Public schools lack Educational Environment

0
174

No society can claim to be normal without the culture of knowledge and the schools imparting education that encompasses the various aspects of universe. Schools are the places where one can be imbibed with the essence of right and wrong.

Hyderabad was once a city famous for not just its rich state but also for the highly educated people who excelled in a variety of fields. Asif Jahi dynasty had contributed immensely towards education. In fact, the similitude of Hyderabad was that of education and training, civilization, character and cultural extravaganza. Meer Uthman Ali Khan did not leave any stone unturned in terms of educational matters. The city in early 20th century became world famous for its educational standards. The state genuinely served the educational needs of masses irrespective of religion, caste and class in those times. There was common curriculum and equal educational resources.

The city of Pearls constituted one of the finest educational hubs in the country with required number of modern educational institutes to be on par with ever growing standards of education and teaching. Foundation of Osmania University aka Jamia Osmania was one of many initiatives in this direction. It was established 3 years well before the famous Aligarh Muslim University. The standard of education in Osmania University was on a par with any international university of the time.

School education in the city of Hyderabad was on par with the Higher education and students were adequately trained to be part of the high standards of Osmania University. Each locality in the state of Hyderabad had at least a Primary, Middle and High School. State had the system of free distribution of curriculum books and notebooks. No wonder the last Nizam is still remembered by inhabitants of Hyderabad as “Sultan-ul-Uloom”, the king of knowledge.

One might draw inspiration from the Chinese legend that emphasizes on human resource development as the key to centuries-long progress and prosperity as against the yearly or decade-long plan that demands a certain minimal-target-based efforts.

No country or nation can cease to fail if not for its educated lot. Their contribution in a form of policy-making institutes is invaluable which is nothing but the result of educational system. Kothari Commission rightly points out the undeniable fact that “India’s future planning is happening within the four walls of her schools”!

Having said it all, the city of Hyderabad, with its illustrious history of education now succumbs to decay in government school education, especially in the last three decades. All the while only the teachers have been made the scapegoats of this educational catastrophe.

Hyderabad constitutes around 70 lakh and more people. It now has half as many government schools as there were before independence, a fact that throws light on the plight of our public sector education system. Moreover, lakhs of people below the poverty line who can only dream of a fairer access to education live in nearly 1,400 slums in the city.

As per statistics, we have only 501 Primary, 6 Upper Primary and 182 High schools against the nearly 1000 schools before independence. While the population has grown manifold, the schools have had been disproportionally decreasing.

As per statistics, we have only 501 Primary, 6 Upper Primary and 182 High schools against the nearly 1000 schools before independence. While the population has grown manifold, the schools have had been disproportionally decreasing. Economically well-off families prefer the private sector whilst the lower economic class of late has finally marched towards private sector, thus leaving the estranged public sector school education to a grinding halt at the verge of vanishing. Some of the grave concerns in this regard are discussed further.

Privatization of Education:

In 1991, Narasimha Rao-led Congress regime started the liberalization of economy which resulted in the privatization of Health and Education. On one hand it helped improve the quality of education, but education also ended up becoming a mere commodity. Founders of schools have become business owners with students serving the job of a servant in disguise. Governments failed to upgrade schools to match the growing needs of education. Eventually Education became just another industry. Businessmen foresaw a bright future in the “educational industry”, which in fact was a disaster in making. Although many regulatory measures and strict rules were brought in as more private players showed interest in the field of education, the corrupt middlemen always prevailed in the system and have had been making a joke of these rules and regulations. Moreover, the huge costs involved in establishing schools force the management to find other ways to get the benefit of investment it had put in! Parents have succumbed to management’s antics in this regard. Lavish advertisement of quality of education in private schools and flamboyant buildings with every possible amenity trap the parents into spending handsome amounts on school education, irrespective of the ground reality.

There is a huge gap between corporate private schools and the government schools in terms of teachers, their trained skills and policy-making individuals. These are a must in every corporate institute, as against government schools with no promising talent. Forget the training and skill development programs, government barely took any initiative to increase the budget to solve the myriad of issues in teaching.

Lack of Educational environment:

Land prices in Hyderabad are at an all-time high, which impacted formation of any new government schools, thanks to the low budget that gets sanctioned for school education. Government started acquiring rented buildings for government schools. People lost all confidence in government-run schools. Whatever money gets pumped for such schools, only results in poor infrastructure including small and dark rooms, no toilet facilities, inadequate drinking water, insufficient furniture and lack of supportive educational material, all factors playing against the popularity of government schools. Contrary to this, private and corporate schools have good infrastructure. Any efforts by government to optimally spend the public money on own building and improving the infrastructure of government schools would be a proper service to the educational needs of the public and the disadvantaged especially.
The system in place allots teachers according to the ratio of students, thus pushing teachers to put in extra efforts to fulfill the needs of students. This often ends up creating the bizarre condition of education-less education institutes. This practice must change with immediate effect by allotting teachers based on the needs of the each class. This would radically better the plight of government schools. There must always be a Head Master functioning in the school. Cleanliness especially in the educational institutes is invaluable. Primary classes more than anything else require language teachers to instill linguistic understanding among students. Since 2000, government has been allotting Vidya Volunteers, a rather untrained lot of teachers for a temporary duration, only to adversely affect the already struggling schools. Increasing the allotment of permanent trained teachers and radical change in the screening process of teachers are the needs of the hour. Moreover, teachers’ retirement during the academic year is another issue to be addressed. Bringing government schools on a par with current educational standards by enriching the schools with computer lab, Library, Projector and other vital infrastructure is a must. Regulation with respect to formation of private schools must be followed stringently. Insincerity and irresponsible behavior from teachers should be taken into serious account by educational officers, and bad teachers eliminated.

