26th February 2018 marked 500 days of Najeeb’s disappearance. Najeeb disappeared on 15th October 2016 from JNU campus, after he was brutally assaulted by a bunch of ABVP members in his hostel room the previous night. Since October 2016, his mother, Fatima Nafees, his brothers Mujeeb and Hasib and his sister Sadaf Irshad have protested in different parts of the country, from Delhi to Bihar to Kerala, in the hope of finding Najeeb. On Monday (26th February), on the call of Fatima Nafees, there was a protest outside CBI headquarters of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in Delhi. This protest was needed because CBI has been guilty of acts of omission: failing to take Najeeb’s assailants into custodial interrogation, failing to look into the Delhi police’s falsely concocted story of Najeeb having been seen in an auto-rickshaw; and acts of commission: derailing the course of justice by overseeing a snail-paced case.
But even as the CBI has failed to make any headway into the case and even the Delhi High Court, back in October 2017, refrained from instructing the CBI to do its job, Najeeb has been framed as a terrorist by various sections of the media, public intellectuals affiliated to the Sangh and even by the government officials. In November 2016, the then Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, Najeeb Jung, was reported to have said that Najeeb had been seen in the city of Darbhanga in Bihar, a city which has been framed as being a terror hub of the Indian Mujahideen. The linking of Najeeb with Darbhanga was not co-incidental; there was definitely a motive to throw disrepute on Najeeb, especially in November 2016, when there was a certain amount of outrage about Najeeb’s disappearance.
In March 2017, after several months had passed since Najeeb’s disappearance, a report in The Times of India reported that Najeeb had searched for information on the Islamic State. The report claimed that the Delhi police was looking into the possibility of Najeeb “getting radicalised and being lured away via Nepal.” Even though Delhi police denied this claim, this report was not retracted and no apology was offered by the journalist who carried the defamatory story. This news was later picked up by right-wing fake news websites such as Postcard news. This report is still available in the public domain, despite requests by Najeeb’s mother that it should be taken down.
This deliberately planned strategy of branding a forcibly disappeared student as a terrorist is intended to salvage the image of the Delhi police, the Home-Ministry appointed Special Investigation Team, the Crime Branch and now the CBI, all of whom have been appointed to investigate the case of Najeeb’s assault and disappearance but have failed to do their duty. Najeeb is not there to defend himself and does not even have powerful voices defending his innocence; but the anti-Muslim right-wing media persists in calling him an ISIS sympathiser. If the media can establish that Najeeb escaped to join the ISIS, then it can be said that Najeeb’s disappearance had nothing to do with the fact that he was assaulted. In fact, the entire conspiracy to frame Najeeb is to give a clean image to ABVP and also to those investigative agencies who are more intent on protecting ABVP than finding Najeeb. Besides, by proving that Najeeb is a terrorist and not a Muslim student who faced a murderous attack in JNU, these Islamophobic accusations try to establish that Najeeb is not deserving of justice, that he is the criminal and not the victim, that he himself is responsible for his disappearance and not anyone else. Whenever the member of a minority is victimised, his victimisation is explained away by false narratives which are built just to appease the Hindu majoritarian sentiment in this country.

Since May 2017, the case of Najeeb’s assault and subsequent disappearance has been entrusted to the CBI. There have been protests outside the CBI headquarters in July and October 2017. On 14th October last year, there was an over-night sit-in at the CBI. But the CBI has not cared to listen to these protesters, especially when most of these protesters have been Muslims.
On February 26th, another protest was held at CBI. But even before the protest could start, the fake news industry had again become active in circulating the ‘news’ that Najeeb disappeared in order to join the IS. This time, there was the involvement of senior BJP leaders like Ram Madhav and Jaswant Singh and even a public intellectual (affiliated to the Sangh) and journalist Swapan Dasgupta in tweeting and re-tweeting fake news. Vikram Singh, BJP MLA from Fatehpur, mocked Najeeb on Facebook and wrote that Najeeb had joined the IS for “global jihad” and that Naxalite students from JNU, HCU, Jadavpur University etc are encouraging the spread of jihad. Later, he deleted his post, but it was obvious that his intention was to deny any involvement of ABVP, BJP and the Sangh in the assault and disappearance of Najeeb. Twitter influencer Shefali Vaidya tried to delegitimise the protests for Najeeb by linking his name to the IS. Vaidya was corrected by Gaurav Jha, former JNUSU presidential candidate from ABVP; true to his ABVP credentials, Jha was more interested in maintaining a fellow-Sanghi’s credibility and did not have any “sympathy with Najeeb”, as per his own tweet. When it was reported that this rumour is baseless, these people simply “un-tweeted” their tweets and did not bother to offer any apology or explanation into the actual reason behind Najeeb’s disappearance. Their tweets were re-tweeted by many others, all eager to otherise a Muslim man and brand his as a terrorist. Branding an already victimised minority probably gives a thrill to these deceitful people.
