Appalling medical education

0
534

According to the 2011 census, the population of Telangana was determined to be at 35,193,978 which, undoubtedly, has undergone considerable expansion in the past five years. However, according to the Telangana statistical yearbook released in 2015, the number of public sector doctors stands at a mere 4713. While the national average doctor:patient ratio is already an appalling 1:1670, compared to the recommended WHO ratio of 1:1000, Telangana falls even further back, with a ratio of 1:1950, including private doctors. Further, this ratio includes several doctors concentrated in big cities, particularly Hyderabad, and some others like Adilabad, Nizamabad and Warangal. Rural areas have very limited access to doctors.These stats clearly point to the dire need to increase medical seats.

A solution to this situation could be the conversion of district hospitals into teaching hospitals. This conversion will not only equip it with specialists of all disciplines-providing all round healthcare-but will also produce doctors in its geographical area, and hence reduce the unequal distribution of doctors. Apart from this, the process of acquiring permission for opening up a medical college should be simplified and made transparent. This should be done strategically in all districts. Private sector should be involved and facilitated by the government to open medical colleges at strategic locations and with good infrastructure. Also, to increase the number of colleges, it is essential to increase the faculty. This can only be achieved by increasing the number of PG seats. The number of PG seats in Telangana is only 1113, with 827 under convener quota and 286 under the management quota, compared to 3,350 UG seats, including 2,350 in private colleges and 1,000 in six state-run medical colleges. This means roughly only one out of three doctors will undertake postgraduate education, and the other two won’t be able to pursue anything further.

Shortage of professors is a bottleneck in running a medical college because of which medical seats at UG and PG levels are not been increased. When PG seats for MBBS and BDS graduates are increased so that they specialize and don’t just stay graduates then medical colleges can have enough PG specialists to recruit as professors. Similar is the story for super specialty seats. Why there are so few PG specialty and super specialty seats is a point to ponder over. Once a candidate is done with his/her MBBS, he/she must be encouraged and facilitated to at least specialize and even better to super specialize so that services offered by the doctors improve.

Even the government should recruit MD Family Medicine, Community Medicine and Emergency Medicine specialists in Primary Healthcare Centers/CHCs to improve primary healthcare standards in India. But there are hardly any seats for these subjects in India. Every medical college can offer 1-4 seats each in MD Emergency Medicine, Family Medicine, Hematology, Infectious Diseases, Geriatrics &; Palliative Medicine, Transfusion Medicine, MDS Maxillo Facial Surgery and Masters in Hospital Administration, but very few medical colleges offer these courses. This way, around 150-200 PG seats will get added immediately this academic year itself. Premier government and private institutes like AIIMS, KNRUHS (Warangal), Osmania (Hyderabad), etc can offer 3-4 seats whereas other institutes can offer 1-2 seats annually. There is huge shortage of specialist doctors in these fields. This was especially seen to affect RIMS(Adilabad) very badly, as without sufficient doctors the hospital has come to a crippling halt. Take for instance the plight of a Ganesh of Echoda, who brought his sister for delivery in the first week of March. He had to spend four days waiting for proper treatment at the hospital but to no avail. As there was no visible signs of getting good treatment, he shifted his sister to a hospital in Yavatmal district of Maharashtra. Though there are large number of doctors and other teaching faculty retiring from the government medical colleges, the state government has not taken up any kind of recruitment to fill up the vacant teaching posts during the past two years. For instance, there is no professor for anatomy, pharmacology, anesthesia, general medicine and physiology in Osmania, Kakatiya and Nizamabad Medical Colleges. The government must aim to help make all medical graduates either specialists or super specialists, even if it is Family Medicine or Emergency Medicine. No graduate must be left out without specializing in a particular field of medicine, just like it is done in some developed countries.

While increasing the number of seats, it is important that the quality of doctors produced has to be good as well. The routine inspections conducted by the MCI focus only on infrastructure, and no attention is payed to the quality of education imparted or the development of a standard of competence. All teaching hospitals, their blood banks, their labs and their Urban and Rural Health Centers must get accredited by NABH(National Accreditation Board of Hospitals and Healthcare providers) or JCI(Joint Commission International). This will help government keep a check on the quality of healthcare and infrastructure provided by teaching hospitals affiliated to the medical colleges. JCI has a special accreditation program for teaching institutes in the field of medicine. Accreditation will help government assess the quality of medical care offered to the patients and the quality of education offered to the students. As government is not directly involved in quality checks, it can be an example of ‘Minimum Government and Maximum Governance ‘policy.

Apart from this, it is necessary to ensure that the staff is present on time. Bio-metric attendance system must be strictly introduced for all faculties and students of all medical colleges on a par with corporate hospitals. Ghost faculty problem will get solved with this.

Doing specialty and super-specialty means many doctors will be students till late ages. But they too have a family to look after financially. These doctors must be provided adequate amount of stipends in government and private medical colleges and that too on a monthly basis. But this is not the case in most of the states in India. Either no stipend is offered or too little amount is offered or the amount is not given to the doctors on a monthly basis. Not only this, but a vast majority of the hospital patient load is handled by the postgraduates. This has become a form of bonded labor where the worker has absolutely no say in the matter. Government can decide on the minimum stipend amount that must be offered to graduates and Post Graduates in this regard and make strict guidelines which are easy to follow and understand for all. This must be communicated to all the medical colleges. The amount must be adjusted keeping inflation in mind and annual review must be done in this regard.

There is also the concern for privacy of the patients. Medical colleges and teaching hospitals cannot turn patients into rats and mice of a lab to learn skills on. Human dignity must be respected. All medical colleges must have Simulation Labs for its courses, whether UG or PG, to practice skills on and perfect them as is the case in most of the developed countries. Even the topmost colleges in Telangana like Osmania,Gandhi and Kakatiya do not have such labs. Simulation Labs must offer all basic and advanced skills training to graduates and postgraduates to get hands-on training on cadavers and simulation models.

Medical seats are very few in number unlike Engg, MBA seats. So keeping web counselling for admissions into UG and PG courses is not at all helpful for the candidates. Medical PG courses are divided into Clinical/Non-Clinical, Medical/Surgical, Degree/Diploma, government/private seats, etc. So keeping web counselling does not help the candidate as the decision to opt for a seat in PG is very, very complex. So it is better to avoid web counselling for admissions in medical streams. Telangana and AP conducted web counselling for academic year 2016-17 for PG admissions. Most of the doctors were very unsatisfied with the result of the counselling and a lot of doctors did not join the PG course they got selected into through web counselling.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here