Al Ghazali And Intellectual Ethics

0
282

“He, to whom the evil of his conduct is made alluring, so that he looks upon it as good” – The Quran (35:8)

The Medieval Muslim intellectual Al-Ghazali cites this segment from the Quran while discussing the vice of pride in his magnum opus ‘The Revivification of the Religious Sciences’ (Ihya). Al Ghazali makes the case that this particular kind of pride is most difficult to cure, because a person who deems his/her own view to be undoubtedly true could hardly be troubled to lend their ear to another’s view. Even if they do bother listening, they would nevertheless be hard-pressed to abandon what they consider to be the absolute and saving truth.

Al Ghazali entertains the possibility that contrary to popular sentiment, absolute conviction may not always be virtuous. It may often be nothing more than a veneer for an underlying insecurity and lack of intellectual confidence. Being absolutely certain of one’s opinion for reasons of personal sentiment and prejudice hardly befits a sound and sincere mind. Al Ghazali draws attention to the fact that practices of rationalizing and philosophizing may very well lose their way if overpowered by an untamed pride. And finally, the medieval scholar suggests some habits of mind as therapy against the disease of intellectual pride:

1. Begin with the presupposition that one’s own personal sentiment is often little more than an arbitrary preference or prejudice, which in itself is unworthy of any intellectual merit- let alone being something to pride oneself over.

‘Hich’, a Farsi word meaning “nothing”, found inscribed in Turkish, Iranian, and Central Asian Sufi tekkes.

2. One’s certainty or conviction may only be justified when it has been established not on an arbitrary intellectual inkling, but by systematic reasoning following the rules of logic or by the systematic study of scripture and its sciences.

As the devil Mephistopheles in Goethe’s Faust impresses upon a student who had come to him for academic advice:

“Make good use of your time! It hurries past,

But order and method make time last.

So, friend, take my advice to heart:

Hear lectures on Logic for a start.”

3. Like Mephistopheles, Al Ghazali insists that the attending of lectures, and systematic and disciplined study under scholars and specialists of various fields, is the surest way of proceeding in an orderly manner. And this prolonged pain-staking endeavor serves as the perfect antidote to the enthusiastic ego that is only overcome with joy at the prospect of associating itself with fancy philosophers and pompous jargon.

4. As for those who cannot meet the demands of academic integrity and rigor – which entails nothing less than an entire lifetime in the ardent pursuit of knowledge – they must at least learn to do no harm: to not speak of what one cannot take the pains to know. It is best to know one’s limits and to defer to the authorities in areas that one does not have mastery over.

Now, this last point may leave one with the impression that Al Ghazali encourages blind belief in authority and stands against independent thinking. But before one jumps to any conclusion, one must take stock of the complete oeuvre of a scholar. Alas, such a monumental undertaking is certainly not the aim of this article. We need only examine a few pointers from Al Ghazali’s work to begin appreciating the complexity of his thought on the issue.

As Ebrahim Moosa, an expert on Al Ghazali, asks: “Can we seriously entertain the idea that a scholar who not only underwent dramatic changes in his life, but also self-consciously reconstructed himself, was not untouched by his life experiences?”

One has to merely read his brief autobiographical account in ‘Deliverance from Error’ (Munqidh) to learn how this Muslim intellectual was famously besotted by doubt, owing to the plethora of views in the intellectual marketplace. Al Ghazali’s intellectual milieu was composed of various trends and traditions such as the literalists, the people of dialectical theology (kalam), the philosophers, the Sufis and the ultra-esoteric Shia Ismailis. And each group demanded allegiance to themselves based solely on their authority without providing any compelling reason for such loyalty.

Amidst such a cacophony of convictions, Al Ghazali questioned conviction itself. He saw that each person is born without these affiliations, and that it were social contexts that determined what beliefs a person would come to hold in life. As the Prophet said, each person is born pure of nature, and it is only society that later makes him either a Jew or a Christian or a Muslim.

Thus, accident of birth alone wasn’t justification enough for one’s belief – otherwise everyone would be equally justified to uphold whatever beliefs they inherited from their forefathers.

