Caste Among Muslims In India

0
374

The title of this article may have provoked almost all readers who happen to have read about Islam sometime back. For some individuals it is the first time that they are coming across this through this write up or they are aware but they have not experienced it or it is the other way around that they might have been the victims of this cruel system of practice, so it is incumbent upon me to deal with all these categories without exaggerating . Keeping aside emotions, if we analyse objectively we will find a sharp contradiction between what is preached by Islam and what actually is practised. In this article I would like to throw some light on modified version of caste system which was( is being) practised by few Muslims in different parts of India (including south India). The intention behind this article is to portray the reality of Muslims (few) and create awareness among masses that Islam in no way legitimises this cruel system which places individuals in hierarchy and discriminates them by their ascribed status. Moreover the concept of pollution is also not a part of Islam.

In view of the above discussion the article is divided into three sections following the introduction, the second sections deals with those who think that there is no caste system in Islam and the third section deals with those who are aware but didn’t experience and those have been the victims of such cruel system.

First I would like to deal with those who think that there is no caste system in Islam in general and among Muslims in particular. Yes their views about Islam are correct. Ideally, no text of the book Quran or the sayings of the Prophet Mohammed(PBUH) supports this cruel practice. Neither it was found in practice among the companions of the Prophet nor among their after comers. The philosophy of caste is quite contradictory to the basic beliefs of Islam which explicitly emphasize on equality and universal brotherhood. In theory , Islam in no way tolerates or recognise any discrimination on the lines of lineage or occupation. What we get to know from the preachings of Islam is that every Muslim irrespective of his rank or his birth is equal in the sight of Almighty Allah and hence there can be no distinction among Muslims except in regard to degrees of piety and God’s consciousness .

” O mankind, indeed We have created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Acquainted “(Al Quran 49:13).

This was also practised by Prophet, the idea of equality and brotherhood was established during the early days of Islam through the democratic form of political organisations, moreover scholars of the past and present unanimously agree that the world’s first written constitution which guaranteed and was practised ideally was the ‘Constitution of Medina’ .

Moving further to deal with those who are aware and those who have been the victims of this cruel system of. Yes you are also right, there exists among certain band of Muslims the Modified version of this. Before going ahead it seems advisable to describe briefly how Islam or Muslims came into India. Islam entered first time in the southern part of India , what is now called as Kerala. It was through trade and commerce that Islam entered India and not by the sword as it was( is being) propagated by Orientalist and staunch enemies of Islam. One important factor for people embracing Islam was the honest and trustworthy trade practice of Arabs, because the local people found difference between pre-Islamic Arab traders behaviour and post Islam the same Arab traders behaviour. With the passage of time the pattern of social life of people was affected by external forces they soon started to assimilate into the local community and borrowed many traits from other communities. External traits which have transmitted at different periods through process of diffusion was accepted and fused within local setup and social conditions already prevailing in the region.Thus slowly and gradually the caste system which was present in the brethren community took a new shape and it was modifiedand embraced by Muslims( few). There are differences of opinion among scholars and there are various definitions of the term “caste”, and therefore, various opinions on whether this term can be used to denote social stratification among non-Hindu communities. In independent India, Ghaus Ansari (1960) initiated academic discussion over the Muslim caste system. Subsequently, Imtiaz Ahmed elaborated the topic in his “Caste and Social Stratification among the Muslims” .According to M. N. Srinivas, an eminent sociologist, Indian Hindu converts to Islam brought their original caste system to the Muslim society in the region.Thus ‘caste consciousness’ is also noticeable among Indian Muslim (few).

Ansari uses the term “caste” to describe the Muslim social groups with following characteristics:

1)Endogamy within a given social group.

2)Hierarchical gradation of social groups.

3)Determination of the group membership by birth.

4)In some cases, association of an occupation with the social group.

Present day Muslim( few ) society in India is divided into four major groups. These are

1) Ashrafs consisting of Sayyads, Shaiks, Pathans and Mughals who trace their origin to foreign lands like Arabia, Turkey , Iran etc.,

2) The higher caste Hindus who were converted to Islam

3) The clean occupational castes

4) The converts from the untouchables castes: Bhangi (scavengers) or Arzal.

The Sayyads and Shaiks claim to be the descendants of early Islamic nobility of Mecca and Medina and they consider them superior than others. The Sayyads command respect from all Muslims and occupies the supreme social rank. The Sayyads in (some parts of) India who are casteist and boastful of their ancestry never marry outside their group.

The Shaiks ranks second on the social scale. The Mughals and Pathans reckoning their descent from the ruling families of past and occupies almost a relatively equal status. Ashrafs ( four above castes ) set them apart from the Muslim converts of Indian origin. Ashraf is a plural of word Sharif , meaning honourable and thus enjoy(most of the timeclaim ) the prestige.

Below the rank of Ashrafs are a number of clean occupational castes like Julaha (weaver), qasab or qasai( butcher) , Nai or hajjam(barber), teli(oil presser), Dhobi (Washer man) to name a few are some examples of clean occupational castes. The non-Ashrafs are categorized as Ajlaf.

The Bhangi are the Muslim untouchables . In some parts of India they are not permitted to enter into a mosque no matter how clean they are. Although in theory any human being should be allowed but in practice their entrance is restricted. Bhangis are allowed to learn the holy book, but they are not expected to teach it. Bhangis are given water in such a way that the jar does not touch even their lips. In Bihar, cases have been reported in which the higher caste Muslims have opposed the burials of lower caste Muslims in the same graveyard. In the recent years, separate mosques have been enacted by the “untouchable” Muslims against the rest, similar to what Indian Christians have in South India. Relationships between the Ashraf and Dalit Muslims are strained through endogamy and punctuated by commensal segregation. Not to our surprise, the neighbours have not left us alone to shame. The footsteps of caste system have crossed the borders of India and reached Pakistan, there is ‘caste consciousness’ and the concept of Pak (purity) and Na-pak (pollution) is being practised through endogamy and occupation.

By going through out this article the reader would have founda sharp contradiction between what was preached and what is being (was) practised. All those who practice any modified version of caste system in the name of Islam are ignorant and they should be educated then and there.

Note: The terms like Bhangi and other names were used not to degrade, but it was a humble endeavour to depict the reality as it is.

Reference:

Ansari, G. (1960).Muslim Caste In Uttar Pradesh. Lucknow,UP: The Ethnographic And Folk Culture Society.

Ahmad, I. (1963). Caste and Social Stratification among the Muslims. New Delhi : Manohar Book Service.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here