Strike down Sedition

0
89

Mahatma Gandhi termed Section 124 A as ‘The prince of political sections in the IPC designed to suppress the liberty of the citizen’. Time and again this section has been invoked against human rights activists, journalists, public intellectuals and very recently, against the students. This provision of Sedition was brought to our land by the Britishers to curb the rising nationalism and sustain the imperial power of the colonizers. In England this provision was used from centuries to punish those who by their conduct jeopardized the safety and stability of the state or disseminated feelings of disloyalty which lead to the disruption of Public order.

The words ‘Government established by law’ in the Section 124 A mean the government as an institution or government as a symbol of state and do not mean the ruling party in power.

In India, the sedition law was initially invoked against the editors of nationalist newspapers who advocated for a free India. Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Annie Besant and Mahatma Gandhi were some of the people who were constantly harassed by the colonizers by the invocation of sedition law. In the draft constitution sedition was included as an exception to the Freedom of Speech and Expression guaranteed under A.19, but it was later eliminated when the drafters remembered the horrors of the law and felt that such a law could be misused and abused as it had been adduced against the freedom fighters.

The language of the Section 124 A of the Indian Penal Code which contains the law of Sedition is very wide and problematic. There is a very thin line which distinguishes as to what would amount to Sedition and what would not. Prior to the Independence of India the Federal Court( which was the highest court of appeal in India at that time) in the year 1942 in the case of Niharendu Dutt Majumdar v. King Emperor, limited the scope of Sedition to only those cases where there was an incitement to disorder or use of words which had a tendency to incite disaffection and disloyalty. But this position was departed from in the year 1947 in the case of King Emperor v. Sadashiv Narayan Bhalerao, where the Privy Council (highest court of Appeal for Commonwealth Countries at that time) held that incitement to violence was not a necessary ingredient of the offence of Sedition. Finally in the year 1962, the Supreme Court of India while upholding the constitutionality of Section 124 A in the case of Kedarnath Singh v. State of Bihar ruled that the section aims at rendering penal only such activities as would be intended, or have a tendency, to create disorder or disturbance of public peace by resort to violence. The Supreme Court in this case reaffirmed the view of the Federal Court, henceforth limiting the wide scope of the Sedition law.

The language of the Section 124 A of the Indian Penal Code which contains the law of Sedition is very wide and problematic. There is a very thin line which distinguishes as to what would amount to Sedition and what would not.

It is to be kept in mind that the law is made by the legislature and it is the executive which implements it. One of the reasons as to why there is a gross misuse of the provision is that the law enforcement agencies while invoking the section use their subjective analysis while determining as to what would amount to seditious and given the nature of the section, it becomes quite impossible for them to ascertain the nature of any writing or speech. This then paves the way for the governments to curb any type of dissent or even heavily loaded criticism by invoking the law to drown the voices of free speech. The Supreme Court has remained firm in its opinion on Sedition but the law enforcement agencies have continuously disregarded the interpretation of the law by the apex court. The Sedition law is being used to penalize any type of political dissent in the country and also any alternate political philosophy which runs counter to the ruling party’s ideology. The words ‘Government established by law’ in the Section 124 A mean the government as an institution or government as a symbol of state and do not mean the ruling party in power. Therefore any strong criticism of the measures of the government or its agencies, which do not generate the inclination to cause public disorder, would not be penal.

The law of sedition in Britain remained unused for almost a century and in 2009 by the Coroners and Justice Act it has been completely done away with. In such a situation when time and again an obsolete law is creating havoc in the name of reasonable restriction it is high time that either the courts intervene to give clarity on the law or the Parliament repeals it because such a law does not have a place in a modern democratic state like India.

The law makers should keep the laws updated by constantly reviewing and revising them in the best interests of the society and country. The 21st Law Commission has undertaken to revise and review the law of Sedition and we can only hope that this draconian law is done away with so that no longer the citizens have to think twice before speaking against the government in power.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here