India, world’s largest democracy is going to celebrate the festival of masses, General elections, in mid 2019. Indian people are looking forward to this great opportunity to shape their destiny through this exercise yet again. This time around the challenges seem to be more than before. It is for the first time that sectarian nationalist party, the BJP which came to power in 2014, in alliance with ragtag of opportunist parties, won simple majority for itself. It garnered 31% of seats and 282 Parliamentary seats. The May 2014 elections were contested on the hot pitch with the present Prime Minster, Narendra Modi, contesting with full force, with sky high promises. As we approach the next election we need to do the analysis of Modi rule, so that we can decide as to what is the best option for India in future. In this article we will mostly see the ruling BJP and its merits and demerits during its last over four and half years of rule. The major steps and successes being claimed from this stable about which boast is being made of are Ujwala Yojana (gas subsidy for poor), Make in India, Skill India, Jan Dhan Yojna, health insurance and many similar schemes which had actually made no impact on the problems faced by people.
Modi Comes to Power
The present Government came to power with big promises of reduction in prices of commodities, bringing back of black money; depositing of Rs 15 lakhs in everybody’s account, creation of two crore jobs every year, ending corruption and protection of women in society. However what we have witnessed in society is contrary to the promises made. This has been a period when the policies of government have led to an increase in the prices of commodities, skyrocketing rise in the cost of petrol-diesel, rising unemployment, increase in the number of farmer’s suicide, and worsening of the plight of the average people. During this period the corporate sector has been a big beneficiary of the policies which have led to loot of our resources.
The senseless policy of demonetization led to the death of over 100 people while standing in the queues to withdraw their own money. As such 99.3% of currency notes have come back to the banks. The claims that this will abolish counterfeit currency; will check militancy proved to be more than hollow. The tardy implementation of GST led to a big harassment of small traders and other sections of society. At the same time big businessmen like Sushil Modi, Vijay Mallya, Neerav Modi and Mehul Choksi could escape abroad with crores of public money. It seems the self proclaimed Chowkidar (watchman) Mr. Modi was in deep slumber. The rising unemployment is alarming. The reports show that unemployment has been highest in year 2018. (1) Farmers and workers condition has worsened in recent times. The frequent, regular and costly trips of Prime Minster to other countries had hardly any bettering effect on our relations with outside countries. Our friendly neighbors like Nepal and Sri Lanka are becoming closer to China in recent times. The handling of Kashmir has led to rising discontent as the process of dialogue has been stopped. The dissidence, discontent has been countered by pellet guns, leading to over a thousand people losing their eyesight’s and close to a hundred youth losing their lives. (2)
Fringe Elements or Division of Labor
With the victory of BJP-Modi; the affiliates of RSS, like Bajrang Dal, VHP, ABVP and many such organizations became more assertive and aggressive. They have been taking the law into their hands with impunity. This has led to an increase in the Hate and violence. Hate speech by these organizations, which is frightening the minorities, has been on the rise. A new pattern of processions by ABVP-Bajrang Dal, on motor bikes, carrying tricolors and shouting anti minority slogans, leading to tension as witnessed in Kasganj in UP, has become common. There are open statements against Indian Constitution. One Anantkumar Hegde a Minister in Center stated that ‘BJP is here to change the Constitution’. (3) The politics being pursued by BJP-RSS has harped on Holy Cow, Love Jihad and Ghar Wapasi as major issues. Ghar Wapsi, has been the major campaign in the Adivasi areas and among slum dwellers in cities in particular. The lands of Adivasis is being taken away, their marginalization is on the increase. The propaganda around love jihad has caused the brutal killing of Afrazul by Shambhulal Regar among other acts of violence. He also got it filmed on video. Such an atmosphere has been created that Regar is being looked up as Hero by many.
