Home Nationalism Rahul Gandhi Is Wrong In Comparing RSS With MB

Rahul Gandhi Is Wrong In Comparing RSS With MB

782
3
Muslim Brotherhood' s then President of Egypt with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. PC: AsianTribune

As reported in The Telegraph, Rahul Gandhi said on 8th May the Sangh – BJP was taking control of the country just the way the Muslim Brotherhood was in Muslim countries. He further said “The RSS over here and the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, Pakistan, Tunisia and Turkey are doing the same thing.” He said this while addressing a gathering of learned people which included many teachers, retired bureaucrats and police officers as mentioned in The Telegraph’s report “Ready to be PM if Cong biggest Party: Rahul”. More interestingly the above statements are on a reply to a very serious question that how even neighbors were getting divided by politics and religion in India.

Rahul Gandhi is absolutely wrong in his answer to that very serious question which is disturbing every peace loving citizen of this country. Since he is the President of oldest political party of India which also tries to show itself as the biggest secular party, we expect some reasonable and valid answers from him. During the time when ruling party leaders including our Pradhan Sevak are busy in spreading propaganda, wrong history and even providing wrong information at the public rallies and at other official communications, the sane minds of this country desperately want to see a politician who is honest in his knowledge and information.

RSS is a textbook example of fascism and bigotry. If it has to be explained to the people of India that how bad it is – then bring the real examples of bigotry and fascism from around the world. If an honest politician wants to warn the people of India about the dangers of RSS’s nationalism then develop spines to talk about the damages done by the European nationalism and Trump’s nationalism. Rahul Gandhi must have read the basics of RSS and other right wing forces around the world. And I think it would be lamented if he fails to educate his audience about the real problem of RSS. RSS stands for fascism and the best examples of fascism are rule of Italian president Benito Mussolini and Hitler’s rule in Germany. Rahul Gandhi isn’t calling spade a spade. He is actually misinforming his audience about Muslim Brotherhood.

3 COMMENTS

  1. Dear Farhan, you have offered no reasoning for your claim and – like Rahul Gandhi – you have only offered statements.
    It would be more enlightening if you would have built a rational case in support of your view, offering a systematic point-wise comparison of the two groups in question.
    How would you persuade someone who takes the opposite view? – say Rahul Gandhi? You would clearly have to offer more than merely stating your view without offering an argument in favor of it.
    Would love to see such a studied, comparative evaluation from you, if you can offer.
    Best wishes.

  2. Tell how Rahul Gandhi is wrong?
    Don’t You see how MB is trying to politicize islam and its teachings to go beyond the basic responsibilities as a muslim?
    Is Rahul Gandhi wrong is saying that MB uses democracy to contest and win? Which many muslim scholars have said as haraam and shirk?
    Does MB wants to use shirk and kufr democracy to implement shariah?
    Is Rahul Gandhi wrong if he says that MB invigorates muslims towards extremist ideology of implementing shariah without spreading the roots of islam as primary priority?
    Is it not true that many scholars of islam have refuted the ideology of MB and likes of maududi or syed Qutub?
    Political Islam is new concept that was innovated 100 years ago,and if any of the ulema from MB or Jamaat e islami could see the lifestoriez of 4 imams or sahaba or tabbayen no one protested the rulers apart from 4 caliphs of islam.

    Bringing revolutions and uprooting rulers who never stop any muslim from praying or stopping them from following islam is even not recommended in sunnah of , only if you know about the sunnah of propeht pbuh,You would learn.
    Being a non muslim Rahul Gandhi understood it and being a brainwashed muslim you write journals and justify the MB or Jamaat books which should be banned outright.

    https://abuaminaelias.com/islam-forbids-violent-rebellion-against-an-unjust-muslim-ruler/

  3. If Rahul Gandhi is wrong in saying that MB uses democracy and then they change the institutions of democracy,then you prove is it not right that MB and Jamat e islami hind has a goal of establishing shariah based administration using democracy?
    How can MB use democracy which the islamic scholars have defined as shirk,to establish islamic caliphate?
    And who will be the caliph? Will it be a khomeni type caliph? Or from Sufi or from JIH or from some other srct of islam?
    Because the arrival of Caliphs are being dreamt in almost all sects of islam.
    How can JIh unite Shia and other innovated sects on 1 platform with People especially from Ahle Hadeeth?
    How and why JIH or MB has imposed the Responsibility of Allah to establish a Caliphate on itself?
    Does MB and JIH doesn’t read the history of 4 imams of how they were among the rulers who were very tough on them?
    Especially of Ahmed Ibn Hambal who was improsined for the issue of Qalq al Quran? And despite he being severly tortured never advised ummah to revolt?
    Is this polticial islam an innovation by Sayid Qutub and Maududi?
    Explain please

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here