The Power of Life
Human life is transient. Nevertheless, being transient doesn’t mean it is incapable. Rather, the transitory nature of life makes it phenomenally incredible. It subscribes life with the miraculous meaning of being ‘imperfectly perfect’. In physical definition, life is an operative phenomenon. All the material inventions and scientific discoveries around us reflect the brilliance of life. In the short spell of life, humans have the ability to achieve aspiring heights. They might succeed to climb up to the final step of their identified “ladder of success”. In short, life is full of dynamism, energy, and power. The question arises: do all people live the same kind of life? The answer indeed is no.
The “mechanism of life” is different for different people. Let’s explain the “mechanism of life” with an evocative water analogy. Water is in our routine observation. The water in a stagnant pond is characteristically different from the running water in a mountain stream. To maintain the purity, the latter has the motion and endurance to strike with rocks and fall from heights. While as, the former remains stagnant and, eventually, loses its features and turns foul.
The water analogy profoundly illuminates that stagnation; a lack of courage to face the hindering conditions, is loss of purity i.e. death of success. Inferring, for life it is impossible to make incredible achievements if certain conditions aren’t met. Those conditions might be demanding, perplexing, and grueling. Among all the conditions, the most vital condition is to maintain the ‘triangle of balance’ between behavior, time, and potentiality – the triangular equation of success. The ‘triangle of balance’ implies that the three sides of the triangle are correlational and each side is equally important by virtue of its equal contributing capacity. Once the condition is met, a person is capable of harmonizing/reforming/modifying his/her behavior with the contextual pressures of the time in order to transform the potentiality into actuality.
History testimonies the fact that whoever did it in the past; i.e., managed to achieve the ‘triangle of balance’, still live in the present and will be remembered in the future as well. Such people, not necessarily born geniuses, become ‘history makers’, ‘trend setters’ and ‘influencers’: in short, they become the milestone for others.
The “Triangle of Balance” and Human Nature
In the ‘triangle of balance,’ we have three sides namely behavior, time, and potentiality. The behavior represents the ‘externality of the action’. In the psychological description, before the performance, action is conceived cognitively. The conception of action at the cognitive level represents the ‘internality of the action’. When an action is repeatedly transformed from cognitive level to performative level, it becomes part of behavior. Time includes it’s both quantitative as well as qualitative dimensions. For example, in winters there is no agricultural activity in the fields of Kashmir.
If someone, overwhelmed by the will to work, invests hours (4-5 hours let’s say) on his/her field clearing the snow and frost and sows the seed, would he/she get the produce? No. The seed wouldn’t germinate in the first place. Why? Because, qualitatively speaking, it isn’t the appropriate time. Inferring, the two dimensions of time must converge to produce efficient action. Potentiality embodies the reservoir of unexploited organic energy. In the physical description, it is like the potential energy of the water reserved in the dam. The moment it falls, potential energy is changed into kinetic energy. Philosophically, the seed is the potential tree and the tree is the actualized seed.
The positive triangular equation of these three factors produces a structured and result-oriented action. An action that is transformative in nature; i.e. it transforms a lower level into a higher level. Nevertheless, all people can’t maintain the ‘triangle of balance’ throughout their life. It needs a tremendous level of consistency, courage, patience and will. Since human nature is, by default, weak, therefore, it impossible for man to be perfect and self-sufficient all the time. Having recognized the intrinsic deficiencies in human nature, Islam introduces the regulatory mechanism.
The regulatory mechanism is “self-control” (ḍabṭ an-nafs); i.e., a transformative movement from “self-dominance” (ḥaymanat an-nafs) to “self-discipline” (tarbiyat an-nafs). Since the “mechanical modeling” of present life has conditioned our mind to the extent that we firmly believe in the dogmatic exhibition of “self-dominance” as the only prompt approach to achieve success. But, unfortunately, oftentimes we either miserably fail or our success level doesn’t meet our expectations. The movement we realize it, we tend to deconstruct the psychology of “self-dominance” and move into the domain of “self-control”.
While deliberating on his theory of “ego depletion” Roy Baumeister, prolific American social psychologist, demonstrates that, “self-control is much more powerful and well-supported as a cause of personal success.” He goes on to admit that, “self-regulation failure is the major social pathology of our time.”[1] The psychological analysis of self-control brings about the fact that other psychological concepts such as “emotional control”, “habit-breaking”, “delayed gratification” and “performance regulation” directly depend on the method of “self-control” employed. From the Islamic standpoint, the idea of the “Reward and Punishment Method” (RPM) is one method of “self-control”.
Reward and Punishment from the Islamic Standpoint
Humans get affected by their respective contexts. The context is responsible for setting the external stimuli or calling them ‘living conditions’ that not just invoke but also alter the internal response or call it ‘cognitive behavior’. The interaction between stimuli and response shape our ‘behavioral pattern’- the actional disposition of one’s personality.
