Jadavpur On Fire: Take A Stand Or Stand Never

0
145

Every time Jadavpur University becomes the socio-political potboiler of our state, our routine drill of clearing rumors, taking stand and reasoning with our well-wishers begins. But when my friend asked me to write on this 19th September incident, I couldn’t write it. With due respect to our duty as student and researcher in social sciences to speak up, I never felt more disinterested. Because people around us do not see, do not listen, do not understand and do not care enough to even try: an apparently sentimental thought which only got stronger during last 13 days (or should I say months?). In these days I witnessed how ‘neutrality’ and ‘political correctness’ were turned into the biggest farces. Hence I am avoiding both of them in this article.

The evening of 19th September, I was in my home working when my parents called me from the drawing room: “look what’s happening in your university!”. It was past 7:30. I reluctantly walked out to see the news. The live telecast showed a burning pile of debris inside gate no. 4 (the main entrance of university), the demolished union room, some saffron-clad people swinging their clubs and sticks around the wreckage, some of them jumping at the top of a fire engine outside the gate, preventing that to come in, all of them screaming “Jai Shri Ram”. The reel changed to incidents few hours earlier: Babul Supriyo (singer, BJP leader and a union minister) is walking into the campus, pleasantly chatting with his officers walking side by side, followed by a handful of security; Supriyo is surrounded and being pushed by a large number of students, his bodyguards stretching their arms around him to guard, sensational headlines flashing below as ‘his spectacles fell off’, ‘shirt’s button torn’, ‘his hair pulled’, ‘fell on ground at one point’, ‘VC fell sick while trying to escort him out’, ‘the angry students refusing to move and letting him go without an apology’ etc. The reel went back to the current ruckus at gate no. 4: media interviewing some agitated students (some of them bleeding) inside the UG Arts building where they were showing the wreckage around; meanwhile the news flashed below, the governor and a big police force are coming to the campus to rescue the minister from the agitated students. Someone in the room said, ‘ki obostha eder! (what’s wrong with these students!)’. I couldn’t bear anymore and left the room.

On 19th September, amidst the agenda of celebrating five years of ‘Hok Kolorob’ movement in the main campus of Jadavpur University, ABVP, the student wing of BJP, planned to hold their Fresher’s welcome program (including a seminar on Indian political scenario post-independence) where they invited BJP leaders Agnimitra Paul and Babul Supriyo (also a union minister). Almost all other students’ organisations of the campus decided to protest against the event and stop them from entering the campus. After I left the room, things went like this: the governor rescued the minister. The 20th September, both the students’ union and the BJP leaders filed complaints against each other. ABVP and allied groups rallied near Park St. to condemn the students’ actions. The same day, an anti-terror and anti-fascism rally of students and teachers of Jadavpur University started from the main campus and later joined by other students and activists, number rising up to 6000. The blame game among the political parties continued. Babul marked two students from the media pictures in his Twitter handle as the primary instigators, demanding investigation against them, but forgave them at once when the ailing mother of one of those boys begged mercy for her son over media (after their names, colleges and whereabouts of their parents were flashed in every channel). Finally on 23rd September a big rally of ABVP and allied groups started towards the university to ‘gherao’ the campus until the university authority rusticates the group of students involved in heckling . The teachers and students of the university formed a human barricade at gate no. 4 while the police, well-prepared this time, successfully stopped the rally midway keeping them away from the university entrance. ABVP called off the rally later in afternoon.

It is not a new game. If anyone remembers 2016, when ‘Think India’ of ABVP invited director Vivek Agnihotri for a screening of his right-propaganda movie ‘Buddha in a Traffic Jam’ in the campus, things took the exact same turns- students’ protest, goons infiltrating campus, bigger rally to ‘teach lesson’, human-barricade to protect campus and police intervention at last. The specialty of 2019 is its scale of violence which was much higher than 2016: the saffron-army vandalized union room, the adjacent stationary shop, set things on fire (including mobiles and computer), entered the UG Arts building (went up to first floor) to damage further, beat up students, even hunted down some students on their way back home after things calmed down. The students might have feared this beforehand from the 2016 experience and wanted to stop the BJP leaders from entering at the first place; the party successfully anticipated this reaction, so the respected minister kept on fueling things inside while their cadres waited outside with their sticks, clubs and acid-bulbs. Let’s not get into a more detailed analysis of this neat sequential game and rather take a look at the pay-offs of this game in this changed political environment of West Bengal. BJP once again proved to mass how poor the law & order condition of this state is and how badly the ‘terrorist hubs’ like JU-JNU need a good leash. TMC condemned the involvement of the governor and BJP’s intervention into state matters using central power, and showed how efficiently Kolkata police stopped the second ABVP rally to maintain order (and also showed how vile and violent BJP is when the same police force failed to stop those goons from entering the campus). Left-front condemned the students but claimed their share of ‘moral victory against fascism’ as well, because whenever convenient, they have a ‘moral’ claim on any success of any leftist idea anywhere in the world. People relished over their popcorn entertainment of ‘those unruly drug-addict protest-lover entitled spoiled kids who never study’, lamented over how their precious tax-money is being wasted on creating terrorists and naxalites, and moved on to next headline. And at the end of the day, Jadavpur University stood alone- burnt, bruised and humiliated.

How does ‘neutrality’ look like? What do we mean by being politically correct? Almost every channel and newspaper reported the whole incident chronologically with the generic headline of ‘minister got harassed by students’. It is not difficult to understand which part of the incident got dialed down by the consequential effect. Even the makers of ‘Pink’ understood that, but our media was ‘neutral’, so the unbiased news-following people thoughtfully said ‘Yes, the vandalizing was bad but…’. Neutrality demands equal criticism irrespective of personal preferences. Political correctness is the cold disillusioned middle-ground which sees through every ‘best of humanity’ vision promised by the ideological extremes. But when the world slides down towards one side, standing in the middle does not help stop that. Neutrality and political correctness then become the moral high-ground to escape the dirty conflicts of reality. Sometimes we need to choose between being politically correct and taking a stand. Sometimes we can either stand on the moral high-ground or come down to protect it. This is probably the most important lesson I learned from this whole episode.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here