter of fact it was the collective marvel for monuments[1], temples, mosques, gurudwaras and cathedrals that made our chests swell in pride when we thought of beauty and culture and patriotism – which ironically has turned into fuel for the raging extremist[2].
Now when I’m presented with a dictionary definition that calls secularism a “belief that religion should not play a role in government, education, or other public parts of society[3],” it very much conflicts with my own experience of secularism in India.
Before dissecting my thoughts on what this experience of secularism is all about, I would like to point out an interesting flaw, or should I call it a Freudian slip, in this seemingly myth-proof definition of secularism. Panikkar in his insightful discourse on faith, called out the myth-centric connotation of the word ‘belief’ which he propounds is placed in the feeling of having faith in something[4]. So, by this definition, understood in the light of Panikkar’s suggested model, ‘secularism’ would mean putting faith in institutions that are supposedly outside the realm of ‘faith’, although I cannot see how ‘education’ and ‘public’ parts of society can be separated from the philosophies of religion or spirituality and related schools of thought. The irony almost seems deliberate, I imagine the authors chuckling darkly when they thought of how their definition would be brandished by evangelists (ahem) of secularism, only to quite certainly fail on epistemic scrutiny.
So I think it’s important to draw attention to these loopholes in the intellectual sources of secularism as understood by certain people who clearly don’t share the same socio-cultural contexts as we experience in India. While expounders of this separatist model of secularism are most certainly entitled to their opinion, we couldn’t settle for its universalism when we as Indians, or people from a specific part of India, or for that matter people from any geography in the world, don’t recognize it in our own societal experiences.
Given the validity of our lived differences, should we limit our understanding and force ourselves to work within the premise that components of faith are indeed separable from the public life of state and government? Or could one argue that the application is purely practical and comes handy while making decisions of societal development where superstitions could hamper the well-being of citizens?
I would like to approach these questions in the perspective of ‘multiple identities’, as I first described in my introduction on what secularism meant to me as a child, which to a large measure remains the same. To explain exactly how I understood this beyond theory, I indulge myself with an incident from back in college. Things couldn’t have shocked some of my relatives more when I got my eyebrows pierced with silver studs. From questioning my (degenerate) moral standards to the parental skills of my mum and dad, I noticed that much of the vitriol revolved around my being a “pastor’s daughter” strutting around with this most unholy object.
I remember thinking how absurd it was that they saw me mostly, or rather only, as a pastor’s daughter when I was so many other things as well – guitarist in a rock band and published author, all conducive for some experiment with style I would say. In fact, I hadn’t even thought of it as an act of rebellion until someone accused me with such confidence.
My views on multiplicity of individual identity have been time again affirmed, expanded and enlightened by Indian economist and philosopher Amartya Sen. The professor has deconstructed what would otherwise be an abstract notion by explaining that “a person’s citizenship, residence, geographic origin, gender, class, politics, profession, employment, food habits, sports interests, tastes in music, social commitments, [religion] etc. makes us members of a variety of groups. Each of these collectives, to all of which this person belongs, gives her a particular identity. None of them can be taken to be the person’s [only] identity or singular membership category.”[5]
He then goes on to validify that these identifies could be accentuated at different spaces and times: “The freedom to determine our loyalties and priorities between the different groups to all of which we may belong is a peculiarly important liberty which we have reason to recognize, value, and defend.”
Now is it likely that we board up our ‘religious’ self somewhere in the dark attics of our minds while putting on our governance related ‘public’ and education-centric hats? Even if we still believe the practical applications make it possible, it is absurd to think that our decisions are independent of these multiple associations and mental models. All along, it is the entirety of our perspectives that form whatever practical, non-superstitious public lives we want to perpetuate. The sooner we acknowledge the holistic nature of human activity as interlinked between politics, economics, religion and governance, the more chances I believe we have of building less extremist systems in the state.
My contention is that living unreal definitions of ‘citizenship’ and ‘secularism’ creates illusions that fester into harmful fundamental forces. We may be shocked at some of the extremist groups rampaging across our country today, but we must remember that we are complicit by virtue of either remaining silent or not speaking out – being politically, spiritually and culturally complacent that puts up no resistance, or, subscribing to cold definitions of how human beings should live that creates the inertia perpetuating the explosion of fundamental forces.
How to be ‘secular’ as a person of faith:
I’ve put across why I think of a secularist state or government as one that is comfortable with the aggregation of different religions, rather than a sharp separation of religion and state even by definition. Now I shall explore my own experiences of living this secularism, at a personal level, which I believe are quite unique to the Indian context. I have further filtered this perspective as a person of the Christian faith and how I can relate with people from other faiths in India, even extended to neighboring Asian countries in some instances.
Recently, I accompanied two friends to Tirumala, a famous Hindu pilgrim spot. In keeping with their vows, we walked the entire distance barefoot across seven hills right up to the temple’s inner sanctuary. All the while, I was filled with a mystical ecstasy by observing the expressions of devotion around me, and somehow I was filled with the thought of Jesus’s long walk of pain and loving sacrifice up the hill of Calvary. It was no less a pilgrimage for me as I trudged up with conviction that my own God would be waiting for me atop the hill.
There have been many other similar experiences when the piety of a person from another religion has kindled and strengthened my own faith as a Christian. While I do acknowledge that some people may justify the apparent “dangers” of such free-flowing spirituality and theology, I am always reminded of a lecture by Professor Abshar Abdalla, an Indonesian Muslim scholar, at a conference held by the World Council of Churches. When asked about what irked him most while engaging in inter-religious dialogue, he said it was when one section began with a conviction that their beliefs are the ultimate truth to which other faiths must be argued into seeing.
The arguments are complex but for me faith has always been a point, rather a sweet spot, when everything conflicting within an individual finally converges to make real and complete sense. For me, it is in the life and work of Jesus, while my friends from other religions would draw strength from their own understanding of faith. It is this convergence of meaning and motives that I believe our Secular India should start working towards, quite different from dilution or dismissal of faith discourses which form a large part of our politics and cultures.
And as Gandhi famously put it, “our innermost prayer should be that a Hindu should become a better Hindu, a Muslim a better Muslim, and a Christian a better Christian.” I would even qualify that a person from another faith often makes me a better Christian and that’s my secularism.
Notes
[1] Here my use of religious constructions is only for the direct benefit of this essay’s theme, although the purpose extends to other spheres of heritage such as science, discoveries, literature and so on.
[2] BJP MLA Sangeet Som’s comment on Taj Mahal as a “blot on Indian culture”…built by “traitors.” http://www.firstpost.com/india/sangeet-soms-remarks-on-taj-mahal-betray-his-ignorance-about-history-frustration-with-bjp-leadership-4148643.html
[3] Mirriam-Webster Dictionary, also see: Oxford Dictionaries: “The principle of separation of the state from religious institutions.”
[4] R Panikkar. ‘Myth, Faith and Hermeneutics’, page 5.
[5] Amartya Sen. “Identity And Violence”. Penguin India. Page 5.

