Home Campus voice Bringing diversity and democracy in Campus

Bringing diversity and democracy in Campus

1557
3

College days are always seen as the most exciting and fun filled days in a person’s life. Even after twenty or thirty years of leaving college, people  often  reminisce and recall college and campus life with nostalgia  remembering friends, exams, teachers and roommates.  Often the carefree college days are portrayed as the best phase in a person’s life. Is that really the whole story?  Is there another side to campus life that we rarely talk about? As campuses are getting more diverse with students and staff from different religions, regions, cultures and economic backgrounds, new tensions and new kinds of conflicts are emerging.  Maybe it’s time to recognize that with the transition from school to college, the shift from  home to hostel and  the experience of sharing  classrooms, benches and  hostel rooms with people from different and unfamiliar backgrounds, campus life can also be difficult and harsh.

So, what does it actually mean to shift from school to college? Is the college just a bigger school   with higher classes without the school uniform and big bags? Or is there a fundamental difference between school compounds and college campuses in terms of the composition of students and the culture that is practiced?

For many young people the shift from school to college involves taking important decisions about which courses to study and which subjects to drop. This is often a confusing process because school students do not get adequate guidance or information to choose a career path based on their dreams, aptitudes and interests. And even if they do get such guidance it is  the mark-sheets, parental expectations, family’s financial situation, social status, caste and religion,  and where they live that dominates the final choice that is made. It is a process of much turmoil without having the freedom to fully express what one actually wants.  So, young people could enter college in a frustrated and confused state about what they are studying and why.

And finally the first day of college arrives. It’s a day of much excitement colored by the fear of entering a new space. The fear of ragging adds up to the tension.  While ragging used to be a friendly process of interaction between seniors and juniors and “breaking the ice”, over the years ragging has become a tool for domination, intimidation and harassment. The popular pranks and loud laughter are not always funny they often ridicule a person for belonging to a particular language, religion, caste or gender or just being poor. Cruel and insulting jokes and such harsh treatment in the name of ragging can spoil the whole fun of entering college life and even leave deep emotional scars of humiliation.

Bringing diversity and democracy in Campus raggingAs the phase of ragging ends, going to college also means making new friends and leaving behind childhood friends with whom one has studied from Standard 1 till 10. This is both sad and exciting and if a student is going from a girls’ or boys’ school to a co-educational college it can also be the first time they are getting a chance to make friends with the opposite sex.  Therefore, instant crushes and attractions are always coming and going. These can distract a young mind considerably, as getting to talk to the person you like can be the most important agenda for the day. While these are  natural and normal processes,   it is also a difficult  one as no–one is completely sure of what they want, whether the person you like also likes you, who else likes her/him etc. and  how to differentiate between  friendships and attractions.

While schools always have uniforms, the freedom to choose what you wear to college is something everyone looks forward to.  Every campus has the cool cats and the cool dudes who set the fashion standards and everyone else is often trying hard to be like them.  But that is not easy- having the cool shoes, clothes, hairstyles, bags, phones, snacks and hanging out together often requires considerable amount of money and parental permissions.   With clothes there are also new notions   “decency” and aesthetics.  For the rural student who is now in an urban setting, everything can be confusing. So, trying to not to be “uncool” can also result in lot of frustrations, fights with parents and feelings of inferiority. If you lose friends or are excluded from certain groups or made fun of in any way, it can be quite a painful experience.

To top it, now college authorities are also imposing dress codes and deciding what is decent /indecent. This is supposedly to prevent  girls and boys  from dressing  in  a “provocative” manner. What is needed instead is to help students look at each other as persons with unique minds and souls, and not just a package of clothes. Unfortunately, fashion trends are now confusing  stylishness  with  “sexy” and   such sexualisation of beauty can make it  hard to  distinguish between  dressing  to reflect your personality and tastes  or  dressing  to be attractive and cool.

While schools always have uniforms, the freedom to choose what you wear to college is something everyone looks forward to.  Every campus has the cool cats and the cool dudes who set the fashion standards and everyone else is often trying hard to be like them.

In addition to clothes and accessories, one’s proficiency in English is also becoming a serious issue. Most young people of our country come from villages, small towns or urban disadvantaged backgrounds, and have emerged from families and schools where English is not a medium of communication. Therefore, lack of comprehension and fluency in English is a reality for the majority.  At the same time with increasing corporatisation of the economy and global influences, English is now becoming a kind of currency for employability and social mobility.  Within the college, text books in English and the premium placed on knowing English, exert tremendous pressure  on a large number of students. While they desperately want to learn, their foundations in this language are weak and so they struggle with vocabulary, grammar, accents and syntax.  College authorities could do a lot more to empower and help such students and simultaneously need to actively discourage any form of discrimination against those who are not English savvy.

