“There was this pregnant woman. I slit her open.” – India: The Modi Question
The recent two-part documentary series by the BBC has been a cause of célèbre ever since its release. The documentary reveals a never-before-published report that a British inquiry team had sent to the United Kingdom government. Its release in India has seen mixed receptions, some support, some doubt, and some aversion. The most striking of it all though has been the ruling government’s response to the documentary. The documentary prompted a vehement response from the government, which has described the documentary as “a propaganda piece designed to push a particular discredited narrative”. Days after the release of the documentary, Twitter and YouTube were ordered to take down content providing links to the documentary which led to tweets of about 50 people being blocked. Opposition leaders criticized the government for the clampdown; Mahua Moitra took to Twitter and shared an archived link to the documentary saying, “Sorry, Haven’t been elected to represent the world’s largest democracy to accept censorship. Here’s the link. Watch it while you can.” On the other hand, the External Affairs Ministry has alleged that the documentary pushed a discredited narrative, calling it a propaganda piece that smacked of a “continuing colonial mindset”. With all the opposing opinions on the content of the documentary, what is equally as important is discussing the censorship and resistance surrounding it, especially in university spaces.
The documentary has been screened in various universities and colleges by youth organizations and student bodies albeit to, at best, dissent, and at worst, detainment. It was screened at the University of Hyderabad, multiple colleges in Kerala, and Jadavpur University in Kolkata. At Delhi University, multiple students were detained, the power supply was disconnected and section 144 was imposed ahead of the documentary screening by students’ organizations. JNU, Jamia Millia Islamia, Punjab University, and Presidency College, among others, saw similar reactions from the authorities. On one hand, there were allegations of attempts by students to disturb the peace of the area; on the other hand, different student organizations were seen asking “Why have the students of Jamia been detained 20 km from Jamia Campus? Why are they being denied access to their phones? If the Supreme Court has proven the Prime Minister to be innocent, then why is the government afraid of the film?” At the Central University of Rajasthan, about 10 students were suspended from their college and hostels after members of the ABVP released the list of the students who had gathered together and watched the documentary on their devices. What wrong students who watch a documentary-which has not even been banned in the country- on their own devices have done that led to their suspension is a question that looms over us. Why no action was taken towards ABVP members of the same college who barged into the hostels of the suspended students- in a college where students from one hostel aren’t allowed to enter another- threatened and raised violent derogatory slogans against them is also a question that looms over us. These, amongst many others, are questions that we must demand answers for.
It is instances like these that render one doubtful of the freedom of expression and the gist of ‘open discussion’ that universities in our country claim to provide as democratic spaces. India, in recent years, has seen a steady decline in its citizens’ freedom of expression, more so in academic spaces. Amnesty International in 2017 warned of a similar decline in a statement where they said that “intimidation and threats continue to restrict free speech on university campuses.” A report on Academic Freedom in India published by professors at Delhi and Ambedkar University in 2020 similarly states that since 2014 India “has seen an unprecedented assault on academic freedom as well as on academics.” It seems as though political parties are uncomfortable with, if not insecure about, independent voices and critical evaluations that could come from universities. Another threat to academic freedom that has similarly seen a stark increase in recent years is the interference by the government and other non-academic bodies in what is taught inside the classroom. Lack of freedom of open discussion of opposing ideals, leaking of data of students that dare speak against the government, changes in the academic curriculum made without consulting the teaching body, exercising of power by the state governments in appointments of vice-chancellors, faculty, and other staff have all become common in recent times. Campuses have been turned into spheres of influence for political parties. These repeated occurrences negate the essential concept of universities as autonomous spaces, where freedom of expression is an integral part of the learning process. One is left to wonder whether our democratic university spaces are really that democratic after all.
Amidst all the censorship, a query that most people have had is how democratic the process of blocking certain kinds of media from the general public is. Let us take a closer look at the same. The directions to take down links to the documentary were issued by the Ministry of Information and Broadcast, invoking emergency powers under Rule 16 of IT Rules, 2021, and Section 69A of the IT Act, 2000. Under Rule 16, an authorized officer can examine the content in question and submit a written recommendation to the secretary of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, post which any content on the Internet can be blocked “without providing the content/intermediary an opportunity to be heard.” The rule says that in case of an emergency, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting can ban public access to any information or part of it through any computer resource as an “interim measure”. “The Authorised Officer, at the earliest but not later than forty-eight hours of the issue of direction under sub-rule (2), shall bring the request before the Committee for its consideration and recommendation,” the rules further specify. However, there is no clarity on the process of reviewing the ban, which is crucial for a ban that is imposed with no due process. In this case, there is also no report on whether such a request for consideration was even brought before the Committee two days after the links to the documentary were taken down. All we now see are more and more links to the documentary being taken down, students being detained, and many even being harassed.
It is also to be noted that the concerned IT rules were only recently introduced under the current government. Moreover, two clauses in these IT rules have been stayed by the Madras High Court, which has said that the oversight mechanism prescribed in the rules appears to be aimed “at controlling the media by the government.” For a country whose Press Freedom Index dropped from Rank 142 to Rank 150 in just a year, this is an issue of utmost concern. Further, the Internet Freedom Foundation has stated that “several requirements under the act suffer from unconstitutionality and undermine the free expression and privacy for millions of internet users in India.” The IFF claims that when a post is ordered to be censored by the government, there is no way for the public to know why the post has been asked to be censored. The way to the BBC documentary being blocked has not been officially mentioned either. Sure, the government has called the documentary a propaganda piece, but do we as citizens not have the right to watch the documentary and decide for ourselves? If all ‘propaganda pieces’ are to be banned, what about movies like ‘The Kashmir Files and ‘Why I Killed Gandhi’, which have been claimed to be propaganda pieces by multiple parties? When ‘The Kashmir Files’ was released, the Prime Minister had said, and we quote, “Instead of assessing the film on the basis of facts, a campaign is on to discredit it.
The entire ecosystem opposes anyone who dares to show the truth. He tried to depict what he thought was the truth. But there is the reluctance to understand or accept the truth. The conspiracy for the last 5-6 days is to ensure no one sees the truth. My issue is not this film but bringing out the truth for the good of the country. There can be many aspects of truth and different views. Those who think it is not correct can make their own film, but they are shocked that the truth that they tried to suppress is now coming out with the backing of facts and efforts.” Can the same not be said about the documentary? And so, yet another question arises- is ‘India: The Modi Question’ a controversy because it seeks to defame the governing body and increase tensions in the country? Or because it seeks to bring into light the truths of the deeds done by the governing body, deeds that have been covered up? We leave it for you to conclude.

