On 10 July, a Turkish court has ruled that the conversion of Hagia Sophia mosque into museum in 1934 by the then autocrat ruler Ataturk was illegal and violation of the will of its endower Sultan Mehmet II. The court delivered this verdict on a plea filed by an Istanbul-based NGO Permanent Foundations Service to Historical Artifacts and Environment Association.
The court observed that the sultan, who conquered Istanbul in 1453, converted Hagia Sophia into a mosque, therefore turning the structure into a museum violated the law. The government is mere custodian of the historical heritage and it does not have authority to change the status of the UNESCO world heritage site. Hagia Sophia is a part of Mehmed II’s waqf.
This court ruling which corrected a historical injustice done by then dictator Ataturk has drawn a lot of outrage at the international level. Not only the common people but also political and religious leaders from the western countries have opposed the move. US secretary of State Mike Pompeo and Pop Francis, leader of Roman Catholic Church also raised objection on Turkish government’s decision to convert the museum into mosque. The issue created a lot of buzz on social media in various countries including India. Most of them argued that the historic building should remain as the museum and converting the museum into mosque is against secularism.
But all this outrage and hue and cry against converting the museum into mosque is not just Islamobhobic and far from the justice and truth. There was no legal and moral ground on which basis one can say that the Hagia Sophia should remain museum. Because the historical site is a waqf property which was donated by the Sultan Mehmet for the mosque not museum. The mosque had been converted by then Turkish dictator Ataturk. After becoming the first president of Turkish republic, Ataurk had suspended the religious rights of Muslims in Turkey and took many steps to cleanse the entire country from the Islamic cultures. He had imposed a ban on wearing Hijab and on Arabic azan. He had changed the Arabic scripts of Turkish language. Likewise, he had taken many such steps to change Turkey’s Muslim society into western culture. He was doing all this to appease the western powers. The conversion of the Hagia Sophia mosque into museum was one of part of such extremist secularism which are grave human rights abuses. This was not only injustice against the Turkish society but also destruction of their culture and civilization which they developed over centuries.
Under any parameter and ideology, this suppression of a culture and religious rights cannot be justified anywhere. If it is looked upon according to the modern values, it is a universally agreed upon that the religious rights are one of the fundamental rights and it must be respected under all circumstances. But surprisingly, Ataturk has been hailed by western historians as the biggest reformer of Turkey for doing all this. They gave it a cover of secularism. Does the secularism mean suspending religious rights and destroying any particular culture?
All these undemocratic moves of Ataturk are still being glorified by some section of left-liberals. This is why the conversion of the Hagia Sophia from museum into mosque has offended them. If one sees it with judicious perspective, this was necessary to correct historical wrongs.
The second question raised on the conversion of the museum into mosque that the Hagia Sophia was originally a church and the converting a church into mosque is wrong. This argument is being made by ignoring the fact that the Hagia Sophia palace was bought by the sultan Mehmet from the church authority and dedicated it for building the mosques. That’s why the court called it Sultan Mehmet’s waqf property. There are documents available which shows the Hagia Sophia was the waqf property of Sultan. Even historians are saying that the building was bought by the Sultan after winning Constantinople in a battle and dedicated it for the mosque.
According to Egyptian historian Raghib Als-erjani, after the conquest of Constantinople which is now Istanbul, Christians took refuge in the cathedral. The Sultan Mehmet allowed them to practice their religion normally. He left all of the churches in the city untouched and performed his first prayer outside Hagia Sophia. The Sultan asked the bishops if they would purchase the land and the building. The bishops agreed to sell it. The sultan paid to them from his personal wealth and gave orders to turn the building into mosque. Turkish historian Salim Agdogan said similar things about it.
After knowing this fact that the building and land was sold by the bishops, the Christians have no authority to make claim on the Hagia Sophia and raise objections on its mosque status. The very fact that the Sultan bequeathed the palace as a religious endowment for the mosque is being ignored by all those who are outraging over mosque status. The second fact which is being ignored is that the Hagia Sophia was not like common churches where the worshippers go for only prayer. But it was a political center from where the Christian kings were plotting against their enemies including Muslim rulers. It is a fact that anyone who is fighting against them will attack on their political centers when there will be battle between them. So, the Hagia Sophia cannot be considered as the common church which cannot be touched in the battle.
The second thing which has emerged from this outrage against the conversion of the museum into mosque is the double standards of the western world regarding the conversion of religious palaces. The world remained silent at various point of times when a mosque was converted into other religious palaces and any other structures. When India’s Supreme Court ordered to build the temple at the site where the Babri mosque once stood, the world remained silent. There was no reaction from the US and Russia on the Babri verdict as they have reacted on the conversion of Hagia Sophia into mosque. The world remained silent when historical mosque Al-Ahmar in Safad was turned into nightspot in Israel. In Spain, Mosque Cordoba was converted into churches but no one has spoken up about it.
If it is a matter of the principle that we should accept the history as it is and it cannot be changed. Then, this first applies to the Atarturk who had changed the status of the mosque and did not accept the history of Hagia Sophia as it is. Since, the status of Hagia Sophia had been changed by Ataturk in the modern world, it must be corrected. However, the status of medieval history cannot be changed according to the modern principals. Because, the principals of modern and medieval were drastically different. And the status of Hagia Sophia has been wrongly converted into museum in the modern era and it’s conversion into mosque is correct.