Inspection Issues:

Inexperienced and irresponsible educational officers are not at all helping the government schools get empowered in the desired manner. It has been observed that to inspect Urdu medium schools, sometimes non-Urdu educational officers are appointed and vice versa. Educational officers must be promoted based on skills and not on seniority.

Teachers and Teachers Unions:

Unnecessary teachers unions, union leaders unaware of the myriad problems in education system and lack of healthy relation among teachers, parents and other stakeholders of education system are also to be blamed for the plight of government schools. Unions could play a vital role by bridging the gap between the teachers and parents, and can themselves affect the educational system positively as their circle of influence is better on the education system outside the classroom or school.

The aforementioned and scores of other problems are the reasons we see vanishing government schools. This situation is made worse by educational officers who are not at all in touch with other stakeholders of education. Child labor and poverty result in dropouts. While there are some good non-governmental organizations working to improve the condition of schools, there are many rubber-stamp organizations functioning too with respective financial agenda that need an immediate purge.

In 2007, the then Hyderabad Collector, under the grab of rationalization, abruptly closed 282 schools in Hyderabad. This drew the attention of several organizations and the stakeholders of education and was followed by a pool of protests, apart from discussion in the legislative assembly. Depending too much on statistics to implement rationalization of schools is a mistake that has to be corrected. The subject-wise and class-wise allotment of teachers in High schools must be emulated for Primary schools too.

Although the literacy rate in India has been increasing in the past 3 decades, it came with a relinquishing cost of lack of values in Education. Privatization in education started in 1990, and since then there have been many circulars issued by government to control and recognize the private schools. In the guise of fulfilling the needs of underprivileged and poor, schools that charge average fees have been subjected to the rules and regulatory measures of government while the influential and corporate groups in education easily slips from the hands of government. For a private school to get recognized, a lot of money is required and thus low-cost schools fail to get themselves recognized. Government’s blatant hypocrisy comes out openly upon a cursory look at the rules and regulations bound for the private schools which are no way followed in government-run schools. Right from foundation to the management of school, every rule gets breached by government schools. The emphasis on quality of education given in private schools is rarely followed in government schools. Same goes with the infrastructure in government schools. It is imperative of government to fix the corruption and loopholes in education system to help private partners in education function properly as well as control the business that has been carried out in the name of education. Commercial property tax, Electricity Bill and Water Bill demand on private school buildings have led the management to find illegal ways of demanding money from parents.

The state of Andhra Pradesh introduced a Circular on 1st January 1991 for the foundation of private schools. It has been amended time and again to fulfill the requirements of education system. This circular still plays a crucial role in the State of Telangana. Recognition of private schools is subjected to the availability of trained and experienced Head Master and teachers, scope for indoor and outdoor games and healthy sports, experimental labs for science and other subjects, library to promote reading culture, NOC certification from Fire Brigade dept., Traffic Police dept., Govt. certified Civil Engineer and from Health Dept. etc. Each and every aforementioned rule must be followed by the schools and onus is on the government to implement the same. There must be enough accountability in place for government schools to follow the said rules. If the government is not able to follow all these rules and regulations in its own institutions, how it expect private parties, especially the low-cost schools, to fulfill these requirements? Isn’t it unrealistic? This whole fiasco has led to an unwanted entity emerging as the biggest stakeholder in the education system of the state, the so-called “corporate group”. Corporate institutes have successfully converted the states’ education system into a business model. These institutes invest money and claim the profit back come what may, paving the way for a consumerist attitude among other stakeholders of education. Corporate sector unequivocally exploits the students, parents and teachers. Apart from inspecting the misconduct and irregularities prevailing in private schools, there must be an environment to help solve the genuine problems that hinder the empowerment of schools.

Suggestions to address the loopholes in the rules and regulations imposed by government for schools:

  1. Whole country faces a dearth of well-trained teachers. Every year Vidya Volunteers get allotted in government schools on a temporary basis. If there private schools are mandated to employ trained teachers only, why are then government schools given an open window to recruit untrained teachers? Untrained teachers employed in private schools must be oriented during non-academic times.
  2. Schools located in residential areas with low traffic density should be exempted from NOC certification of traffic department.
  3. Playgrounds offered by Municipalities charge Rs10,000 for a mere usage of around 30 hours per year. Immediate steps should be taken to freely avail playgrounds for schools. Here too, private schools get pushed to construct playgrounds while there are huge irregularities in government schools. It shows how the present system is not helping either private or public sector education.
  4. Fire extinguishers are enough in case of any unfortunate incident of fire but expecting the management to have the complete fire-fighting infrastructure inversely affects the students as management fulfills this requirement through higher tuition and maintenance fees. Renewal of Fire NOC must be made compulsory once in 10 years as against current once in every year. Electricity and water bills should be charged as per domestic norms rather than commercial taxation. Property tax must be abolished for private schools. Recognition process which is rather tedious and prone to corrupt practices should be averted by restricting it to just the education department. Only a state that empowers government schools and help private schools run properly for the benefit of students deserves to be called as a welfare state.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here