It has been more than a month of the ongoing protests against the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) in the country. People, cutting across religious and caste affiliations, belonging to varied regions, ages and genders, are on the streets. They are vehemently opposing the NPR, the NRC and the CAA by holding Indian flags and placards, chanting slogans and singing nationalist songs. What is significant is that Muslim community particularly its women and students studying or trained in modern secular institutions, are taking the lead. Indian Muslims have always been blamed for being retrograde and orthodox. They are portrayed as cruel, evil, adverse, distrust-full, disloyal and anti-national by Indian Cinema and Hindu nationalist organizations. Hence, their Indian-ness is always questioned. The ongoing protests and demonstrations revealed three remarkable truths which I think will play a pivotal role in making the image of Indian Muslims in times to come.
The first and foremost important thing which stunned everyone is the proactive participation of Muslim women who otherwise are highly believed to be confined within the four walls of their houses. Their participation has actually some important and implicit truths which must be unearthed and brought to the public domain.
About Muslim women, it is the dominant perception that since they do not have agency, they are subordinate to their men and entirely driven by them. They are illiterate, backward and totally unaware of socio-political affairs of the country. Contrary to this commonly held perception, Muslim women are actively participating, organizing and leading the protests in different parts of the country. Their protests are having the flavor of patriotism holding Indian flags, carrying photos of nationalist icons such as Mahatma Gandhi, B.R. Ambedkar, Maulana Azad, Bhaga Singh and Ashfaqullah Khan, etc. along with the chanting of patriotic slogans. Their talks are more logical, rational and appealing than that of their men who are always loaded with the emotions and fantasy.
The role of Muslim female students clad in Islamic hijab is extremely laudable. They seem to be very courageous, vocal, and confident and they have a clear understanding of Indian secularism and democracy which shows that beyond domestic chores, they have the capability to deal with the socio-political issues as well. These spontaneous anti-CAA protests provide wonderful opportunity to clear the old imagined picture of Muslim women in India who are always labeled as being segregated and unconcerned with what happens in the society. Moreover, their active engagement with the protest breaks the myth pertaining to their subordination in the community and explicitly argues that the issues of Muslim women were and still are communalized and politicized as it was widely propagated that Muslim girls are not allowed to get higher education, they are immensely discriminated by male members of the family, and they are oppressed and imprisoned in their homes.
Secondly, a very significant development is the complete alienation of Muslim youths from religious clerics over secular issues. For a very long time, despondency, anger and frustration were brewing among the community towards Ulema and religious scholars who maintained complicit silence on victimization of Muslims. The abrogation of the Article 370 made the case stronger which resulted into complete negligence and disobeying of religious figures of great stature such as Shahi Imam of Delhi Jama Masjid and others who made abortive efforts to convince the people that CAA is not anti-Muslims. But gone are the days when the political destiny of Muslim community was decided by Ulemas. Now the time has completely changed.
The young generation, raised in Weberian modern rational world wherein traditional authority ceases to be functional, believes in debate and argumentation which the religious traditional authority lacks immensely. These students studying in secular institutions seem to be more aware and logical. Since students in universities are very much familiar with the intricacies of modern democracy and the ways state can easily suppress the dissent, students of these universities are aptly leading the protests despite police brutalities on various occasions. In a democracy, we must be familiar with different means of peaceful protests so that the dissent voices may be strongly felt and at the same time we can also never be ignorant of the ways the state can suppress dissenting voices. Closely connected to this is another clout of students who receive their education in seminaries and Madrasas. Often dubbed as ignorant of the contemporary affairs and merely immersed in rote-learning of the orthodox traditional knowledge, these young madrasa students were seen defying the myhts, when thousands of them conducted protest marches at Deoband and Nadwatul Ulema against the discriminatory CAA.
The third phenomenon which is of paramount importance is directly linked with the image of Indian Muslims. Since independence, Indian Muslims have been carrying the double burden of allegedly being unpatriotic and appeased simultaneously. Their loyalty to the country is often questioned. They are portrayed as disloyal and terrorist and are always asked to prove their Indian-ness which is not the case with the people of other religions. Interestingly, these protests are witnessing long national flags, national anthem, patriotic songs and different symbols of nationalism which put the right wingers in great difficulty to blame the protesters as anti-nationals. The plank of nationalism which the BJP and other Hindu nationalists consider their monopoly was forcefully snatched by these protesters.
These three developments not only will change the stereotype of India’s Muslims but also prove as the torchbearers for womenfolk to lead the nation.

