Veganism : Activism Or Attack

0
114

The debate of veganism in India has always been seen through a communal lens. A significant number of times in liberal circles as well as ‘woke’ generations demonise people around them for not going vegan and tag all genuine limitations as plain “excuses”. People brag about turning organic and going completely vegan with almond milk and often ask others “You seem to be educated, why cant you stop eating meat?Why are you so selfish?” With the recent passing of Eid-Ul-Adha I came across a number of posts talking about whataboutery calling out those who advocate crackers free Diwali on being silent on the issue of meat on Eid–ul Adha.

Here are a few arguments to be put forward for the crusaders of going vegan demonizing those who don’t. I have lost count how many times I used to feel ashamed in school when kids around me told that their parents have instructed them not to eat from our lunch boxes because we eat meat. The discussions in class when very conveniently our teachers used to target the minorities of being cruel or the sole reason of cattle meat industry existing in India were very common. The structural casteist communal thinking was internalized by me because of not being old enough to understand from where it has been coming from. A lot of people consider sacrificing the animals as mere “symbolic” or something as celebratory. The attack on the festival comes from blatant lack of research going with the stereotypical image of Islam that has always been prevalent in the mainstream media.The festival serves the poor who don’t get to eat sufficiently round the year.The argument put forward to switch to vegan products is itself ignorant. In many regions, cleaning land of natural vegetation for agriculture is not sustainable and different regions have different dietary patterns naturally with different food cycles.

Scientifically, it is impossible to completely go vegan because it will not only disturb the whole ecological system of the area and also not to forget the fact that the compensatory protein diet is far more expensive in different regions and inaccessible as well.

Coming to the idea of Indian veganism, a lot of promotion comes with upper caste–class privilege. The ignorance of culinary legacies of tribal population and capitalist culture that doesn’t allow everyone to afford products like almond milk is problematic. What itself is problematic is the idea of debate around veganism. Every time the debate is turned towards calling out those debating as “cruel”, “inhumane” and in India as “impure”. The idea to go vegan is to promote veganism and not of criticism and showing superiority over those. The deeply rooted idea of purity and pollution with caste and class privileges is what vegans need to think about. If we are to start a dialogue,if we are to talk about issue, we need to rethink our stand and others’ stand on the issue as well. The deeply rooted structured lens of seeing everything through communal binaries and bias is what itself is problematic. The cow vigilantism and recent cases of mob lynchings is a stark example of this rooted lens which takes violent turns in our society. After all, we need to think that whether the idea of preventing river pollution, going vegan or going cracker free comes from a biased ignorant stand or advance a dialogue and take action about things that matter.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here