For answering this question, we need to know what exactly feminism is. Anyone would define it as believing in the equality of men and women. That sounds reasonable. If this is true, then there should be no incompatibility between Islam and feminism. However, is today’s modern feminism really still purely about equality? This has become doubtful. From here on, in this article, the word ‘feminism’ refers to the modern Western third wave feminism. No one knows any more what exactly it is that today’s feminists want.
It is true that in many societies, women were historically oppressed since many ages, both by men and other women. They didn’t get equal opportunities to pursue education or employment. A lot of them didn’t have ownership or voting rights. However, what happens if you compare the Islamic society and the West?
The condition of women in the Arab society before the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was also the same. Islam liberated them. There’s an interesting story of the wife of one of the Prophet’s companions who was so rich and her husband so poor that she got the idea of giving Zakat to her husband. However, she didn’t know if it was allowed, so she asked her husband, who also didn’t know. He told her to ask the Prophet herself, as he was too embarrassed about it. She asked him and got to know that it was allowed, so she paid the Zakat charity to her own husband. If this is not women’s liberation then one can wonder what is. Our Prophet’s first and most beloved wife Hazrat Khadija herself was a 40-year old business lady whereas he was just a 25-year old shepherd. Women in the Muslim culture had the rights to ownership and making decisions in the 7th century itself whereas they didn’t have it in many Western countries till as late as the 20th century! Muslim women were pursuing education and imparting education since the Prophet’s days itself whereas women were being rejected from enrollment into Harvard Medical School until as late as the 1960s just because they were women. So does our society really need the feminism of the West?
Shortcomings of the modern third wave Feminism
The biggest issue with modern day feminism is that it is nothing but an extension of the ‘individualism‘ of the West. The basic assumption of the philosophy is that the individual is the basic unit of the society and that fulfilling our individual needs and wants should be our first priority. Contrary to this – nowhere in Islam has it been mentioned that we should think about ourselves first. It has always been a constant concern (fikr) of something more – the judgement day(Akhirah), the humanity (An-nas), worldwide Muslim community (Ummah), the society and the family.
Feminism is ill defined.
We have all kinds of feminists doing all kinds of things in the name of feminism. You have sincere feminists who fight domestic abuse and advocate equal education and employment opportunities for women. Then there are radical groups like the FEMEN from France, there are feminists making their male toddlers wear pink and play with dolls. All this is done in the name of equality of genders. Contrary to what many feminists want you to believe, gender is not a social construct. There are actual biological differences between men and women – even in their brains and behaviour. Can’t believe we are having to debate over this.
Playing victim and blaming others
Feminism fails to criticise women who are at fault. Just like there are bad men and good men, there are bad women and good women. Almost everything is blamed on patriarchy and men. Contrary to this, Islam says that the status of a person is decided merely by his/her actions and is not based on their race or gender. Bad women are admonished as equally as bad men. (I’m sure half of you must’ve gasped – How dare you call a woman bad! :P)
Feminism offers no practical solutions to these problems whereas Islam does. Feminists constantly keep saying – Don’t tell the women to cover up, tell the men to stop raping. Any practical person with common sense will say – why not do both? And Islam literally does that. The orders for the women to cover up and men to lower their gaze are in consecutive verses (24:30-31). In fact, men are told to lower their gaze first.
Feminism has assumed that the only way for a woman to achieve ‘self-actualisation’ is to go out of her home and work for other people rather than for her own family. It is literally in their books. It looks down upon women who have chosen to adopt a less stressful lifestyle and do the more important job of raising children and maintaining the family. Home-making and full-time parenting is thought of as something that only an uneducated or unskilled person would do. But is it really so? Is parenting an unskilled job? Does home-making not require brains? Can anyone even cook something without having the ability of learning it well?
No modern philosophy gives a mother the status that Islam has given. Not every woman has the stamina of being the over-worked, stressed out ‘supermom’ that the West idealises. Islam neither expects it from women nor rewards it. Service is very different from ambition, and even service is expected to be done closer to home. A Muslim girl will know very clearly whether motherhood is worth compromising on, or her career. She will make her Creator happy without feeling the need to prove anything to these people.
Ill effects of ill-defined Feminism.
In the USA, 50% of all marriages end in divorce. This skyrocketed from the previous 10-12%, due to the rise of feminism in the 1960s. 70% of these divorces are initiated by women. In Japan, 70% of men identify as ‘herbivore men’ as they have given up on marriage and women, as it’s just too stressful. And the sad thing is that this phenomenon is spilling over to the East too. Divorce rates are increasing in the Muslim community, even in Arab countries. Many people have begun to treat it as a normal acceptable phenomenon, probably, from an individualistic selfish point of view. But, what about the family and the society? It wrecks a havoc on children. It creates an unstable environment for both the sexes in which a lot of productivity is lost. But the most important for us should be – it is not liked by Almighty Allah (except for the genuine extreme cases).
The West is coming to its senses
There’s an interesting story of a feminist – Norah Vincent – who disguised herself as a man and spent 18 months with men and came out with a completely changed opinion on them. She literally stepped into a man’s shoes and walked around in them – the exact definition of understanding and empathy. A book called ‘The Surrendered Wife’ by Laura Doyle, that became a New York Times bestseller and highly popular with women, basically says – respect your husband and stop trying to control him all the time. What a revolutionary thought! So many women are joining the anti-feminist humanist movement. Conservatism is on the rise as can be witnessed by Brexit and the election of Donald Trump. While we may not agree with the politics of it, people are realising that conservation of our traditional values is very important for the greater good and for the long-term. Will our newly liberated society learn from the mistakes of the West and avoid them entirely or will learn after seeing failure themselves? It remains to be seen.
So what do we need to do?
Educate yourself about what Islam says about gender roles. This may not be a popular opinion, but Islam requires a woman to respect and obey her parents before marriage and the same rights get transferred to the husband after marriage. Does this mean inequality? Is it not possible to respect an equal? Islam requires both men and women to show the best of their Akhlaaq (manners) to their spouse and family first. It celebrates values like modesty(Hayaa) and patience (sabr) whereas there is no equivalent of such things in any modern philosophy. Islam says that even if there are only two of you, make one leader. The same applies to families. In corporations and workplaces, teams are usually made to work on various tasks, but how do you think a team would function if there was no team leader? In an ideal team, the leader wouldn’t consider himself superior to his teammates, nor would his team consider him so. It is only at times of disagreement that the team leader comes into the picture, and most of the times, the team is more than happy to oblige to his decision. A family is also a team, and Almighty Allah has made the husband the team leader. The wisdom behind this is only being understood now.
Most women, especially Muslim women and those of our culture, do find the present day feminists absurd in many of their opinions. We have plenty of guidance in the form of our Islamic and cultural values whereas the West doesn’t. However, their propaganda has entered our social media, our movies, our TV shows, news and even our society. One has to be very careful with what these are telling you. Actively differentiate and reject anything that is against the Islamic opinion. Embrace natural gender roles. Don’t reject traditional roles only because they’re old. Reject or accept them based on their merit.
So the next time someone shares something like – “Do what makes you happy”, give them a piece of your mind and say – No. Don’t do what makes you happy. Do what will spread happiness around you. Do what’ll make Almighty Allah happy. Do what’ll help make a happy family and a happy society. Only when you think of something greater than yourself can you achieve what everyone is desperately after – true happiness.


