Modi’s 10 Percent Is A Pandora Box

0
107

Ever since the BJP led NDA government decided to introduce a constitutional amendment bill in the Parliament to provide 10% reservations in jobs and education to the upper caste, it has opened a can of worms. Even though the move is a classic example of mass electoral bribing, its implications will have a long-lasting consequence, which in the current volatile atmosphere of our country should be the last card of communal politics. It seems the BJP has succeeded in placing other political parties on a sticky wicket by playing the reservation card, which is evident from the fact that many parties cutting across their ideological orientations expressed their support to the bill.

Without commenting on the timing of introducing the bill and the fact that almost entire lower house voted in its favor, there are three points in this whole episode which make it impractical, illogical and unimplementable. This bill is bound to fail the legal and judicial scrutiny for the following reasons :

1. Constitution doesn’t provide scope for reservations based on an economic criterion. The concept of the reservation was introduced in the institution, not as a poverty alleviating tool, but to help the marginalized and trampled communities come in equal with the rest of the population. In the Indra Sawhney case, Supreme Court was explicit in underlining the point that economic condition couldn’t be the sole deciding factor for granting of reservations.

2. The Indra Sawhney Union of India & ors verdict of 1999 is the benchmark, and a source of reference for the issue of reservations has put a cap of 50% for providing the reservations. Now, this attempt is a clear violation and disrespect for the Supreme Court’s orders and is nothing more than dirty politics and contempt of court.

3. The criteria laid down for getting reservations has indeed opened a Pandora box. The definition for the deciding factor, i.e., the economic level /poverty level, is itself in contradiction with the government’s definitions mentioned in poverty line estimates such as Tendulkar Committee. For example, while providing reservation to OBCs the government has classified them into two sections; Creamy layer and noncreamy layer

To distinguish between these two, a demarcation has been created with the help of income levels. Those OBCs earning below 6 lakh annually come under non-creamy layer and are eligible for 27% reservations, whereas those earning above 6 lakh forfeit their right to reservations. In other words, an OBC earning more than 6 lakhs annually is not entitled to reservations. But the proposed legislation has fixed the threshold for availing reservations at 8 lakh. To put it simply, an upper caste earning below 8 lakh is eligible for reservations. Isn’t it weird? An OBC earning 6 lakh isn’t eligible for reservations but an UC earning the same is eligible for it.

It is not that the government is unaware of these loopholes, but for the mere pleasure of vote bank politics it seems to be playing with the sentiment of citizens. It’s a time when the country’s atmosphere is getting increasingly volatile day by day with battles for asserting identities and growing suspicions among communities. Added to the situation is the ever growing list of demands from various forward classes for reservations like Jats, Gujjars, Marathas, Patidars and so on. If the current trend prevails the condition is only going to get worse.

This move by the government has not only created ripples in social strata of our country but has provided with an opportunity to critically analyze and discuss the whole topic of reservations. It has been 7 decades when the concept of reservations was materialized, the demographics and social conditions have changed. It might be the most appropriate time to reset the discourse on reservations and critically evaluate how much it has helped in the emancipation of the downtrodden, and what should be the road ahead for creating an egalitarian society.

To get a better picture of reservations on the whole, it would be better to go back for a while to the events surrounding the Indian independence. It was a period when people of certain communities were considered untouchables and denied access to even the basic human rights. Birth would decide the level of dignity a man could be offered. Birth in a Brahmin family would entitle a person to a lifetime of glory, respect, and dignity whereas birth in a Shudra family would result in a life full of slavery, insult, and disgust. The shudras couldn’t draw water from the community well, pray in the temples of upper castes or even allow their shadows to fall on savarnas.

As a result of this discrimination, for centuries together, emerged the unimaginable and pitiable conditions of shudras. They were pushed back and discriminated socially, politically and economically.

Their rights subjugated, their voices silenced, their minds enslaved, they were no more than creatures born to serve the savarnas.

