The Surgical Strikes and the rhetoric

0
149

Last month, the nation saw an unprecedented announcement by a high-ranked military official informing the nation about the ‘surgical strikes’ carried out by the Indian army.

What was unprecedented here is not the nature of the strikes, but such a public revelation of it. Contrary to popular opinion and claims by our Defense Minister, such a strike was not carried out for the first time. According to a revelation by former National Security Advisor Shiv Shankar Menon and documents published by THE HINDU, such strikes had also been carried out in the past decade (and targeting not just militants but the Pakistani Rangers themselves). However, as the NSA admits, the reason they were not made public was that satisfying the demand for a fitting reply to Pakistan before the Indian public was not the objective of such strikes.

Then why did the government chose to tread a different path this time? There are two primary reasons for that –

1 – It easily takes the attention away from the civilian deaths and unrest in Kashmir which has now entered the fourth month. In fact, the same is the reason the government played up the Uri attack (though it did not have such an international and high-pitched response to either of Gurdaspur, Pathankot or Pampore attacks which together accounted for the death of 25 civilians and army-men).

Pakistan has been time and again cited as the main enemy of India by the ultra-nationalists. It is nothing but a gimmick to divert all the attention away from the host of issues plaguing our country. The same trick is also being played in Pakistan for decades. Even recently, when the credibility of Nawaz Sharif was in question after the Panama leaks, he skillfully played up the killing of Burhan Wani (even terming him as a martyr) to shift the focus of the national media there. In fact, he cannot afford to relent to India as then he would appear weak vis-à-vis the Pakistan Army (which thrives on hatred for India).

2 – It provides the government an excellent matter to boast about in the upcoming elections in Punjab, Gujarat and Uttar Pradesh. In two of these states, the BJP is a part of the current government and performed excellently well in the third in the 2014 elections and thus the three hold high importance for the BJP.

Much of the debate after the strikes has been focused on some political parties asking for proof of the strikes, which in the opinion of some is equivalent to blasphemy, because how can you question the Army? The Army is beyond all questions, scrutiny and everything they say is to be accepted without challenge.

There is a grave error which we will be committing if we hold Army on such a high pedestal. The Armed Forces are nothing but an instrument of the state, like administration, police forces, municipalities, legislature etc. and in the end are accountable to the government who are in turn answerable to the people of the country. True, we are all grateful to the men and women guarding the borders of the country just to keep us safe. But in the end, they derive their powers from the people, in an indirect manner via the government of the day and should be within the broad umbrella of institutions which the citizens can hold accountable.

We were so much concerned about the 18 soldiers being killed and the pressure was built on government to respond to it because it was an external enemy. Why isn’t such a sustained pressure built on the government to deal with more than 1 lakh deaths in accidents that happen in our country every year, which is more than the death toll in all our wars put together.

Worshiping the Armed Forces and reducing their accountability is fraught with many dangers. We only need to look at Pakistan to realize what lies for us in future if we keep treading this path. The government should always have supreme control over the Armed Forces and the latter should always be accountable to the government and via it to the people.

There is also a fundamental error we make here while upholding the martyrdom of the soldiers who lose their lives at the borders. It seemed the whole nation wanted revenge of the killing of the 18 soldiers in the Uri, but what about the hundreds of the RTI activists, honest public servants and brave-hearted policemen who also died only to make our lives better. Did we even notice that National Police Commemoration Day just passed by in the midst of this heated debate? Why is it that we worship the soldiers but turn a blind eye towards all the rest who also serve the country diligently and also sacrifice their lives for it?

We were so much concerned about the 18 soldiers being killed and the pressure was built on government to respond to it because it was an external enemy. Why isn’t such a sustained pressure built on the government to deal with more than 1 lakh deaths in accidents that happen in our country every year, which is more than the death toll in all our wars put together. What about the deaths due to respiratory infections, rail accidents, lack of proper health care in rural areas, hundreds of farmers suicides and numerous other much more important issues?

There is nothing that we are going to gain out of this politics of hatred except for the consolidation of votes by the right wing nationalist parties of this country. It is same as the communal politics played by the politicians – based solely on rhetoric and stereotypes.

It is tempting to blame the government for all of this but the truth is it is us who frame the policy of this country and also set the priorities for the government, which acts whichever way the popular will goes. Thus, it is our duty not to be swayed by such empty rhetoric and rather focus on the actual issues plaguing our country, which in my opinion, are much more important.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here