Intolerance
The policies of the government, the assertion of RSS combine have created an atmosphere of intolerance. After the murder of Dr. Dabholkar, Govind Pansare, M M Kalburgi and Gauri Lankesh were assassinated in similar way. The murder of Ikhlaq, Junaid and many others added to the viciousness in the atmosphere. In the middle of these ‘hate crimes’, writer Uday Prakash and Nayan Tara Sahgal returned their well earned honors. This was followed by eminent scientists, film makers and writers returning their awards. None from the RSS combine came with the appeal or instruction to stop the acts of intolerance like killings; in contrast some of them said ‘award wapasi’ (returning) being done with a political and monetary purpose.
While the real issues of the society remain neglected, the issue of Ram temple has been kept in the forefront, more so when the elections are round the corner. As such the matter is in the court, yet there were claims from the spokesmen of BJP that Ram Temple will be built. Lately VHP and RSS have decided to postpone the issue till after elections. The blunt and aggressive statements on the issue and attitude from RSS combine is leading to an atmosphere of fear, more so among the weaker sections of society and among the religious minorities. This Government; issued the advertisement on the eve of Republic day in 2015, in the ad there was facsimile of preamble of Our Constitution, in which the words Secular and Socialist were missing. With Yogi Adiyanath, as CM, the state Government organized Divali, with actors dressed as Ram and Sita landing in Ayodhya in a helicopter. Same Yogi Adityanath said that Secularism is a big lie of Independent India, showing us the intentions of BJP-RSS is concerned.
The attacks on the character of our universities and education system are going on. We painfully saw the incident of JNU, where by showing a doctored CD; many students were charged with sedition and labeled as anti-Nationals. It was no surprise that police has failed to file the charge sheet of the incident for nearly three years. Court had rejected the plea of State that Kanhaiya Kumar, Anirban and Umar Khalid are anti nationals or need to be given punishment for that. It has created an atmosphere of fear in our educational institutions. After JNU, Aligarh Muslim University is on the target, with targeting some Muslim students as anti-Nationals. The curriculum is being communalized and the BJP leaders are promoting blind faith. They have claimed that there was plastic surgery, internet, genetic engineering, Pushpak Viman in the ancient period. This is an assault on the scientific temper; this is contrary to the directive principles of Indian Constitution which tells us to promote scientific temper and rational thought. (4)
Plight of Dalits
Dalits are getting a rough deal at the hands of this government. Rohith Vemula, the research scholar at Hyderabad Central University was forced to commit suicide as his organization was labeled to be indulging in casteist and anti national activities, Vemula’s scholarship was stopped and he was expelled from the hostel. The Ambedkar Periyar Study Circle was banned in IIT Madras. In Una four dalit youth were mercilessly beaten after stripping them. Young dalit leader Chandrashekhar Ravan was put behind the bars; he implicated and put behind the bars on NSA charges for caste violence in Saharanpur, and was released after nearly one and a half years.
The Kathua rape case and Unnav rape were horrifying. In Kathua BJP took out a rally to support those accused of rape. In Unnav the BJP MLA who was allegedly involved was arrested only after the family of victim threatened to commit suicide in front of Chief Minister’s residence. The issue of Cow, beef, has been projected as one of the major issues. Many lynching’s leading to death of Muslims, on charge of eating or trading of cow has shaken the conscience of society. Around ninety people have been mob lynched. Lynching of Junaid (June 2017) in the outskirts of Delhi, in a train, did come as a saturation point of Cow-beef related violence. To express their anguish people came to streets in great number in a largely spontaneous protest, ‘Not in My name’. While many critics undermined this expression of pain and anguish of the sections of society, it did catch the attention of the national and international media, bringing shame to the image of our country. The result was that our Prime Minister who has been keeping maun (silence) on the issue came forward to make a bland statement.
On the issue of Cow-Beef lynching the data collected by IndiaSpend, based on the content analysis of media reporting tells us that, “Muslims were the target of 51% of violence centered on bovine issues over nearly eight years (2010 to 2017) and comprised 86% of 28 Indians killed in 63 incidents. As many of 97 per cent of these attacks were reported after Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government came to power in May 2014, and about half the cow-related violence — 32 of 63 cases –were from states governed by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) when the attacks were reported, revealed our analysis of violence recorded until June 25, 2017.” (5)
Our society has been accepting plural norms in most of the arena of our life. The issue of cow-beef has added to the intolerance in society, suspicion against dalits and Muslims have gone up due to this. Incidentally BJP has exhibited very hypocritical attitude in matters of Cow-Beef. In North-Eastern states, in Goa and Kerala, it keeps quiet on these matters while in other states it raises the pitch of this topic to polarize the society. Incidentally due to the cow vigilantes now it has become difficult to sell the old cattle, the result is that hoards of cattle are roaming freely damaging the standing crops.
