A case against the capital punishment

0
133

“Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement.” This is what Gandalf tells Frodo in The Lord of the Rings- The Fellowship of the Ring.

But we as a society need to give punishments to the criminals. But why do we do that? There are three main reasons for this-

1 – The first reason for punishing criminals is to deter future potential criminals, by giving out a message to the society that you will be given a justified and proportional punishment if you commit this particular crime.

2 – The second objective is to make the criminal realize what he did was wrong, make him regret it and to reform him, so that he can be integrated back into the society as a productive member. Moreover, we need to keep the society safe till the time he is reformed.

3 – Lastly, punishment is given to give a sense of justice to the victim.

Now let us analyse these points if the punishment to be given is death.

1 –Talking of deterring potential criminals, it is very clear that death penalty does not add any deterrent effects other than those already achieved by the supposedly lesser punishment of life imprisonment. This argument has been established in various research works. The United Nations’ agency, Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (Moving Away from the Death Penalty, 2014)and the Law Commission of India (August 2015 report on Death penalty) are also of the same opinion.

Death penalties have been given out for centuries, but the numbers of murders and rapes have only been increasing. Nor can it be argued that because of the fear of death penalty, the barbarity in these crimes has decreased.

It is not the severity of the punishment, but the high likelihood of getting caught that is the real deterrent in serious crimes.

2- About keeping the society safe -the objective is achieved by giving life imprisonment without parole as punishment. We do not need to resort to death penalty for that. Moreover, life imprisonment provides the criminal an opportunity, howsoever bleak, of reformation.

3 – Now for the last point, death penalty is retribution or revenge, and surely not justice. Capital punishment serves no purpose other than fulfilling the blood lust of the victim or of the society.

93.5% of those on death row in terrorism cases and 75% across all cases are Dalits or those from the religious minorities. At the ground level, the response of the police is very different in the case of a poor lower-caste individual as compared to that in the case of an upper-caste village Pradhan.

Now let us see in which cases the death penalty is actually awarded.

According to the Supreme Court judgement in Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab in 1980, death penalty is to be given in only the ‘rarest of rare’ cases. This was the only criteria given by the Supreme Court for awarding the death penalty, and it has remained the same ever since. Recently, the courts have also said that they are awarding capital punishment because the crime shook the collective conscience of the society.

The criterion is purely subjective and is based solely on the perception of the judge. Consider this – Trial courts handed down 1,800 death sentences over the last 15 years. Fewer than 5 per cent of the 1,800 death sentences were confirmed by the Supreme Court, and a third resulted in acquittal. Take the case of 2002 Akshardham temple attack case for instance, in which the death penalty was imposed by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court, based on what the Supreme Court later ruled was wholly fabricated evidence.

There is not only a difference in opinion regarding the punishment to be given but also in determining the guilt of the accused, even in such serious crimes where we are taking someone’s life.

It is not always a matter of perception. There is a significant margin of error in functioning of the courts, and mistakes do occur even at the highest levels.

Fourteen eminent former judges wrote to President Pranab Mukherjee about the death sentence having been wrongly given in 13 cases- two of these convicts had already been executed. These were the cases in which not just the trial courts but the High Courts and the Supreme Court too had seemingly erred.

We are doing immense and an irreversible damage because of these ambiguities and human imperfections. Leave the moral reasons aside, just the inconsistent outcomes from the judicial system on this question should be reason enough for us to change our stand on death penalty.

93.5% of those on death row in terrorism cases and 75% across all cases are Dalits or those from the religious minorities. At the ground level, the response of the police is very different in the case of a poor lower-caste individual as compared to that in the case of an upper-caste village Pradhan. The poor and the marginalised sections of the society are not able to afford their lawyers most of the times, and perhaps this explains their high proportion in the prisons too, which is significantly higher to their proportion in the population.

One must weigh all the effects of capital punishment as it has several drawbacks to counter its supposedly obvious advantages. For example, offenders threatened with death could have an added incentive to kill witnesses to their crimes. Furthermore, it may be difficult to convict people when the punishment may be death than when it is less draconian, as in the case of the former, the bar for determining the guilt of the accused would be set quite high. In other words, severity of punishment may run counter to the more effective certainty of punishment.

Even for a moment if we assume that capital punishment can be justified in some cases, the method of carrying them out cannot be. Methods such as death by hanging in India which is a legacy of the colonial era, prolonged and excruciatingly painful lethal injections, and death by firing squad are punishments which very often end up being disproportionate to the crime.

So why do we still give capital punishment? Politicians support the death penalty in order to appear tough on crime. It distracts legislatures on the state and national level from focussing on real solutions to crime problems(which requiresdedication and constant efforts) by instead adopting a short and inefficient route. Misconceptions regarding deterrence and what should constitute justice lead to support of the capital punishment by the public.

Thus it is my firm belief that capital punishment serves no purpose other than providing a sense of revenge to the victim or to the society, and cannot be justified on any other technical or moral grounds. It is time we understand this and do away with this inhumane and barbaric form of punishment.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here