Dhanak, A Queer Feminist Group From JNU Extends Support To Hadiya

0
185

Dhanak, the queer feminist group of Jawaharlal Nehru University, extends its full and unconditional solidarity to Hadiya and Shafin Jahan. The case of Hadiya has gained much media attention by now and the facts of the case are out in the open – the conversion of Hadiya to Islam, the annulment and nullification by the Kerala High Court of the marriage of Hadiya and Shafin, the enduring house arrest of an adult, 24-year old woman, the multiple, pathetic utterances in the judgments that infantilise Hadiya and insinuate many unfounded things against her husband, and perpetuate the Islamophobic discourse of “love jihad”, and the dangerous and completely unnecessary ongoing NIA probe into the case that has been ordered by the Supreme Court of India – and do not require to be told and retold each time.

The most recent developments in the case are also perhaps the most terrifying. News from the NIA probe has found its way in major newspapers, including the Times of India (30th August 2017) and Malayalam media (Asianet). The NIA probe – which was ordered perhaps precisely to present the findings in such a way that would cement the annulment of the marriage of Hadiya and Shafin, extend her house arrest, criminalise Shafin and further the false discourse of “love jihad” and “radicalisation” – reports its findings predictably: that of Hadiya’s conversion being forced, of the marriage being a sham, and the entire conversion and later, relationship being part of a larger pattern of forceful conversions and even links Shafin to ISIS and indicts the Popular Front of India as a large scale force carrying out such actions. What will come of the probe can be predicted already, but if we are to prevent irreparable harm being done to either of the two people in question, and to create a popular and public resistance against the widespread discourse of “love jihad”, we must speak out now before it is too late. Videos have also emerged from outside Hadiya’s house showing her shouting and crying about being hit, visible from outside her window. This is beyond the mere question of house arrest – she is forced to live in direct and closed proximity with her parents, surrounded by police, and there is no information of the conditions she is being kept in.

As a queer feminist group, we would like to highlight certain issues and questions that should be raised in the continuing unconstitutional, illegal and strongly condemnable annulment of their marriage, the house arrest of Hadiya, the NIA probe, and the public and media demonisation of the couple in question.

Islamophobia and the Indian State

There is no question at this point and perhaps there never has been – it is undeniable that the Indian state and all its apparatuses are extremely Islamophobic in nature. Whether it is the Kerala High Court – a high court in the state that lays claim, almost always, on much progressiveness, even radicalism – or the Supreme Court, all are affected, even created on these foundations of Islamophobia and extreme anti-Muslimness. This is not a question of one right-wing government, or one aberrant incident. There have been many, many facets of this Islamophobia, manifested in everyday and extraordinary ways, through the very laws and rights that are seen as objective, rational, inclusive and as forming the basis for equality in the Indian state. There have not just been many other cases like Hadiya’s, but they have been easily tagged under categories of “love jihad”, and we do not even know how many lives have been ruined in this fashion. Islamophobia works in so many, numerous ways that unless we speak of these interlinked facets, it would be impossible to challenge it. Even in this case, it has been deployed in many ways- from the bogey of love jihad, to the aversion and suspicion on the conversion of a woman to Islam, to the highlighting of Shafin and the organisation he is linked to as irrevocably “criminal” and “terrorist” – the judiciary and the NIA have left no stone unturned in displaying the various ways Islamophobia functions throughout the arms of the Indian state.

On Hadiya’s Conversion, and its threat to Brahminism

While there has been solidarity for Hadiya and Shafin to the extent that it is seen as a violation of their constitutional rights to marry, to love, and Hadiya’s right to liberty and freedom, one question that must be seriously addressed is that of her conversion itself. The courts in question have consistently displayed doubt and disbelief towards not only the fact that she could choose to marry Shafin of her own accord, but more importantly, complete disbelief and even anger at her conversion. What is it about conversion to Islam – and away from Hinduism – that threatens the very foundations of the Indian state itself? If she is truly a powerless, 24-year old girl who doesn’t know what is ‘good’ for her, what is it about her decision to convert that has shaken everything and everyone around her? Her choice of doing so – if one cares to listen – has been an extraordinary one, and also one that so many other men and women have suffered for choosing in this nation’s past.

