The term ‘Agnostic Muslim’ seems like an oxymoron to most agnostics and Muslims. For surely being an agnostic means you do not belong to any idea or ideology? Well, there is no such thing as non-belonging. We will discuss the impossibility of such a notion in reference to Heidegger below. To me, being agnostic is about inhabiting a certain frame of mind – one that is inquisitive, critical, patient, and bears the marks of intellectual humility. It is as much an intellectual mindset as it is a spiritual state of being. It requires the holding within of opposites, contradictions and antinomies. Eschewing any haste in forming an opinion, it demands a patient, just and unbiased consideration of a situation from various perspectives. To be agnostic is simply to have the wisdom and the courage to say ‘I do not know’.
But surely a Muslim cannot identify as an agnostic? Aren’t believers supposed to know God? How can anyone serve a God they do not know? Well, classical theism has always emphasized the transcendence of the Divine – that something as permeating as the ground of all Being is paradoxically also the most obscure. If to name a thing and to conceptualize it, is to dominate it – then do we really mean to say that God can be dominated? Does not the Qur’an unequivocally assert:
“No vision can grasp Him, but His grasp is over all vision: He is above all comprehension,” (Qur’an, 6:103)
In fact as Saint Augustine says, if you understand it – it is not God. In a sense, anyone who is not slightly agnostic of his/her comprehension of God – is arrogating Godhood to their self in claiming comprehension of God – which none but God can claim. Despite the fact that popular religion makes use of ready-made dogma and cut-out catechisms, one must resist this impious urge of ‘mastering the Divine’. Rather, one must always maintain a basic sense of their place as creatures whose reach is terribly limited in ultimate matters, and who must find their joy, not in the hubris of possessing all the answers, but in recognizing their place as humble servants of the singularly All-Knowing. And that all we may really say in the face of most mysteries is: ‘I do not know.’
“If you understand it – it is not God.” – St. Augustine in His Study by Vittore Carpaccio, 1502
On my personal blog, I have found myself writing variously as a secularist, a rationalist, a believer, a Muslim, an agnostic and even as an atheist. This might seem again as another disconcerting departure from predetermined categories. Does such a statement even make sense? Yes. Because I make sense of it. Because I am able to identify with all and none (vs. either/or). Since the first post on this blog, this vision of multiple-belonging has always sustained us. It has also accompanied us as we explored the nature of our roots and what it means to seek a ‘rooted-ness’. Having recently written a piece as a Muslim on the need for critical thinking among Muslims – I intend in the present piece to do the same as an agnostic, for other agnostics.
Let me begin by setting a few baselines for what the agnostic imperative demands. We must begin with the presupposition that indoctrination is evil. That education must be imparted democratically, with Socratic spirit and must inspire intellectual confidence. Thus, we ought to always be sceptical of the kind of authoritarian pedagogy that has become the stock-in-trade of popular religious preaching. Arguing ‘from authority’ is a logical fallacy – just because an authority figure says something, that doesn’t therefore make it true. All propositions must be accepted or rejected on their own merit – not because of where they appear or who says them. Which is why I’m certain that there can be no substitute for a critical mind of one’s own. We all need to think for ourselves. No one else can do our thinking for us.
The agnostic imperative must also make us suspect the power of ‘communal solidarity’. The special bond fostered among people by banding together around a common cause can be incredibly powerful. This kind of tribalism can be immensely reassuring psychologically – but is also for this very reason, highly dangerous. The tribalist temptation makes things easier because it dampens one’s critical faculty and independent decision making. Individual responsibility in thought and action is subsumed within the flow of the crowd, and it is this tide that comes to determine the direction one takes.
I am all for resisting such herd mentality or group-think or limiting of one’s intellectual independence. However, I also find it quite natural that there must be group formation within special areas of operation. For instance, someone who seeks to treat the sick, quickly finds affinities with others who are involved in the same work. Around the same work, the group develops a common language for talking about their specialist knowledge. Which to an outsider might seem arcane. Or for that matter, take acting as a profession. Actors and artists band together around commonalities in their vision or work. This in itself is entirely harmless. However, things can turn ugly when people start unjustly favoring those of their group over others – nepotism, corruption, injustice and oppression ensue as a result. And with greater power comes more violence.