College can also differ from school in terms of academics and ways of learning and teaching. In fact, college should be different and methods of teaching should encourage wide reading, discussion,  critical thinking and healthy debate. However, most college teachers continue to treat their students like school children, giving notes and encouraging rote learning for passing exams without facilitating analytical and reflective learning. This is a serious issue as young people need to be encouraged to develop opinions, become creative and to take stands. For a young person who is at the brink of adulthood, such child-like treatment in the classroom can be very stifling and discouraging.  With the semester system there is continuous academic pressure, leaving very little time for extra- curricular activities which are a crucial part of the person’s holistic development. On the whole, the learning experience in college leaves students frustrated and pressurized, instead of being stimulated and satisfied.

So what is the solution to all this? Can we have campuses where the diversity of students is seen as a resource?  Can we have campuses where campus life itself becomes a significant source of learning? What do we mean by an inclusive campus?

Today college campuses are much more diverse than they were a few decades ago. In the last century when universities and colleges were just being established, most students  were  upper caste, upper class and  urban  with  very   few women.  Gradually  with the  role of  missionaries and social reformers,  children  from scheduled castes  and other  backward  communities   were able to complete  their  schooling  and enter colleges and universities.  Religion and caste  based  trusts  also founded  colleges and universities  primarily  to encourage youth from their  communities  to gain access to higher education.  Some communities who were  primarily engaged in agriculture, business or crafts  did not see much value in higher education as their children entered the parents’ professions and learnt  knowledge and skills from their elders.

 While it is a good thing that college  education is no longer  restricted to a few,  it also means that  we need to deal with the diversity of today’s college campuses and create  inclusive campuses.

Today even these communities are interested in college education. As a result we have colleges which  are run as businesses and private universities as well. Management quotas,  reservation quotas  and  college admission policies   have  ensured that  today most colleges  have a  wide mix  of  students- rural and urban, south Indians, north Indians  and north-east Indians, male and female, upper castes and  scheduled caste, Hindus, Muslims  and Christians. They often know nothing of each others’ cultures, they are not aware of each other’s problems  and lives and have internalized  superiority and inferiority. When thrown together they  often  end up sticking to their own groups and reproducing  the inequalities of  society inside  the college campus.

While it is a good thing that college  education is no longer  restricted to a few,  it also means that  we need to deal with the diversity of today’s college campuses and create  inclusive campuses. An inclusive campus  is  one where students from all backgrounds feel equally respected, treated and  nurtured  together; where students  are  taught to learn from each other as equals; where the diversity of cultures and  world views  is seen as a resource. Is this happening? Unfortunately, old mindsets  prevail and  staff and managements  create  campuses  conducive to  students  of their  own communities  seeing  the others  as outsiders. Inclusion, however is not merely about accepting quotas and then discriminating against those students in subtle ways  or admitting those who pay huge donations and  continuously extorting money from them .

Inclusion is  about changing the rules of the game  so that students  from all backgrounds  can  blossom in an atmosphere where there is no fear of stigma or ridicule. It may even mean  re-interpreting curriculum so that all worldviews are  recognized, allowing diversity  in forms of dressing,  providing  food for different  culinary tastes, ensuring that staff teams are diverse and going beyond  “neutrality” to accept that those who has entered  the campus   from a disadvantaged background  could especially be  vulnerable. Dalit students’ suicides in premier institutes of engineering, medicine and management   have met with a deafening silence. Muslim students and those from the north-east are often called outsiders or anti-nationals and attacked or bullied.  Sexual harassment of girl students by teachers and college mates is rampant but it goes on as there is no system in place to deal with their grievances.

What is needed therefore are,  inclusive campuses  where democratic values  are practised in classrooms, staff rooms, board rooms, hostel rooms and common spaces.  The reality however is that in most of these spaces  there is domination rather than  democracy.  In the class room teachers dominate over students. In the staff rooms seniors and those who belong to particular castes or gender dominate. In the board room, trustees of particular communities and those who can bring in resources dominate. In the hostel rooms and common spaces, the cool gangs or those who come from powerful communities dominate. The latter have their  own  nexus  or  informal associations  which wield power and even use violence to safeguard  the status quo. Others are silenced or sidelined in such a tense atmosphere.

Can students do anything to make campuses   more inclusive and democratic? Can students play a role in democratising and energizing campuses to make them vibrant and  dynamic spaces? Can students have and assert their rights ?

Bringing diversity and democracy in Campus 1Students can play a critical and vital role in making campuses democratic, safe, vibrant and inclusive. Firstly, they need spaces to engage with each other across gender, caste, region, religion and class lines. They need spaces to make friends across the board, understand each others’ dilemmas and life stories and  to articulate their issues without fear.

Secondly, they need  platforms through which they can seek  justice. Student organizations, unions, clubs and other student associations for students with special vulnerabilities  of gender, caste, religion or disability etc., can also be used as platforms for making requests or demands

And lastly they need mechanisms  to deal with  genuine grievances. There need to be grievance cells to receive complaints  of discrimination, committees for prevention of  sexual harassment, spoken English support, counseling cells and  career guidance cells etc., so that students’ needs as individuals and as a community are  addressed and  justice is delivered.

3 COMMENTS

  1. Thought provoking article, Ms. Ratnam has beautifully explained the merits and demerits of the present campus/educational setup. I liked the idea of democratization wherein more emphasis has been given to the ‘individuals & education’ rather than the ‘power & elections’.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here