Hadiya has complete legal and constitutional rights to make the decision she did – but of course, legality and technicality is not what is even being considered here. If it was genuinely a question of legality, all of Hadiya and Shafin’s actions were in the legal frame of things. But when it comes to a question of a women transgressing the boundaries that Brahminism has set down for her, deciding to embrace Islam, and marry a Muslim man of her choice, all legality goes out of the window. If we must speak of choice, agency and freedom – we must also speak of why this decision, why this conversion has sparked so much outrage and trigger such events.

Of “Potential Patriarchs” and “Extremists”: Saving Women from Muslim Men

Recently in an article in The Wire, ‘prominent’ feminist activist and writer J. Devika perpetuated familiar stereotypes where she called Shafin a “potential patriarch” and tried to create a binary between the RSS and outfits of the Sangh on one side and the SDPI/PFI on the other, even as she admitted there was a significant power imbalance between these forces. The fact that in a piece that was meant to be a feminist defense of Hadiya, the writer chose to focus on the (inevitable) potential patriarchy endowed in the (Muslim) male body is actually entirely unsurprising, but nevertheless deeply problematic. The eternal project of saving women from Muslim men, Islam, and their own desires to either enter into more egalitarian faiths than the ones they were born in, or to love those seen as the eternal other has a long and wretched history in this country. It is not a new project. All through the twentieth century, for example, there have been organisations that have created the bogey of love jihad – in different forms and with different names – with absolutely unverified and unfounded claims of hundreds, even thousands of Hindu women who were ‘seduced’, ‘tempted’ or otherwise attracted towards Muslim men. There exists on record many historical pamphlets and writings that have laid claim to the same – and this continues in new and unprecedented ways well into 2017, including a clutch of Hindu nationalist websites that make similar claims about love jihad and conversion.

The fact that the Brahminical imagination can extend to fantasies of the inevitability of the potential Muslim patriarch, but cannot imagine a world where one may love freely, across caste, religious and class lines, is a testament to the impossibility of love in this ‘nation’ which is not just based on the rotten foundations of caste, as Dr. Ambedkar had written, but also one where the Muslim is the eternal other, one whose loyalties are always questioned, and one upon whom the labels of patriarchal (potential or actualised), ‘regressive’, ‘homophobic’, ‘terrorist’, ‘extremist’, ‘fundamentalist’ are always available to be used. This case, and the impunity with which the highest bodies involved in it are able to use these discourses in order to completely snatch away the most basic rights of Hadiya, is perhaps the best – or the worst – example of how Muslimness is criminalised and discursively produced to an extent that seems almost impossible to counter, but absolutely needs to be countered in any way possible.

Can any imagination – feminist, radical, liberal, queer, leftist, Ambedkarite – truly respect and recognise the possibility of Hadiya – or any other woman in her position – desiring, loving, wanting, and forming a companionship with a Muslim man, without casting aspersions, doubts or turning the full gaze of suspicion on them? Can our imagination even extend that far?

Beyond Liberal Politics of Choice and Agency

It is not merely the question of “choosing” – the right to convert, the right to marry, the right to marry across religious bounds, the right to be part of an organisation such as the PFI, the right to be free and not under house arrest. These rights, of course, in theory, exist for all people belonging to this nation-state. A language of choice and rights will merely inform us that all that Hadiya and Shafin did was legal and it is judicial overreach that is at fault here.

The truth remains that not all people, and not all communities have access to these ‘choices’ as easily as others; that not all communities in this country are even seen as deserving of citizenship and all that citizenship brings with it; that the language of liberal rights, freedoms and choices are not even an avenue that would ever be offered to two people so marked in their difference, in their Muslimness, in their deviance, and in their rejection of Hinduism in the case of Hadiya.

