It has been a year when India suddenly woke up to the cries of an innocent girl, raising voices on the gruesome crime inflicted on her. The collective guilt of the nation consoled itself by giving her great names… Jagriti… Jyoti… Nirbhaya… Damini… A year has passed after that unfortunate incident but still crime against women in our country is on a continuous rise. It disturbs us, but for a transient moment, as all our senses have become so numb, that it seems like a normal part of our life. We see, we hear, we feel and then with a click or a scroll, we forget. Why is this so? Is it not because we practice double standards on the issues of injustice and cruelty? Have we ever spoken for a Dalit girl, a tribal woman, a woman from North East or from Kashmir who have been subjected to extreme cruelties beyond our imagination? Are we aware of the unheard Daminis?
Nazish Ashraf a student from Kashmir studying in Delhi reflects her worst fear below in her own words which clearly reflects our double standards…
It has always been difficult for me to leave my home after relaxing vacations with my parents. But this time it was more difficult than usual, not only for me but for my parents as well. Even the thought of me going back to Delhi brought tears into my mother’s eyes and obviously a huge list of do’s and don’ts. My father though silent, couldn’t hide that deep, worried frown on his face, his threat of sending me back, away from home. Friends and relatives equally worried.
Dear Mom you told me that it is difficult to be a girl and that a girl is just a vulnerable body that needs to protect herself every time.
Dear Papa you advised me to reach back to my hostel at time, before it gets dark, to refrain from discussing Kashmir and politics.
I couldn’t imagine how a human can do such a thing to another human. Then different statements of great political leaders of India made me realize that they don’t consider girls as humans, rather an object of desire, which is only made to give sexual pleasure to men.
Dear Mama, Dear Papa even I didn’t want to come back to Delhi. Every time I switched on to any news channel, I saw protests, stone pelting, public gatherings in Delhi as if Delhi was transformed into Kashmir where people are helpless and the government deaf. Those were restless days. I couldn’t imagine how a human can do such a thing to another human. Then different statements of great political leaders of India made me realize that they don’t consider girls as humans, rather an object of desire, which is only made to give sexual pleasure to men. And that these crimes can be reduced, rather vanished only when girls dress modestly. I think this country should start giving workshops to two year old girls of how to dress themselves so that they do not attract a sixty year old eye. That seven year old girl who was recently raped in Goa in her school premises should have known that she was dressed immodestly, that she is nothing just a lump of flesh that if exposed to men’s eye will be consumed .
I could see Delhi crying for justice as Kashmir has always been doing. The only difference was that media, mainstream media, could participate in the plight of people, highlighting the drawbacks of Indian leaders and the injustice done to that innocent 23 year old girl. Not only Damini but the entire history of rapes in rural and urban India was thrown light upon. But Mama, Papa they again ignored Kashmir which is every time on the Independence and the Republic day of India declared as ‘the integral part of India ‘. Damini couldn’t survive but people stood for her; main stream media channels though biased, managed to drag the political leaders and forced them to answer public. They will never allow people to forget Damini. But we Kashmiris are not even allowed to remember our lost ones. They never spoke about the rapes in Kunanposhpora where all the women of the village were raped by more than 60 army personals. They never asked justice for Kunanposhpora survivors. They didn’t speak about Assiya and Neelofer . Mom, Dad, I want to ask them… Are not the girls of Kashmir girls as Damini was? Don’t they deserve justice as Damini does? Don’t the people of Kashmir have right to protest when their mothers, sisters and daughters are raped and killed.
Dear Mamma, dear Papa , I find Kashmir more unsafe where if I be raped tomorrow, no one will be allowed to stand for justice .
Dear Mamma, dear Papa , I find Kashmir more unsafe where if I be raped tomorrow, no one will be allowed to stand for justice. My people will be killed. They will answer their stones with bullets. No one will come for my rescue. Those culprits won’t be asked as they already wear rescue uniforms. Our local media will be banned and mainstream media will show a peaceful Kashmir to India where the rapists will be pictured as the security personnel. They will once again shut down the social networking and internet connections. No one will know me. No one will pray for me as they prayed for Damini. There will be no candle light gatherings for me as for Damini. Mom, dad Kashmir is more unsafe, not for every girl, not for every boy, but for every Kashmiri fighting for his right, who dies in desolation, with cries unheard, with laments unresponded, with murders of not only people but even a cry for justice. Our country without a post office’ is full of desolated Daminis, who were, are and will be left ignored by them.




Very true! Its easy for us to forget a kunanposhpora but anniversary nirbhaya case is celebrated for pure machiavellian pursuits of trp! and to feed our voyueristic tendencies. Double standards indeed !!!
When one stands for a cause, the sincerity is reflected when one is Unbiased. Religion, Region, Caste or any detestable social traits shouldn’t strangle the symphony of the world.
There are multitudinous reasons that trigger biased mind, only universal humanely nature can make the world a better place to live. Let peace transcend every barrier.
-Farukh, Athrady.
Dil se jo baat nikalti hai asar rakhti hai…. The article in its entirety conveys the plight of the oppressed in a heartfelt manner.
Every crime or for that matter every Evil perpetrated in a civilized society leads us to hold the administration responsible and answerable. In this particular case of Damini’s whether heard or unheard, one cannot absolve either party from the responsibility. The oppressor and the oppressed! One is reminded of sayings of the Islamic prophet “Help your brother, whether he is an oppressor or is oppressed”. The rhetoric in the article against the oppressors (includes the administration) is justified and acceptable but at the same time the inattentiveness of the oppressed is left in oblivion. The article as such inclines for the feminist liking by putting all the responsibility of the crimes of kinds of Damini’s of Delhi on males. Somebody on the comments very rightly said ‘There are multitudinous reasons that trigger biased mind’. The irresponsible, uncompromising, unnatural and at times arrogant attitudes of the oppressed heard Damini’s of Delhi could be some of them.
Please translate it in all every language and let India read and know about Kashmir through local print media.(requesting to all readers)