On 30th April 2018 Satish Gautam BJP MP from Aligarh in a letter to the vice chancellor of the Aligarh Muslim university (AMU) asked to explain the ‘compulsion’ of putting Jinnah’s portrait inside the student’s union hall. AMU students defended the portrait saying it was installed much before the partition and Mashkoor Usmani, President of the student’s union called him ‘the hero of undivided India’ according to The Times Of India report.
On 2nd may 2018 a student, Sharjeel Usmani wrote, “15 Sanghi goons enter AMU campus with pistols and revolvers, accompanied by a policeman in uniform. They attack a student who was passing by. Students’ Union and other students’ leaders come to rescue. 6 goons are caught and are handed over to police. The police has released those 6 goons and is not ready to file an FIR.” Just a few moments later some AMU students including SU president were injured as UP police began to lathicharge the students protesting the right wing group’s entry into the campus premises.” A function to confer former vice president Hamid Ansari a life membership of the students’ union was called off after the two protests”, reports Jantaka reporter.
The hero-worshipers of Nathuram Godse, the assassin of the father of the nation Mahatma Gandhi (whose portrait is hanging on the same wall as that of Jinnah’s portrait), shall not surprise us in future if they demand removal of Mahatma’s portrait too from the union hall. Since according to them he played a big role in partition and so is true for Nehru and others, all of whom we pay tribute to, on every independence day along with our Prime Minister who apparently represents a secular nation by hoisting the national flag on republic days but feels proud to be a member of the organization whose headquarter has not witnessed a single hoisting ceremony of the national flag since its establishment.
There are countless arguments, facts and evidences to distort those who are, just like their predecessors, willing to ‘try’ once more to destabilize the prestigious institution, a task that their ‘gurus’ are in a desperate need to fulfill, but sadly it is of no use to unleash that Sawarkar, their ideological master wrote about 6 letters of apology to the then British govt. when along with many other patriotic freedom fighters he was taken to the police custody. It is of no use to ask why Golwalkar, another prominent Hindutva ideologue vehemently opposed the adoption of tricolor as national flag because it represents the ‘secular credential’ of the country, the acts of defying constitution, ethos and spirit of this nation goes on by the very ‘hyper-nationalist’ forces who are questioning ‘our’ loyalty to this land which explicitly requires no proof.
The fact that India has had strained relations with Pakistan since former’s independence and latter’s establishment, does not encompass the pre-independence scenario and more particularly the year of installment of this portrait i.e. 1938, the stage where Muslim league did not even appear to have a concept of the two nation theory. Therefore it is obvious that being a donor and founder-member of the university court he was traditionally granted a life membership of the students union in an ‘undivided India’. If one goes by the trajectory of hyper-nationalists, then Jinnah house at Mumbai’s Malabar coast which is a huge revenue source to the state must be abolished too, but that won’t happen simply because their agenda does not fit there.
It is ridiculous, even to imagine (but not impossible) that there is all probability that anyone of these goons would come back again in future with just as absurd demands—of demolition of historical and heritage sites, of changing the name and status of the institution, since it “represents partition” according to them. All in all one can’t imagine how far these illogical arguments may go.
The only thing that this commotion intelligibly indicates is the decades old tactic of the ruling party to diverge the attention of mainstream public opinion, attack the minorities, disrupt the law and order situation and sabotage a minority institution, with global prominence, solely for their personal and political gains.