Framed by JNUSU President and other students
While it is essential to highlight the extent of the tweets put out by the BJP IT-cell and social media influencers and opinion-makers, and to call attention to the fact that none of these people offered any apology for concocting Islamophobic news about Najeeb when their falsity was exposed, it is also important to remember how Najeeb was first branded as an offending student by the then JNUSU President, his roommate, the former and sitting presidents of the hostel where he lived and the Hostel warden. On 14th October 2016, even as Najeeb suffered grievous injuries from a group of ABVP members, these individuals got together and wrote and signed a letter which stated very clearly that the incident of violence which happened that night was started off by Najeeb himself and that Najeeb should be expelled from that hostel for this reason. In short, that letter signed off Najeeb’s innocence and put the entire blame on him, even though Najeeb was the one who got assaulted and given death threats. These letter-writers were not concerned for justice for Najeeb; for them too, it was easier to blame a defenceless, vulnerable Muslim student than a group of ABVP assaulters. Till this day, neither the JNUSU President nor the other students have offered any public apology for betraying Najeeb at a time when he actually needed them. When it comes to standing by a victimised minority student, both right-wing trolls and left-wing union leaders prefer to appease majoritarian sentiment than upholding the principles of justice.
How JNU gave up on Najeeb
It is not just the former JNUSU President who must take the blame for betraying Najeeb. Even the rest of the largely left-dominated campus has neglected to stand up for ‘Justice for Najeeb’. The irony is this, that while the Sanghi media mocks JNU for supporting a “terrorist”, JNU actually does not bother to carry out any protest with commitment and conviction. Today, protests for Najeeb are held only before a hearing is scheduled to be held in the High Court, as if protesters are expected to determine their protests by the time-table of India’s Brahmanical judiciary. Moreover, these protests are not called by anyone in JNU; they are organised instead by Muslim activists such as Nadeem Khan in Delhi. At the protest outside CBI on the 26th of February, JNU students, mostly from leftist organisations (both mainstream and individual), did not participate in breaking police barricades. Apart from a couple of students from BASO and BAPSA, the rest were all indifferent, preferring not to get mixed up with “anti-left forces.” These “anti-left” forces are none other than Muslims, either from the ‘United Against Hate’ group (which has been active in organising protests after the lynching of Junaid in June last year) or students from Aligarh Muslim University; UAH and AMU activists formed the bulk of the protesters on that day. These Muslims stormed the police barricades in front of CBI, facing police brutality and sustaining injuries as a result. It is highly deplorable that instead of joining hands with them, students from AISA, SFI, AISF and Collective chose to remain mere onlookers. In fact, Collective had even scheduled a solidarity protest for TISS students (who have been protesting against exorbitant fees) at the same time as the ‘Chalo CBI’ protest; they changed the timing only when it was pointed out to them that the two protests would clash. It seems that JNU leftists are more concerned about maintaining the ideological purity of their protests than to actually join hands with protesting Muslims. If one points out that Najeeb’s attack must be apprehended as an attack on a Muslim student one will be condemned as indulging in petty “identity politics”. But the irrefutable fact remains, that the ones exposing themselves to the carceral state for the sake of Najeeb are Muslims themselves. JNU has unapologetically given up on Najeeb.
Also read Tracking Left Unity in JNU on How (Not) to Fight Fascism
Conclusion
Najeeb’s assault and disappearance must force us all to ask how safe are Muslim students in universities like JNU. The enrollment rate in higher educations is the lowest for Muslims; the limited presence of Muslim students in JNU will be further jeopardised unless active measures are taken to secure the life and liberty of vulnerable Muslim students. But no such measures have been taken till date. What has been seen instead, is the continuous branding and criminalizing of Najeeb by media channels. And those who should raise their voices against this fail to do so, preferring to maintain a cautious silence than to join the babble of those who make noises of protest.