This implies if the ‘living conditions’ are encouraging enough to put the time, potentiality, and behavior in the ‘triangle of balance’ then life will become efficiently productive; i.e. meaningful life. In the otherwise case, when the ‘triangle of balance’ is not achieved, life becomes unproductive; i.e. meaningless life. Having said this, it is genuine to claim that if the ‘living conditions are changed or modified to a certain degree the equal degree of change will be imparted in the behavior. It is the natural predisposition of human behavior. Now, let’s analyze RPM theory within this context. Arguably, Islam recommends reward and punishment as a mechanism through which the ‘living conditions’ are changed to induce the required degree of change in the behavior.
Here, it must be clarified that Islam’s RPM is basically a psycho-spiritual method. It establishes a direct link between mind, soul and matter. Matter embodies the ‘living conditions’ or the conditions of, borrowing from Malek Bennabi, time and soil in their social meaning. That means all human beings, at the individual level, have the potential to change their ‘living conditions’ by recognizing the relation between mind, soul and matter. Reward and punishment are the two methods to recognize and reconnect this relationship.
Arguably, the sense of reward motivates the performing agency “to do”; i.e. mind and soul are encouraged to act materially in a preferred manner. On the contrary, the sense of punishment alarms the performing agency “not to do”; i.e. mind and soul are warned not to act materially in a not-preferred manner. Putting it in the moral language, reward drives the action towards what is morally right while as punishment impedes the action towards what is morally wrong. Similarly, in the legal framing, reward promotes the legally just social behavior while as punishment criminalizes the legally unjust social behavior.
Nature of Reward and Punishment
It is important to understand the dynamics of reward and punishment in Islam through its higher objectives. Here, I will refer to two. The first higher objective of Islam is to affirm the centrality (al-markzīyah) of God’s authority. The centrality of God’s authority means being conscious of the fact that God alone has the power to reward and punish for denouncing or performing a certain type of behavior. Implying, repetitive denouncing, or performing, in the psychological definition, should not habitualize the behavior.
The Qur’an is suggestive of experiencing the higher levels of psycho-spiritual behavior. In that sense, repetition is not just about replicating the action. Rather, it entails refreshing, or as I call it dehabitualizing through the conscious repeating of behavior to experience the higher level of underlying meaning and purpose.
In most of the psychological theories, for example, B.F. Skinner’s famous “operant conditioning” theory, the authority of God is not the necessary condition. [2] Speaking from the otherwise side if the behavior gets habitualized both meaning and purpose are lost. Consequently, habitualization eventually reduces the behaviour to its physical performance. The second higher objective of Islam is to regulate human affairs. Islam, through invoking the sense of reward and punishment, wants to establish peaceful and cooperative relations among humans. On the one hand, Islam prescribes punitive punishments for unjust, mischievous, hypocritical, oppressive and intolerant behaviours. On the other hand, Islam recommends unending rewards for just, peaceful, upright, truthful, and tolerant behaviour. All these behaviours have profound bearings on both intrapersonal as well as interpersonal human relations.
In the Qur’anic description, the eternal reward is heaven; the abode of everlasting peace, mercy and bounties, and the eternal punishment is hell; the abode of everlasting distress, pain, and torture. Heaven is the reward of belief and the righteous deeds or ḥasanāt (in Qur’anic terminology) that stem out from the ‘seed of belief’. On the contrary, hell is the punishment for disbelief and wicked deeds or saiyyiāt (in Qur’anic terminology) that stem out from the ‘seed of disbelief’.
Analogically, as the quality of seed decides the quality of stem, branches, leaves and fruits, the quality of ‘seed of belief’ will decide the nature of the reward. Similarly, the quality of the ‘seed of disbelief’ will decide the nature of punishment. In the context of eternal reward and punishment, human beings are enthused to transform; saiyyiāt behaviours into ḥasanāt behaviours, through the love of eternal peace and fear of eternal persecution. Some Muslims fallaciously relate the concept of reward with the idea of “delayed gratification” introduced by the American psychologist Walter Mischel in his famous marshmallow experiment. [3] Although, in one sense of the meaning, heaven is the reward to control the immediate animalistic desires and lustful needs, nevertheless, it doesn’t mean marshmallow theory entirely explains the philosophy of ‘reward motivated’ behaviour in Islam. For example, since marshmallow theory is devoid of any moral authority, therefore, it won’t bother about the ethicality of what is being delayed for whom.
References:-
[1] Roy Baumeister and K.D. Vohs, (2007). Self-Regulation, Ego Depletion, and Motivation, Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 1, 10, 1-14.
[2] B.F.Skinner, (1938). The Behaviour of Organisms: An Experimental Analysis, New York: Appleton Century-Crofts
[3] Mischel, Walter; Ebbesen, Ebbe B. (1970). “Attention in delay of gratification”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 16 (2): 329–337. doi:10.1037/h0029815. S2CID 53464175.

