Home Deliberation Hajj Subsidy : Hidden And Untold Facts

Hajj Subsidy : Hidden And Untold Facts

1196
0

The sudden scraping of hajj subsidy has now become yet another topic of discussion throughout the nation. The subsidy for hajj pilgrims was started in the year 1954 during Indira Gandhi’s governance.  Back then the un-stated need of declaring subsidies was the requirement of the central government to keep government owned Air India afloat. Time and again the Muslims have stated that the subsidy helps Air India and not the Muslims. But the Hajj subsidy was always used to embarrass the community by many who felt it was minority appeasement.

The Supreme Court in 2012 directed the Centre to gradually reduce the amount of subsidies being given to Hajj pilgrims so that within 10 years it is eliminated, and the money be used for the “ upliftment of the community in education and other indices of social development.” Accordingly the government reduced hajj subsidy gradually in the last few years but now suddenly scrapped it mid-way of the 10 year time limit suggested by the Supreme Court. But as per the judgement the difference amount should have been used on the recommended purpose which has not been done in all these years.

The Union minister Mr. Naqwi said that, “the increase in the hajj quota expansion is a record in two years, as it increased from 1, 36,020 to 175025”… and he also said that this shows the Modi government’s concern towards minorities. If it is so then why did the centre scrap the hajj subsidy suddenly? Saudi Arabian government has added 5000 more to Indian hajj quota this year. Is scrapping the Hajj subsidy because of the increased quota of pilgrims from Saudi government?

Mr.Naqwi also said “Saudi Arabia has also given green signal for India’s decision to review the option of sending for Hajj pilgrims through sea route”. The government sources expressed three purposes regarding scraping Hajj subsidy. Firstly, “the sea route will allow more people to undertake the Hajj journey incurring less expense”. And the second reason given by another source was that “One of the ideas is to restrict the pilgrimage to once in a lifetime” and the third reason given by them is ‘it is to ensure that all desirous people get a fair chance to undertake the journey’. If this was the purpose then government could have lowered the airfare than starting the sea route again after 23 years because, few hours journey by plane is always preferable, compared to 3 to 4 days journey by sea.

A subsidy is a fiscal aid or at best a compensatory amount to make some fee or price, affordable, for the consumers. But the amount claimed as given as subsidy looks fishy because only Air India was allowed to ferry the hajjis and no other airline. If it was a subsidy then the amount should have been given to pilgrims directly and they could have than been left free to choose whichever airlines they want.

Though the Hajj tickets are pre-booked in advance and are bulk purchases, yet the Air India are was almost double than the normal fare. Usually for the bulk purchases and pre-booking tickets airways always make the fare much lower. But, for Hajj pilgrims it did not happen and on the contrary they paid higher than the normal fares.  By inviting international tenders price could have been reduced with competition and the false impression of Government subsidy for Hajj pilgrimage could have been avoided. Moreover the pilgrims who go via the Indian hajj committee have to cook themselves and are accommodated in far away and cheap hotels which make the hajj expenses very low compared to other private hajj packages. And when we consider these facts and compare   the amounts paid by hajj pilgrims to the hajj committee and the   actual expenses incurred there remains a balance amount which is over and above the actual expenses. So where does this money go? Is it not a scam in the name of Hajj subsidy?

For example let us take a stock of the Hajj committee costs considering the quality services for the tour. Even if we consider the lowest amount a Haajji (one who goes to Hajj is called as Haajji) pay to the Hajj committee i.e Rs.2,10,000 and add the alleged subsidy  as Rs.45000(which is maximum) , the total cost  would be  Rs.2,55,000. Let us deduct the amount which would be given to a Haajji through Hajj committee as they reach Saudi i.e Rs.35000 and other expenses such as 80,000 for hotels for 45 days(as it is 4 person per room), Rs.30000 for food, and Rs.10,000 for transportation and Rs.60,000 for air ticket(Air India) there would still remain  a balance of unaccounted Rs.40,000 per person. So if we consider 1,00,000 Haajjies it becomes Rs.400 Cr. Where does this money go? Obviously! To the Hajj committee. Hajj committee is an undertaking of the government of India so the money goes to the government. But, if we agree to the statement of government source and consider 450 Cr amount as total subsidy then, can a government not provide even the small amount of 50 Crores to the Muslim pilgrims. Moreover the amount is transferred to Hajj committee bank accounts by the hajjis almost a year in advance. So where does the interest of such a huge amount go?

In addition when it was given as subsidy it cannot be called as a loss for the government because government spends more than Rs.4000 to Rs.5000 Crores on Hindu pilgrimages too. Is this not a loss using the same yardstick? One of the BJP minister said that those festivals are culture of our nation and government has to spend on them. Yes we agree that government has to spend on them, because   it is our nation’s culture, by taking care of the travelers during journey, maintenance of the holy places, medical aids and cleanliness etc. But government also pays the travelling amount which is more than Rs.50, 000 for Kailash Mansarovar yatra pilgrims. Is not it a violation of right to equality? If Hindu brothers and sisters have the right to use government’s amount for the pilgrimage, then why not other religions in this secular nation have that right? Is not Muslim culture and rituals part and parcel of India?

There are many questions of which we need to find the answer to understand the agenda behind scrapping of hajj subsidy. Firstly was the hajj subsidy the demanded by the Muslims? Why was the subsidy not given directly to each pilgrim? And if we take the subsidy loss in an affirmative manner considering government had to give subsidy through Air India then also the question arises why then the air fares of Air India were much costlier than the air fare of other Airways? Why did the hajj pilgrims have to pay double the normal airfares compared to other airlines? Why not India calls for international hajj tender which would help pilgrims to go to hajj with low cost without taking any help from the government? When Supreme Court had ordered in 2012 to abolish the Hajj subsidy by 2022, why the government did take an immediate decision to scrap it within 4 years?

 Now the union minister said “scrapping of Hajj subsidy is a part of the empowerment of minorities without appeasement”. There does not exist the question of appeasement when the subsidy was not the subsidy in actual but it was the business monopoly by the government for the Air India.  If the government really wants to empower minorities then where was such concern when there was lynching of minority people in the name of cow?  Where were they, When there were issues created in the name of love jihad, when the Madrasas are falsely called as terrorist hubs and when in Kerala Hadiya was not allowed to stay with her husband? And why did it not pass the communal violence Bill 2005 which had been forwarded by the UPA to formulate a harsher law to check the menace of communal violence. Why there is no importance for such bills which is the need of the hour and moreover the bill itself will show the concern of government towards minorities. And also why government is not interested in implementing Sachar committee recommendations?

Though the concern for empowerment of minorities was shown but the empowerment did not happen as expected. In three years we have seen there were regular efforts to instigate and hurt Muslim sentiments and emotions. We have also seen either the silence or the diplomatic statements of the NDA government on such issues including issues such as Muslim community’s personal matters, banning of triple talaq, criminalising triple talaq and now scrapping of Hajj subsidy. So when the purpose behind any law or scheme is not clear, when it fails to give the clarifications as expected, it reveals that there is something devious. Instead of focusing just on Muslim related issues the government now has to plan for the overall development of the nation which is shrinking on the ground of humanity, brotherhood and security. All citizens who are blessed with wisdom can easily analyse the agenda behind such instant surgical strikes.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here