Al Ghazali was deeply disturbed by these sociological facts. And ultimately, he sought reconciliation in the process of taking himself to task for all his inherited beliefs. By subjecting everything he had learnt to doubt, and objectively examining all competing views with equal respect and attention, he attempted to reconstruct the foundations of belief and establish conviction on a solid footing.

One may get a glimpse of what this process might have been like from Al Ghazali’s own suggestions found in his ‘Canon of Interpretation’ (Qanun at tawil). Al Ghazali suggests keeping the following in mind, when pondering an interpretation:

  1. Not everything is within one’s reach, and not everything is instantly understandable.
  2. Do not abandon reason. Reason is the vetting agent for everything that we do.
  3. Where there are multiple meanings, persist with the multiplicity and the ambiguity. Settling for one meaning on an issue would effectively deprive it of the richness offered by the rest of its meanings.

This ambiguity is best captured in a term perhaps subconsciously employed by al Ghazali in his autobiographical account, where he speaks of the idea of inhabiting an intellectual and spiritual ‘Dihliz‘. Linguistically, this word stands for the space between the house proper and the outside street. And intellectually, the Dihliz-ian space represents a liminal space – a threshold – a transition chamber. It is the critical intermediate space between outside and inside, between exoteric (zahir) and esoteric (batin). The Dihliz is where exiles and strangers from various traditions can share residence. And it is precisely this in-between space, that needs to be cultivated for an honest intellectual negotiation with the antinomies and polarities of our existence. In order to inhabit the Dihliz, one must not be shy to welcome the discomfort of conflict, the pain of disillusionment and the unease of unknowing. To bear fruit, one must bear the opposition of contraries within oneself and resist all temptation of an easy resolution. For any proposed ‘solution’ to the complexity of the human condition, is often nothing more than a euphemism for justifying the dominance of one narrative over all the rest.

This intellectual effort of patiently holding opposites within one’s intellect without premature judgement or commitment is almost a spiritual practice in itself. One that demands working devoutly while being creatively free. But one cannot enter the Dihliz in a dogmatic frame of mind. Thus, al Ghazali counsels at the end of his Mizan al Amal (Balance of Deeds):

“Avoid the [subjective] authority of [discredited] discursive traditions or collectivities (madhāhib). Seek instead the truth by way of inquiry so that you yourself become one who holds an authoritative viewpoint (ṣāḥib madhhab). And do not be in a position where you follow a guide like a blind person, who ostensibly directs you on a path, whereas you are surrounded by a thousand guides similar to yours; each warns that your guide will lead you to peril and mislead you! Only at the end [when you act on your decision to follow your guide], will you realize the error of your guide. Therefore, there is no salvation except in independence (istiqlāl) [of thought].

Forget all you’ve heard and clutch what you see. At sunrise what use is Saturn to thee?

If writing these words yields no other outcome save to make you doubt your inherited beliefs, compelling you to inquire, then it was worth it. Doubt transports [you] to the truth. Who does not doubt fails to inquire. Who does not inquire fails to gain insight. Without insight, you remain blind and perplexed. We therefore seek God’s protection from such a [wretched] result.”

Note from author: This post had been previously published as a loose translation of a passage from Al Ghazali’s Ihya Uloom ad Deen. But it immediately became obvious to the author that a single passage from Al Ghazali’s work may be an unfair representation of the thought of such a complex thinker. Peer review from other The Companion writers confirmed these suspicions and created the need for introducing more nuance into the picture: hence the revised article.

Further Reading:

Al Ghazali, ‘Deliverance from Error’, translated by R.J.McCarthy (Fons Vitae, 2001)

Ibn Qudama al Maqdisi, ‘Mukhtasar Minhaj ul Qasideen’ (being an abridgement of the Ihya Uloom ad Deen)

Salazar, Abdul Latif. ‘Al Ghazali: the Alchemist of Happiness’ (Documentary, 2004)

Moosa, Ebrahim. ‘Abu Hamid al Ghazali’ in ‘Islamic Legal Thought: A Compendium of Muslim Jurists’, Edited by Oussama Arabi, David S. Powers and Susan A. Spectorsky (BRILL, 2013) Moosa, Ebrahim. ‘Al Ghazali and the Poetics of Imagination’ (UNC Press, 2006)

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here