Reply To Nadim Asrar’s Open Letter To Shehla Rashid

0
130

This is a reply letter in response to the open letter written by Nadim Asrar, former AMUSU President, to Shehla Rashid.

To my unfortunate!

Mr knowledgeable sir, I neither know you nor have I ever had a chance to meet you in person keeping my standing of just 2 years here in AMU in mind. I am writing the reply and by doing so I am advocating neither AMUSU nor the JNUSU. There are calls from various quarters to ignore the diatribes but deconstructing the imperial narratives is an essential exercise.

Mr. Knowledgeable sir! kindly bear with me if I may have any linguistic and interpretative errors as I am not very well versed in English.

Sir! ( I am rather confused whether to call you brother, keeping the Aligarian legacy in mind, or sir) The men in Aligarh are pretty much used to listening to women than men in any other Indian university. Kavita Krishnan, I may add to your kind knowledge, has recently spoken on the “women’s rights”, a demonstration was held by a group of female students here in the campus on 14th of February and was very well supported by the male members of the varsity. We previously had Kamla Bhasin, an Indian developmental feminist, social worker and writer. We, here in AMU also had Zakia Soman, a leading Women’s Rights activist and founder of Bhartiya Muslim Mahila Andholan. Besides, during the last year we had your comrade Shehla Rashid and Kawalpreet as our speakers. The men here in Aligarh have long ago left male chauvinism.

Further sir! If Aligarh, that you claim in your letter, has been a place of ‘Progressive Writers and Academicians’ in the country how come is it possible that they were themselves not progressive or they didn’t support “Progressiveness”. This evidently clarifies your statement to be self-contradictory .

The problem is not the comrades or any other left or liberal minds entering the premises of the campus but it can be judged on the grounds of rationality, that the meet was “ALL INDIA STUDENTS MEET” and I believe you know, there are student leaders beyond Delhi as well. Student leaders in JNU and DU, without any doubt have redefined the student politics but there are leaders in south and central India who have contributed no less than the leaders in Delhi and have at times outshone them. We also condemn the FIR filed against your comrade Shehla Rashid, but you surely would have the knowledge who filed the FIR, a female cabinet member Ghazala Ahmad.

“Tempo High Hai” mocking is ironic, as I am told that you were former President of the AMUSU and one thing about “TEMPO High Hai” is sure that your presidentship may have been the product of the same rhetoric, the same slogans. This is sheer hypocrisy on your part that the same rhetoric which made you the leader of students here in AMU is being mocked upon by you.

As far as the controversial post is concerned, the students here in Aligarh better understand the “Quote” “Unquote” and in this matter no lessons from anyone be he/she a JNUite , DUite or from any other university will be entertained. Freedom to interpret meaning still exists and AMUites are mature enough to interpret the “QUOTEs” “UNQUOTES”

Sir! It is not about, tradition and victimhood alone but the matter is about an ideology for which an institute stands. If JNU can stand united to its ideology and ban the Cambridge academician Subramaniam Swami and Yoga Guru Baba Ramdev (let aside their political allegiance) from entering the premises of its campus, why can’t AMU defend its ideology banning the left ideologue meet which actually was a student leaders meet and yes a victimized nation can do nothing else than showing its victimhood. A victimized, sir, I think, should never hide its victimhood because that empowers the victimized.

And one last thing I may like to add that it is not being submissive to religion and tradition because, Sir I am sure that, you too during the time of your election campaigning would have addressed from the dais of Union Hall the students calling them the “Alambardaars” (upholders) of “Tahzeeb”(tradion). AMU stands for tradition and we want to keep it up.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here