Scribbling the dissent in AMU

0
1636

While Student Union is in itself has been passing through its own kind of legitimation crises. The academic session 2025-26 started with VC Naima Khatoon’s attempt to project herself an Iron lady, has met with serious setbacks and lurking, questioning her sensitivity towards the students of AMU introducing detention and imposition of an unjust fee hike.

It shows her distance and an unawareness of both the student life in AMU and the socio economic background they are coming from. The human side of VC as a guardian to students has a lopsided with the executive position she enjoys, burgeoning a gulf that won’t be covered with the carrot and stick policy. The 15 day Dharna resulted in a promise of relaxation of Fee hike to 20 percent and resignation of Deputy Proctor and Assistant Proctors but it’s a long way to meet students demand as put by them. The muddled path to negotiation has brought many actors into play from Proctorial team’s misbehavior to opinionated Professors who are more interested in ideological tones of the speakers in the Protest. However, the setting is far ahead of the ideological era and thus witnessed blurring of pertinent boundaries and one such is campus life.

How a very ordinary student seeks to look at the protest site is a difficult and fragmented question. Moreover, the snowball effect was not limited; it made its way to professors’ opinions and, similarly, to a notorious headline in newspapers like Dainik Jagran, which is the bloodline of print media in the Hindi public sphere, where Bab-e-Syed was described as an “arena.”

Meanwhile, the deplorable condition inside the university campus has another dimension that requires our attention to root out the problem, which has taken firm hold and spread in recent years.

Denial of Student Agency

When the protest erupted, many learned professors began seeing it as a proxy for the internal politics of professors, thereby denying the agency of students and their voluntary participation in student politics. Although, general students especially post-Covid batches found themselves in a different calendar and architecture, which had skipped an important event: the AMUSU election, along with other important rituals like the graduation ceremony. Many noticed that canteens and buildings, which were once part of the everydayness of AMU, had turned into silent spaces. The lockdown period had technically numbed the entire “here and now,” making the present completely unknowable for students. Agamben, in his essay Requiem for students, highlighted the centrality of physical encounters with fellow students and teachers as essential to a form of life in the university. The shutdown of many canteens and the heavy surveillance of such spaces inside the campus is simply an attempt to make the student body docile and bring it under the institutional gaze. Along with this, classrooms have become one-way dry lectures, and churning out of an agreementative indian as put by Sumana Roy. It indicates a larger problem that only augments nearly every dominant socio-political ill and highlights our helplessness toward the human condition.

Hyperreal AMU

A phenomenon that has plagued a place like AMU is the hyper-romanticization of a life that is not part of everydayness but rather a strange nostalgia in which students themselves are placed. The fascination with seeing the “same” and appreciating it is inducing a self-centered form of life that will develop a disregard for the “other.”

جو ابر یہاں سے اٹھے گا وہ سارے جہاں پر برسے گا

Jo Abr yahan se utthega wo saare jahan pr barsega!

The cloud that rises from here shall rain upon the entire world!

A popular line from Majaz’s rendition to Aligarh implies the expansive zeal ablaze, yet to make its way throughout the world. However, lately, this abr has become insular, lumped against its own representation over the cloud/Internet.

It is not politics that has become a centripetal force; rather, circumambulating around the received information proliferates disconnect—and this disconnect becomes even more elusive when the mediators of “table talks” are chosen by the administration itself. It has aggravated the prevailing discomfort with any kind of dissent inside the campus. It is an immoral act to divide students on the basis of certain coteries, but it must be asked whether the administration is even aware of the banality upon which they have stumbled.

Are sunn le VC aisa bol! -ارے سُن لے وی سی، ایسا بول

The slogans were raised to agitate and amplify the demands. But the VC could not hear anything apart from the clanks of the bureaucratic iron cage, which has kept her apart from the students protesting at Bab-e-Syed, rendering her irrelevant and authoritarian. Naima Khatoon, the current VC, is fortuitously carrying the continuity after her husband Gulrez, followed by Tariq Mansoor, currently a BJP MLC.

AMU students still lament the fact that the previous VC, Tariq Mansoor, paved the way for the state administration to enter the campus premises. The ruthless beatings during the heydays of the anti-CAA protests and thereafter allowed the local administration and authorities to intervene more frequently in campus affairs.

Under the aegis of the current VC, the local district administration and police were knowingly or unknowingly involved in order to dispel the protesting students. This turned gruesome when students wanted to offer Friday prayers at Bab-e-Syed, which led to the detention of two students by the police. However, the idea of offering namaz was not novel, nor a distinct break from AMU’s own forms of dissent, which had been performed many times before. Yet the intervention of the local police carries a serious legacy bequeathed from the previous VC. Students want their VC to be courageous and a strong guardian, not merely an heir to the previous chair holder.

Affordability of Higher Education

In recent surveys by Nous Network, which examined the trajectory of the aftermath of the Sachar Committee reports, only negligible improvement was noted. Thus, it raises many socio-economic concerns, showing how students from marginalized communities still lack the support to pursue higher studies. AMU’s fee hike, despite the university being a home to many underprivileged students, has moved them to question the road they have unfortunately taken.

In her work “Nation and Community”, Laurence Gautier traced the Muslim community and its politics in postcolonial India. She also noted AMU as a gateway to upward mobility for the new Muslim middle classes and for the impoverished coming from the backward regions of UP and Bihar. Saif Wahab, a research scholar at AMU, notes the sudden fee hike in his article “AMU’s Affordability Has Been Its Greatest Strength” and dubs it an administrative betrayal of the legacy of Sir Syed’s vision.

Hunger Strike met Hunger Artist

When India celebrated its 79th year of independence, the VC paid a ceremonial visit to Strachey Hall and later distributed fruits to those admitted to the health centre. But the students sitting at Bab-e-Syed, who had gone on a hunger strike a day earlier, were denied their demands. Thus, the strain has reached farther, and now, upon entering the fourth day of their hunger strike, Kaif and Rayyan did not expect that it would take such a different and insignificant move for the VC and administration to deliberately neglect a genuine demand. In Kafka’s story The Hunger Artist, the artist receives a certain deliberate neglect for the art he performs, something people do not want to look upon. Similarly, the hunger strike turned into a hunger art, but it was scarcely received as a genuine move by the protesting students. On the other hand, the hunger strike has become popular digitally, with social media posts that received many likes but could not gather even one-tenth of the presence on the ground, as if the protest site had become an afterlife that could be salvaged with the “Amen” performed on smartphones.

References

  1. https://indianexpress.com/article/education/aligarh-muslim-university-amu-student-protest-fee-hike-limited-academic-council-student-union-10191178/
  2. https://maktoobmedia.com/opinion/conversing-with-silent-spaces-in-amu-enquiring-cessation-of-canteens-through-habermas/
  3. https://compart.uni-bremen.de/content/4-teaching/0-sommer-20/2-think-the-image-generative-art/3-material/paper-2020-agamben_requiem.pdf
  4. https://www.thecitizen.in/index.php/en/NewsDetail/index/9/18884/Aligarhs-Brewing-Love-Story-with-Chai-Dhabas-and-Cafs-
  5. https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/why-a-noisy-classroom-must-not-be-silenced-9559194/?fbclid=IwQ0xDSwMO6DljbGNrAw7oNmV4dG4DYWVtAjExAAEeQNqP-h9Xou9UaW2RvKrO5_YeU6Xxcpfgsxp-5VecqUHDrbj2ZSzXbiosWCs_aem_-_HU8xZyE4vquJ4c7UB77A

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here