When India emerged independent, technically, every Indian was equaled and had equal and same rights and responsibilities.

But the centuries of slavery and servitude had so deeply impaired them that they were in no position to compete and thrive with the rest of the citizenry, the upper castes and dominant classes were way ahead in terms of knowledge, skills, expertise and wealth.

At this juncture, equality wouldn’t mean treating different people in the same manner. Instead, true equality would mean creating equal opportunities and making sure that everyone would have the same head-start. For this purpose, a special arrangement called reservation was proposed.

It may be well remembered that the purpose of the reservation was socio-political emancipation of Dalits. The makers of our constitution knew that unless the Dalits are provided with a protected enclave, they won’t be able to survive socially and politically.

Reservations have indeed helped in great magnitude for uplifting the Dalits. As a result of which we see Dalits enjoying major and prominent positions in almost every sphere of life, which was hard to imagine without reservations. But the other side of the coin shows us a different picture. Even today some sections of the Dalit community are subjected to abject poverty, discrimination, and exclusion. A long time of seven decades has passed, but still, the Dalit community hasn’t risen up to the mark. Obviously there’s something wrong with the system.

When one goes deeper in this topic, we find that the current system has helped only in creating clusters of educated, wealthy and powerful Dalits among the rest. The fruits of reservations appear to be centralized in urban and literate sections of the Dalits. As the urban and literate Dalits have access and exposure to quality education and opportunities, they have performed well. But their brethren residing in rural and backward areas have been unable to reap the benefits of reservations due to little or no exposure at all. Illiteracy among the upper castes is also a reason that they tend to suppress and subjugate the Dalit population. Brought up in a feudal mindset makes them assume that Dalits are meant to be subjugated. Only if they were taught the lesson of brotherhood and equality, they could have known the gravity of their actions.

Now, the question arises that when the current policy of reservations has failed in the emancipation of its target what should be the next step. At this juncture, two suggestions may be made.

1. Education within everyone‘s reach : The only sure way to social and economic uplifting is universalizing the Education. The government must ensure that none of its citizens are left illiterate. Education not only imparts knowledge but widens one’s horizons. It equips him with the ability to judge what is wrong and what is right. More importantly, the government education system has to be proactive in this regard. Let the private institutions flourish, but ultimately it is the responsibility of the government to see that nobody is denied the fruits of education due to financial or social inability. The network of educational institutions must be spread to the extent that even the remotest of hamlets and habitats are within its reach. The quality of education and infrastructure must be its prime feature. When everyone is provided access to quality education, it forces them to be confident, rationale and scientific in their lives. When this happens automatically, the venom of casteism which runs in our veins shall get drained out. Also, when everybody gets the same education and from same institutions, it would slowly but definitely lead to the paving of a level playing field. In this manner, the main intention of providing reservations is achieved. Dalits would no longer need the crutches of reservations to live, and the UCs wouldn’t have a reason to target Dalits for having snatched their opportunities.

2. Eradicating the casteist mindset : At the end of the day, it’s the mindset which makes people consider themselves superior to some others. Without curing this disease no amount of reservations would be successful in the emancipation of Dalits. Only if a Brahmin considers a Dalit as his own brother only then one could hope for a nation free from casteist barriers. Every scripture, every teaching, every ideology that teaches casteist discrimination must be weeded out from our curriculums. It must not be the laws which should provide a place for the weaker sections but our hearts and minds which must sacrifice themselves for the sake of their brethren. The curriculum must be drafted in a way that every citizen must feel empathy towards the oppressed and disadvantaged. And it’s not just a figment of imagination but the world had seen an example of this phenomenon 14 centuries ago. After the Islamic revolution in Arabian peninsula, a chieftain wouldn’t mind sitting with a slave and following him in the namaz. Obviously there were no reservations which compelled them to do so, but it was the revolution of hearts and minds which ignited the flame of fraternity in them.

The world desperately needs such a revolution once again.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here