This government came to power on the plank of anti-corruption. The Rafale deal shows how the deal was renegotiated to give higher prices and to give it to Ambani’s recently formed company instead of the much experienced HAL. The documents being unearthed show that PM himself was having parallel negations bypassing the regular procedures. On his instance the number of aircrafts was reduced, price per aircraft was raised and instead of HAL the contract was routed through Anil Ambani’s company which has no experience in the matter.
Threats to Democratic Values
This Government is pro Corporate and is thoroughly communal. It has been making the policies which help big capital at the cost of average people, farmers, Adivasis and Dalits in particular. Modi, BJP are the part of RSS, which is trying to bring in Hindu nation instead of secular democratic India, which is the goal of our freedom movement and Indian Constitution. During last few years the authoritarian attitude of Modi-BJP has interfered in the autonomy of our Central Institutions like Judiciary, CBI, Reserve Bank among others. The influence on education system has been in the form of University recruitment of people on the ground of ideological commitment and not merit. The syllabi of university have been communalized, glorifying Hindu kings and demonizing Muslim kings and labeling Christians as foreigners.
In addition the RSS workers have been making inroads into our institutions and imposing the Hindu nationalist agenda. RSS itself has grown strongly during this period. With BJP coming to power the social divisions along religious lines have been deepened. While other parties have lot of weaknesses and inadequacies they do not push us in the direction of Hindu nation. Many of these parties are not able to confront the Hindu nationalist agenda of RSS-BJP, and show a slight tilt under pressure. The real agenda of Hindu nation is to abolish democracy, do away with Indian Constitution and to establish the hegemony of elite Hindus. BJP-RSS don’t stand for Hinduism, they are on the path of Hindutva, which is a politics based on the hierarchy of caste and gender. This politics targets Muslims and Christians and undermines the concept of social and gender justice. This politics promotes the interests of Corporate World. While Gandhi was a great Hindu, he was killed by Hindu nationalist politics, Hindutva. RSS, BJP are interested only in emotive issues like Ram Temple, Holy Cow, Love Jihad, Ghar Wapasi etc,. These issues have been used to create hate, violence and polarization in society. The society needs to tackle poverty, unemployment, poor health conditions and strive towards path of equality.
While deciding who to vote far, we need to consider as to which party-parties or coalition will be able to uphold Indian Constitution and take up material issues of people, rather than just the emotive issues which are creating Hate and violence in society. It is a crucial election and we have to rid the country of divisive politics, we have to strengthen the inclusive values and plural ethos in our social and political life.
We need policies which as Mahatma Gandhi said; keeps in mind the interest of ‘last person in the society’. We again have to look at the central mission of Gandhi which was Hindu Muslim unity. All the present policies are in violation of the principles of Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. We need to strengthen our Amity between different communities and take up policies which create jobs and also ensure welfare of average people of society. We have to decisively reject the party creating Hate and divisions in the name of religion and is promoting the interests of Big Corporate World at the cost of welfare of average people in the society.
Footnotes
- https://www.huffingtonpost.in/2018/09/25/rate-of-unemployment-highest-in-india-in-the-20-years-says-report_a_23541136/
- https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/29/world/asia/pellet-guns-used-in-kashmir-protests-cause-dead-eyes-epidemic.html
- https://indianexpress.com/article/india/anantkumar-hegde-we-are-here-to-change-the-constitutionsecular-mos-4998737/
- https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/oct/28/indian-prime-minister-genetic-science-existed-ancient-times
- http://archive.indiaspend.com/cover-story/86-dead-in-cow-related-violence-since-2010-are-muslim-97-attacks-after-2014-2014




I like The Companion