Criminalisation and Demonisation of Muslim Agency

The demonization of Shafin Jahan – and the organisation he belongs to, the Social Democratic Party of India, which is the political arm of the Popular Front of India – absolutely has to be interrogated when we speak of Hadiya and this case. This kind of production of stigma is not exclusively the domain of the Supreme Court or the NIA – the involvement of an anti-terror agency is a highly dangerous development in this, as we historically know from the demonization and stigmatisation of Muslim organisations such as SIMI or Campus Front of India and PFI itself. The Supreme Court has pointed to Shafin’s participation in SDPI and connected it to larger discourses – unfounded bogeys – of radicalisation and love jihad.

The erasure, demonisation and criminalisation of agency is a running thread throughout this case. Whether it was the agency of Hadiya to convert, or the agency of Shafin’s politics, or of their decision to marry, there is a complete denial of any possible Muslim agency. The involvement of the NIA will only spark off an even greater impetus to criminalise any form of Muslim political agency as terrorist, deviant, anti-national, violent or extremist. As history tells us, it has required the most innocuous of things as “evidence” to demonise Muslim organisations and Muslims associated with such organisations – whether it is innocent children’s books as in the case of SIMI – and in turn, these discourses are used to feed into other discourses of love jihad, of mentioning and dropping random, but very careful words such as ISIS, Syria, radicalisation, etc. that ensure that the needle of doubt and suspicion will never be fully revoked, even if this case falls through and all the rights of Hadiya and Shafin are restored to them.

Why We Speak as Queer Activists

As a queer feminist group, we are aware of the faultlines in what often forms our understanding of queer or feminist politics. Cases like Hadiya and Shafin’s, or the many cases in the past of alleged “love jihad”, and even cases in other parts of the country that involve people loving across caste and paying heavily for it – have often not formed part of what we deem queer politics, and our solidarities have mostly been tokenistic and/or absent. The defense we must hold up cannot be an abstract defense of “love” or “choice” removed from its axes of caste, class, religion, dis/ability, etc. Love is never beyond these identities and axes – and if we are to truly speak of a “queer” politics, we must “queer” our own understandings and formations of why we love who we love, and we why reject who we reject, and whom we consider worthy of solidarity and whom we consider to be beyond the domain of queerness and feminist politics.

If we are to truly see queerness as sticky, as something that must inform all our politics and our everyday lives, then we must look at our own failures as well. In our search for decriminalisation, in our search for privacy, in our celebration of “our” histories and “our” historic events, whom do we leave by the wayside? Where has the gaze of the Indian state turned (and where has it always, always remained) while we were seeking acceptance and our positions as rightful, legitimate citizens? While we celebrate the implications of the privacy judgement on 377, whose lives were falling apart? How has the rampant Islamophobia and casteism within our own queer politics produced and played part in these familiar discourses that can easily and comfortably enact endless violence on the Muslim body? We cannot count ourselves out, and erase our complicities.

The queer movement’s history has been intertwined with legal battles.These battles have never been easy, and while some have yielded partial results, the domain of law is always a deeply contested one. In this case as well, the court has invoked parens patriae – which can only be legally invoked in the case of a minor who is unable to take decisions for herself, which Hadiya is not. The court has consistently raised questions on Hadiya’s mind, on her decision-making, on her independence, and has completely invalidated and erased her status as a subject with constitutional rights. One cannot imagine kind of violence she must be facing in the conditions of her house arrest, guarded as she is by more than 20 policemen and her parents – who the court still sees as having her best interests at heart, despite displaying everything to the contrary. When all these actions and normalised and sanctioned under the law – what legal progress are we chasing?

An Appeal

We cannot claim to know or understand how it would feel to be in the position that Hadiya or Shafin are in today. But our solidarity as queer activists is firmly with the two of them, and with the countless others who have been vilified in this way.

We also appeal to the organisations on this campus who claim to be progressive and democratic to call for some form of demonstration to mark the injustice that is being perpetuated in this case, and to vocally stand in solidarity with Hadiya and Shafin. We may be very far away from the situation in question but it cannot be an excuse for silence or inaction. We are aware that elections are around the corner and this issue may be of little interest in this moment, but these questions cannot be suspended forever. As a campus, we must also introspect and examine our own participation in the discourses that make such horrifying developments possible, not see it as something that happens beyond the ‘progressive’ politics that we claim to pursue.

(This has been taken from the facebook page of Dhanak )

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here