Home Open space How should Muslims respond to blasphemy?

How should Muslims respond to blasphemy?

One thing I’ve noticed as a Muslim covering all this is that after multiple such incidents, we have not learned how to react to incidents of blasphemy or even Islamophobia. Muslims should not react to these attacks emotionally but rather react in a way similar to that of Prophet Muhammad and that is with Sabr and Dawah.

578
2

The situation in Hyderabad has been very tense since 25th August after blasphemous statments were spoken by BJP MLA Raja Singh . Stones were allegedly pelted, police reacted with brutal lathi charges and even barged into houses to arrest youngsters. How did the situation get so bad?

On August 20, the stand-up comedy show of controversial stand-up comedian Munawar Farooqi was organized in Hyderabad amidst opposition by local Hindu Nationalist leadership. The members of the Hindutva camp opposed the show citing that Munawar Farooqi had earlier abused Hindu deities in another show long ago, for which he even was imprisoned for some time.

The Telangana state government allowed the stand-up event to happen, with police protection amidst threats. In response to this, local BJP MLA Raja Singh released a 10-minute long blasphemous video on YouTube mocking and abusing Prophet Muhammad.

This has been the second incident of blasphemy in India in recent times and this time in a city where Muslims enjoy a socio-political significance. The city erupted into protests within minutes of the video’s release and Raja Singh was arrested and presented in court the next day. Within a few hours he was granted bail, and Muslims in shock erupted into even more aggressive protests. Slogans of “hang Raja Singh,” “hand him over to us,” and “sar tan se juda,” (beheading) were echoing in the streets.

One thing I’ve noticed as a Muslim covering all this is that after multiple such incidents, we have not learned how to react to incidents of blasphemy or even Islamophobia. We should try to discuss how we have to react to such situations from this point onwards.

Why does blasphemy happen?

Before we go into how we should be reacting to blasphemy in India as a minority, we should understand why it happens. Is it because Prophet Muhammad’s marriages are disturbing to them? Do they have a problem with polygamy? What is their problem?

As Muslims, we have to always relate whatever situations we are in, back to the Qur’an, sunnah, and the life of Prophet Muhammad. What does the Qur’an say about blasphemy and how did Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) respond when he was in this position? When the people of Quraish continued to hurl accusations and abuses against the Prophet, Allah revealed this verse :

We know that you, [O Mufiammad], are saddened by what they say. And indeed, they do not call you

untruthful, but it is the verses of Allāh that the wrongdoers reject. (6:33)

What does this imply? It denotes that the Islamophobes don’t really care about the marriages of Prophet Muhammad, they have a problem with the message of Prophet Muhammad  (PBUH). Even if the Prophet didn’t marry mother Aisha the abuses would still continue. The marriages are just a front to attack Islam. Now let’s deconstruct why hate-mongers attack Islam and what problem do they have with Islam.

Allah says in the Qur’an :

The true religion with Allah is Islam…. Let him who refuses to follow the ordinances and directives of Allah know that Allah is swift in His reckoning. (3:19)

The Qur’an’s claims that Islam is the only true path to God, the objective truth, and the dismissal of other religions as invalid, is one of the primary problems everyone from all spectrums, from right to left, liberal to fundamentalist, has with Islam. The Qur’an advocates for a contrary perspective, it says:

Never will the Jews be pleased with you, (O Prophet), nor the Christians until you follow their way. (2:120)

Response to Islamophobia and blasphemy

Nowhere are we challenging the traditional view of punishment of blasphemy, but we should also know that Islam forbids extra-judicial activity. As a Muslim minority, how must one react and respond to blasphemy and Islamophobia? Should the response be the same as it is in Muslim-majority countries? Obviously not. Allah also tells us in the Qur’an:

Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah, you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day and remembers Allah often. (33:21)

When we look towards the example of the Prophet (PBUH), we should see how he operated when he and his companions were persecuted as a minority community in Mecca. They reacted firstly with sabr (patience and perseverance), and most importantly and often ignored, they reacted with Dawah (calling people to Islam). Sabr, which roughly translates into patience and perseverance, and Dawah, which is inviting people towards Islam, are two of the most important and heavy weapons of a Muslim minority living in a non-Muslim society.

What was the biggest and most symbolic act of rebellion of the early Muslims against their pagan society? It was Hazrat Abdullah Bin Masood going to the Kaaba (which was back then a center for pagans to gather) and reciting surah Rahman. In many instances, for the sahaba, praying salah publicly was an act of protest, and an act of Dawah.

Significance of Dawah

If done right, Dawah shakes the roots of the unislamic establishment. It’s so powerful, that if done correctly, the state would use every resource within its reach to silence you.  The pagan Quraish offered Muhammad (PBUH) leadership, wealth, and women, and told him that he could pray all he want at an individual level, but on the condition that he stopped calling people towards Islam.

A society’s economic system is determined by its political setup, the social order of a society is the architect of its political setup, and its social order is a direct reflection of the beliefs, values, and morals of the people in the society. The beliefs, values, and morals of a society are the foundations of it.

When we do Dawah, we directly challenge the beliefs, values, and morals of the society, shaking its core foundations. And when those beliefs, values, and morals are challenged by Islam, the threat to the socio-political and economic order is even more severe.

Conclusion

I attempted to convey through this article that as the world moves more towards post-modernism, Islamophobia and incidents of blasphemy will be more frequent. Even though Islamophobia has been constant from the right-wing for the last few decades, post-modernism too can’t tolerate anyone laying any kind of claim to objective truth. We can expect blasphemy from their end to be much more severe as they live in their own bubble of self-righteousness and savior complex.

The main reason why blasphemy happens is Islamophobia, and there is Islamophobia because Islam claims to be the objective truth, the only valid path to salvation. Muslims should not react to these attacks emotionally but rather react in a way similar to that of Prophet Muhammad and that is with sabr and Dawah.

2 COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here