With repeated disasters and catastrophes, the world is facing one crisis after another, just two years after it suffered immense loss due to the Covid-19 crisis, where a large mass of the population had no access to basic necessities like food, medicine, and some even a roof on top of their heads, while many were not fortunate enough to receive a proper burial for their family members.
Another crisis that the citizens had to endure was in the beautiful town of Joshimath. The town is the gateway to several Himalayan mountain-climbing expeditions, trekking trails and pilgrim centres like Badrinath. It is located at a height of 6150 feet, inhabited by over 150 families and 640 residents, most of whom are working-class people.
Before the inhabitants of Joshimath could start recovering from the recent Covid trauma, they are facing yet another disaster – the sinking of their entire town. However, the essential question remains – is this a natural disaster or man-made? It needs to be understood that the level of land subsidence that caused Joshimath sinking is not common, acknowledging it is due to man-made actions resulting in the disaster. So, what has really happened in Joshimath, and what is land subsidence?
According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), subsidence is the “sinking of the ground because of underground material movement”[1]. It can happen for a host of reasons – natural or man-made – such as the removal of water, oil, or natural resources, along with mining activities, to earthquakes, soil erosion, and soil compaction.
A project that was undertaken in Joshimath in the name of tapovan-vishnugad project which had incepted in 2006 November has caused significant damage to the natural habitat of Joshimath. A Padma Bhushan recipient and noted environmentalist Anil Joshi was of the view that any construction beyond the height of 1000 meters “must be taken very seriously and approved only after thorough study. Before giving approval to hydro-power projects or land subsidence projects, the government must consider problems of the land or soil problems in Joshimath” as this land is at a height of 6500 feet above sea level. However, the government had not checked or considered the environmental concerns that were raised by several stakeholders, before beginning the project.
Several activist-groups raised awareness of its dangers and requested the government to stop the project. One such group was Joshimath Bachao Sangharsh Samiti (JBSS) whose convenor, Atul Sati, in a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, accused the Uttarakhand government of ignoring its warnings about the imminent disaster for 14 months and dealing with it now at a slow pace.
The Samiti also demanded the scrapping of NTPC’s Tapovan-Vishnugad hydel project, holding the building of its tunnel responsible for the imminent crisis in Joshimath. It said the L&T company was initially building the tunnel for the National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC), but had to quit as it was not satisfied with the way the corporation worked. The letter also mentioned a research paper published in an international journal in 2015 which said the tunnel was dug in the “Fault Zone”.
The Government should take full responsibility of this disaster; the hydropower project for extracting water from Joshimath has not benefitted the Joshimath citizens in any way, but has rather wreaked havoc in the lives of the inhabitants. Both the government as well as the corporate did not consider the concerns raised by the stakeholders, or the environmental guidelines before proceeding on the various projects – the focus has clearly been on maximising profits, at the cost of the people’s safety.
Many geologists have blamed the government for rapid construction works in the fragile Himalayas[2]. They say NTPC’s power project near Joshimath and Char Dham highways are damaging the nearby regions. This is yet another example of how the actions eventually cause man-made disasters, which leave people devoid of a home, food and water. Public properties are also damaged by cracks in the process, for instance in Joshimath around 600 buildings have developed cracks in them, and 4000 people have shifted to safer places. This shows the apathy and negligent behaviour of the Government towards its citizens and the environment.
The lives of the people have changed overnight post the disaster. Some demand cash compensation; some own land where they want to build houses, while others want to be relocated within Joshimath. Public awareness is needed, of both the aftermath of the disaster and what proceeded and allowed the disaster to take place. The culprits and the State should take responsibility and make efforts to restore normalcy in Joshimath. The stakeholders should be involved in the process and their voices should be heard and answered when they raise their concerns.
“When the whole world is silent, even one voice becomes powerful”– Malala Yousafzai
Lets awaken our conscience regarding the environment, and raise our voices for the people of Joshimath who have been suffering due to such disasters, and stand up to the estate and corporate entities like the National Thermal Power Corporation Limited (NTPC) who need to reform their agendas regarding the environment and take responsibility of the environmental refugees and help in the resettlement of affected people.
We must continue to educate and raise awareness of environmental policies, and the impact the State’s decisions have over our environment, and consciously play our role as stakeholders of the society to avoid another Joshimath like man-made disaster.
[1] https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/subsidence.html
[2] https://theprint.in/environment/why-is-joshimath-sinking-construction-on-unstable-land-poor-drainage-deforestation/1306070/