I see religious communities as serving a similar function. Religious mythology and rituals offer a language and an enactment for the expression of certain deep, fundamental human impulses. Over time, these practices become elaborated and specialized and give rise to a common language that may express their meanings and dynamics. Thus, the same ‘transcendental impulse’ leads to diverse expressions, ranging from Buddhist seekers, to Christian disciples, to Muslim devotees. Each community develops its own language of communication. So, we find the same wisdom being manifested differently in the context of different communities. The difference in language naturally results in a difference in accentuation and emphasis. Thus, we find common grounds as well as areas of departure. However, to reduce these rich and elaborate expressions of our humanity, to a singular, universal ‘wisdom’ is a bad case of mixing our metaphors. If we follow the modern tendency of ‘secularizing’ them and denuding them of their religious colourings, we may be left at best with a merely elementary level of discourse – as any dumbed-down version of a specialist area is bound to produce. At worst, we may end up spewing out nonsense and balderdash.
Now we may wonder what any religious language might offer, that a secular language does not? To me, this is a vital question worth exploring. It is however a daunting task to take stock of all history, philosophy, religion and psychology. One would need to look at what sort of imagination human beings inhabited for the vast measure of their existence as Homo sapiens, and as ‘Homo religiosus’ – to borrow a term popularized by the anthropologist Mircea Eliade. In his recent book ‘God: A Human History’, the scholar of religions Reza Aslan writes exploring the anthropological origins of religion:
“What remains undeniable is that religious belief is so widespread that it must be considered an elemental part of the human experience. We are Homo religiosus, not in our desire for creeds or institutions, nor in our commitments to specific gods and theologies, but in our existential striving toward transcendence: toward that which lies beyond the manifest world.”
It would be extremely insightful to see which areas of human life found expression in traditional practices and ancient rituals. And to contrast it with what we have lost in gaining the modern secular imagination? The latter is a question that becomes the mainstay for post-structuralists like Michel Foucault.
The atheist thinker Alain de Botton recognizes that the fact that religious myths and rituals having lasted for centuries, must mean that they channelled a vital dimension of our human experience. And that their persistence for so long cannot be grossly reduced to mere authoritarian imposition – since clearly some of the most brilliant minds of human history have found them meaningful and have also gone on to contribute much meaning to them through their works.
To me, these are perplexing and open questions that I cannot hope to resolve any time soon. My agnostic inclinations challenge me to retain the perennial question mark wherever I can and for as long as possible. For precisely this reason, I am inclined to keep all doors of inspiration open. I must be careful not to lean towards the same tribalistic affinities one naturally develops by inhabiting a certain kind of group for a long time. I am highly skeptical of such ‘colonization’ by one tribe over others – and this is a colonization that takes place in our minds. Each camp naturally comes to see itself as possessors of the superior way – if not the exclusive way – of going about things. And no group/tribe is immune to such dogmatism and intellectual imperialism. Rationalism, secularism, nationalism, religion, atheism and even ‘agnosticism’ (when an ‘ism’ is made of holding an ‘agnostic attitude’) – all these can turn into different expressions of the same dogmatic impulse. For this reason, I apply the same principle everywhere, without reservation: It is the inherent logic and merit of a proposition itself, and not by which group says it, that decides whether we accept or reject an idea.
Despite my brazen rationalism and my unabashed agnosticism, I am also unabashedly Muslim. It is part of my multi-faceted, multi-spectrum intellectual identity. I am quite comfortable in drinking from many springs. The blood in my circulation derives profusely from various donors. Despite this fact, I am unafraid of the shock of any transfusion reaction or ‘mismatch’. I am a universal receiver.
