As the brouhaha over the ‘murder’ of George Floyd, a middle-aged African American, by Derek Chauvin, a white Minneapolis police officer, assumes centre-stage in the United States and around the world prodding countries to introspect and refurbish their social-structures, it makes sense to us Indians to look for what it has in store for India. The two scourges which culminated in the said incident and which are now being protested against in the #BLACKLIVESMATTER protests throughout the world are those of discrimination (on the basis of race) and police brutality. And the presence of both of these evils in India is not dubious and their practice is a daily norm in our country.
A Prolix History of Discrimination
The fact that Indian history is full of incidents of discrimination and paranoia describes to a certain extent the present inequities in Indian society since the social-structure of a nation at a particular point of time finds its basis in the sui generis culture and history of its own. Indian history endorses a wide magnitude of discrimination which was prevalent in its society. Indeed, the practice of untouchability and the labeling of certain people as untouchables in ancient India had been one of the most stringent forms of discrimination. This immense quantum of the unfair treatment of the selective groups of people finds its explanation in the fact that the grounds of such maltreatment were more than one. People were looked down upon based on their caste, sex, religion, region, race, ethnicity and their ilk. What can depose the ubiquity of discrimination in Indian society more than the fact that the pièce de résistance of the immensely followed Varna System was its inherent discrimination on the basis of one’s caste? The inaccessibility of a certain people to the public wells, assigning jobs to people on the basis of their jati, exempting some people from reading Vedas considering them to be of low caste, the ghettoization of women in the domestic walls of the household, the ostracisation of Indians from the administrative groups during the colonial rule, violence over people belonging to a particular religion, etc. are testimony to the prolix history of discrimination in India.
The ‘Legal’ Way Out
Our constitution-makers’ timely recognition of discrimination as one of the biggest stumbling blocks to the country’s prosperity and stature is quite laudable. Thanks to their sapience, we have had the right to equality articulated in our ‘grundnorm’ since the formation of India as a Republic in 1950. This ostensibly put an end to the prolonged reign of discrimination in our country, threw open the public spaces and employment opportunities to all and sundry irrespective of their religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth and defenestrated the untouchability making it an offence punishable by law. Instead of discrimination, we have had the provision of ‘special discrimination’ in the form of reservations to bring the victims of supercilious attitude at par with others. Some other anti-discrimination legislations of the country include Equal Remuneration Act, 1976 which guarantees the payment of equal remuneration to men and women alike; The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 which granted the similar rights to daughters as those were granted to sons; Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 which intended to prevent atrocities against marginalized communities, etc. Since we consider the precedents as one of the sources of law, the Supreme Court of India has also been instrumental in setting the anti-discrimination narrative in the country. The landmark judgment of Supreme Court in Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India whereby Section 377 of IPC was pronounced to be unconstitutional ‘in so far as it criminalizes consensual sexual conduct between adults of the same sex’ is a perfect example of the “legal” establishment of toleration and abnegation of prejudice in India’s experiment of democracy.
The Haunting Realities
But, the true spirit of democracy does not lie in written word. Instead, it lies in the routine practice of the rule of law and although we have been successful in codifying non-discrimination, we have drastically come a cropper in its practice. There are various reports which quote India’s miserable position on discrimination prevalent in its society. According to a research by the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis published in Lancet Global Health in 2018, an average of 239,000 girls under the age of five die each year in India because of their gender. The norm of ‘equal remuneration for equal work’ still waits for its full application in India. Combining the fact that a day rarely passes without the newspapers carrying the news of Dalits being killed with the research that various atrocities or other discriminatory behavior meted out to Dalits go unreported, one can imagine the quantum of prejudice being faced by them. And the most visible form of discrimination in present days is that against the people belonging to the community of LGBTQ. They are often harassed or bullied and to eschew this harassment they drop out of school or leave their jobs. The International Commission of Jurists, a non-governmental organization has found in its report that ‘educational and training opportunities are often denied to LGBTQ persons due to harassment, bullying and violence.’ Although in 2014, the Supreme Court in NALSA v. India acknowledged transgender people to be a ‘third gender’ affirming that the fundamental rights will be equally applicable to them, the reality is not as pleasant. At various public places these people do not even have the access to toilets, rendering the grant of fundamental rights almost nugatory.
We need to understand that discrimination is the repercussion of parochialism of society and lies in the minds of people. And although law has a pivotal role in rooting out this evil from society, we should know that it is not enough. It does not have the potential of extracting this out of people’s minds and here comes the role of education. As London is reviewing its public structures and altering the names of public spaces to make them more reflective of the diverse communities in the wake of #BLACKLIVESMATTER protests, we can review the content of our textbooks and modify it to make it more illustrative of toleration.



