“Past generations,” said Martin Seligman, a psychologist at the University of Pennsylvania, ” had three anchors of stability in all of their societies: faith in God, pride in one’s country, and stability in the family.”
Over the past few decades, demographers have predicted and documented many radical changes in our societies that have quite literally reshaped the lives of young adults. By some measures, they have very different lives than their past generations and seem to be missing out on all three anchors of stability. Although, young adults in conservative societies are affected to a lesser degree, we still frequently find ourselves ensconced in a global trend of utmost sexual freedom, irreverence to all-things-godly and in a confused state of patriotism. Our anchors of stability are quite shaken if not uprooted entirely.
Rising rates of divorce and consequent family fragmentation have always troubled child and family welfare. Though divorce seems to be an obvious cause for concern, there are yet many other factors that amplify disintegration of families but are hardly even considered to be domestic issues. Family fragmentation is not just about divorce or children living with troubled parents. It’s also about children living with single mothers or fathers or unmarried partners or with no biological parents at all. Contrary to most beliefs, one of the most advanced countries on the globe, America, owes its biggest domestic problem to catastrophic rates of out-of-wedlock babies and teenage pregnancies.
Our unbridled rage for sexual freedom and unquestioning faith in science has revolutionized the family system, delegitimizing early marriage (or, marriage itself), legally upholding transgender partnership, homosexuality and surrogacy, breaking the most intimate, unconditional bond of parenthood. Having no scruple for morals, science is often used as a decoy to promote sexual freedom. If some of the scientific ideas have helped few enjoy the blessing of parenthood, they have so at the expense of the parenthood or childhood of another. For whatever reasons surrogacy is justified, basic human emotions lead many to question if it is right for a woman to sell her body for the sake of others, or to physically and emotionally detach herself from her child reducing his existence to a mere commodity. Researchers have only begun to realize the alarming effects of such endeavors on a child’s self identity. A child’s tie with his biological parents is the most ‘intimate’ and ‘closest’ to his being. Such biological ties, they say, are ‘identity-determining’ and ‘best for child safety’, in view of the soaring rates of child abuse by step or foster parents and unmarried partners.
Of course, there are successful single or foster parents at one end of the spectrum, but as James Q Wilson, an eminent social scientist says, “Almost everyone- a few retrograde scholars excepted- agrees that children in mother only homes suffer harmful consequences….the best studies show that these youngsters are more likely than those in (mother/father) families to be suspended from school, have emotional problems, become delinquent, suffer from abuse and take drugs.”
It is now widely agreed that children raised by two biological parents do better in life as individuals, irrespective of their economic conditions. A strong and balanced two-parent family ideal ensures all the basic needs of children. It develops a sense of belonging and security in individuals of all kinds. Family ties build a sense of responsibility not only in childhood but make them more emotionally secure and prepared in adulthood to take up responsibility for their own families and children that other marriage substitutes only help dodge. Some research scientists go as far as linking this sense of responsibility to the economic welfare of a country.
With more and more being primed to believe in a mere bodily existence, the entire sexual revolution is one colossal example of how dissatisfied many are with their own bodies. And this discontent persuades many to deny biology all together and continue to live in a state of make believe. The already existing problem of troublesome marriages (between heterosexuals) is further aggravated by homosexual and transgender partnership bringing under assault the ‘defining paradigm of mother father and child.’ But it seems who we click with is of far greater consequence than we think. Breda OBrien writes, “…a same sex relationship cannot provide a child with a mother and a father. This makes it profoundly different to marriage. Therefore, its not discriminatory to treat same-sex relationships differently.”
Interestingly, many children conceived through surrogates and donors, after having reached adulthood often claim the right to know their biological parents. The fact that they have been willingly abandoned by them creates a hole in their very existence and that vacuum in their biological ancestry, that missing identity is one of the ‘greatest psychological difficulties’ they face as adults. Even if children are being raised in the happiest of homes, their longing to establish a biological connection is difficult to be ignored.
And that is proof enough to know that parental love is unique in itself and important for human well being- its a ‘moral obligation’ parents owe their children and to willingly give them up without the intention of ever wanting to raise them, is a breach of that obligation. It is as morally problematic as is marrying someone with the intention of abandoning him/her soon after.
But the laws supporting these unnatural ways of child bearing and the frequent public outcry in favor of those who utilize them, are at a treble frequency than those who choose traditional marriage and natural ways of conception. The problem, it seems, lies in judging these laws by their intentions, the intention to help childless partners, rather than their consequences. In disguise, they have only helped selfishly prioritize our adult sexual needs, where biological ties- mother, father, siblings, grandparents, and extended family are a burden to be with and marriage is conflated with religious fundamentalism.
A ton of scientific evidence on child and family welfare points towards natural and traditional ways of marriage. Just as there cannot be a substitute to biological parents, no other substitute can replace marriage or do justice to a child that is to come.
Or, are we so biased to think otherwise for a common good?