Now, a few words on my Muslim affiliation. I take seriously the Heideggerian presumption of our ‘thrown-ness’ into the world. As per Heidegger we are already and always interpreting beings qua human beings. We only ever encounter Being through our being. As Dasein, (Heidegger’s term for human beings) we’re never abstractly impartial, never purely objective creatures. We only are (sein, German for “being”) when we are in a place or condition (Da) and cannot know anything apart from such conditionality.
Our historical conditioning heavily determines what we can become. Philosophy itself is predicated upon the contingency of history. And so any notions of Universal or Objective or Absolute Truth, are frankly presumptuous. We always ever encounter wisdom (vs. the term ‘Truth’) through and in the operations of society, and only in the way that history has allowed them to reach us at our present coordinates in space-time.
Hannah Arendt emphasized that philosophy must always focus on life as it is lived in the here and now. Personally, being brought up in a Muslim family and community, there are parts of that imagination that have become my own.
This is not a defense of blind belief or of externally imposed doctrines and dogma. These are all dispensable – and we are undoubtedly better off without them. However, what I find of value and seek to retain of my upbringing is the language. I find within Islam and Muslims a common language to talk about a shared experience with the Divine. The language of theology can offer not only a way of describing deep and universal intuitions of the nature of our reality, but also offers us a means of talking about human psychology, psychoanalysis, and tools of coping with the brute realities of our existence. Yet, unlike the academic disciplines mentioned above, the religious alternative speaks to all –the simple minded as well as the intellectually sophisticated. Now, this is in no way to imply that religion is an alternative to these academic disciplines. Nothing could be more absurd. Rather, I see these disciplines as indispensable to any rigorous understanding of the religious. Without them, a comprehensive picture of these mysteries may not be reached at. Now, religious practice itself may not provide a sophisticated theoretical framework that speaks to contemporary epistemology. Nonetheless, it offers a practice immediately accessible to all who wish to reap its therapeutic benefits, with or without theorizing it at length.
I approach rituals with the same wonder, and relish the mysteries at their heart. I am quite aware that rituals are often enacted unthinkingly and uncomprehendingly. So, I do not regard ritualism as a virtue. It can be another escape from the burden of thinking and taking existential responsibility. However, the underlying wisdom and symbolism of these rituals has me affixed. As the broadcaster and author Krista Tippet eloquently notes in her latest book ‘Becoming Wise: An Inquiry into the Mystery and Art of Living’:
“Rituals are sophisticated ancient intelligence about the body. Kneeling, folding hands in prayer, and breaking bread; liturgies of grieving, gathering, and celebration—such actions create visceral containers of time and posture. They are like physical corollaries to poetry—condensed, economical gestures that carry inordinate meaning and import. Rituals tether emotion in flesh and blood and bone and help release it. They embody memory in communal time.”
Apart from my obvious symbolic and mystical interests in religious language – I must admit that I also find it to be an indispensable medium of ethical discourse. As part of philosophizing amidst the here and now, I have chosen to embrace this language-community myself. Being equally at home as a Muslim, I am able to participate in a whole world of intellectual contestations that would otherwise remain closed to me as a mere agnostic.
These may seem as concessions to some. To others, it may seem as if I am setting undue limitations on ‘universal reason’. However, as an agnostic I cherish being a Muslim, precisely so as not to make concessions on the basis of the dominating trend, and to free my imagination from all constraints and colonizations.
Finally, taking stock of all the above advantages to knowing Muslim-speak, there is another critical element that I feel is being left out. I can only describe it as the result of spiritual practice. A relational knowledge of the source of reality/ the ground of Being. It’s quite hard to put my finger on it, much less to express it in words. Yet, it is precisely this elusive element that emboldens me to identify with the faith as an exercise in spiritual (and intellectual) openness. To be crudely certain of the secular view of the world would mean being deprived of much richness that lies in other non-modern traditions and ways of being in and seeing the world. That would mean saying smugly: ‘I know’.
But that is not what it means to be truly agnostic.
To be an agnostic is not to know God.
But it is also not, not to know God.
Thus, to know God.
“My incomprehension of Him, is my comprehension of Him.”
– Abu Bakr (The First Calif)
Note This is a sequel to previously published piece “Can Muslims Doubt God?”


