As a value system democracy has three characteristics: intrinsic, instrumental and constructive. The first relates to social and political participation in decision making and the second offers people a hearing and directs political attention to their needs and demands, while the third one brings people, barring all caste and religion affiliations, together into fruitful discussions and debates on the functioning of governance. The third characteristic, in connotation, should imply criticism. Criticism is a way of evaluation and assessment, an inquiry into fallacies and loopholes of strategies to achieve targets. To make it stronger, I would say constructive criticism. Criticism ought to be distinguished from propaganda and allegations. While the former leads to an open discourse of discussions and brings about a more refined form of democracy, the latter merely perpetuates hatred and violence among the people comprising a polity.
The recent decision of IIT-M’s dean to “de-recognise” a students’ group is ethically unjustifiable and constitutionally undemocratic. Ethically unjustifiable because the dean unilaterally decided to impose the ban on the group, following an anonymous complaint letter lodged by some student to MHRD, without giving the group a chance to explain their stand on the controversy. Here the basic constitutional rights is violated & denied as the academic institution can’t take away the right to freedom of expression from anybody. The ban undoubtedly is devoid of instrumental and constructive value as enumerated above. Had the institute been really concerned about polarisation which it claimed was happening due to the organisation named after Dalit and anti-Hindutva ideologues, it would have derecognised the other student’s bodies named after their own ideologues. The banned group have been actively engaging in discussions on socio-economic aspects of policies of the current government. Active participation in academic talks and discussions on issues like agriculture, land acquisition bill, industrial disputes act & many more do not buy any genuine logic of de-recognising the group. Being an academic campus, sensible investigation and critical observation on the policies should always be welcomed. The interference of MHRD in the autonomy of institutions of higher learning by replying to an anonymous complaint letter is in the first place nonsensical and derogatory.
In a democracy if people are not empowered with the right to dissent, the democracy loses its significance and ultimately collapse into a system of autocratic dictatorship. Wielding power unlawfully and suppressing dissenting voices marks the death of a progressive democracy.
Campuses are the power houses of multi-facet ideas and opinions where students ascribe to different perceptions, viewpoints and ideologies. Homogenisation of such vast diverse campuses is not feasible. Striking out German, introducing Sanskrit, mandatory yoga , one-sided education policy are undervaluing the cultural and communitarian diversity. They put a curb on socio-religious freedom. The restriction on students in expressing their views, is an impediment in their intellectual growth that forms healthy democratic environment. As a result the educational institutions fail to challenge the young minds which are doomed to have no dynamism, no innovation, no activism no new thoughts and no breakthroughs. In order to promote constructive democracy in campuses where the bedrock of future of nation is built, any activity promoting jingoism and communal fascism must be checked. The progressive steps towards carving out an egalitarian Indian campuses representing various students’ bodies ought to be encouraged and appreciated.

