There emerges a stringent need to problematize the contemporary meta-discourse of/on Muslim women as the liberal/secular normative is constructed upon the rhetoric of Muslim women’s liberation. The power politics and subsequent patronization of Savarna/elite feminism is made possible through the strategic manufacture and dissemination of a (jingoistic) feminist epistemology wherein the Muslim women are earmarked as the ‘ideal victim’. Thus the task of every decolonial/Muslim feminist is to topple the canonical narratives of European/modern/Savarna feminism which classifies and objectifies Muslim women under its anthropological/academic gazes. The semiotics of secular discourse is governed by elite-Savarna etiquette –and thus the secularists and feminists (‘fab-India feminism’) are obsessed with the plight of Muslim women around the world, who are grappled under the tyranny of Islamic Fundamentalism and ‘macho-masculine’ Madrasas. Feminism constructed around modernity was monolithic, essentializing and patronizing on its own. Complicity, multiplicity and intersectional nature (of female spaces) were selectively ignored and thus failed to reflect the diversity of (Muslim) women’s experience around the world. Added to that was ‘secular antagonism’ to Islam which ‘represented’ a breach of secular values, an usurpation of the ‘West-constructed’ ‘secular spaces’ as put forth by Professor Adrien Katherine Wing and Monica Nigh Smith –
‘Muslims have attempted to create an Islamic identity with local, institutional, societal and cultural structures (…) the erection of mosques and the loud Islamic calls to prayer represents a ‘clash of civilizations’. (Wing 32)
The Islamic ‘veil’ and its ‘visual presence’ meant (for secular feminists) a breach to the “West’s” historical commitment to secularism and an adherence to patriarchy for which Islam stood for. Professor Mari Matsuda (In Critical Race Feminism)speaks about the ‘multiple consciousness’ a women of colour may feel: marked by race, gender, ethnicity, marital status, class and most pertinently political ideology(Wing 24). These plurality and heterogeneity (which I would regard as ‘distinct’ experiences) was narrowed to a monolithic equation – ‘wherein the Burqa-clad self was sensationalized as a victim of Islamic misogyny. The ‘twin figure of the Islamic fundamentalist and his female victim*’ emerges to be the currency of the time with the European ‘war on terror’ operating upon the body of Burqa-clad Muslim women. This was reflected in the Feminist Majority Foundation’s campaign against Taliban’s brutal treatment of Afghan women wherein popular womens’ magazines (like Glamour, Jane,Teen etc ) in addition to feminist journals like Sojourner, Off our Black and Ms., carried articles with regard to Taliban’s atrocious standards. It also provided a point of unity for groups from a range of political perspectives: from conservatives to liberals to radicals, from Republicans to Democrats, and from Hollywood glitterati to grass root activists.(Hirschkind, Mahmood 339-340 ).
Taliban’s brutal regime has to be condemned and denounced but the political ‘incorrectness’ and selective amnesia of Feminist Majority Foundation and secular conscience is unraveled as the trope of Islamic Fundamentalism* is (mis)used as a ready-made explanation to pin down the complexity of Afghan issue within a linear paradigm of Islam v/s Muslim women. The facades of the ‘civilized west’ (with its paternal feminists) ‘saving’ Afghan women (alluding to Spivak’s white men ‘saving’ brown women from brown men) thus caught the global psyche wherein U.S’s role in aggressive militarization, starvation and refugee crisis of the region was silenced. As Hirschkind and Mahmood argue, ‘the variety of ideas, images and fears that Islamic fundamentalism evokes in American imagination (…) women wearing headscarves , the cutting of hands and heads, massive crowds praying in unison, the imposition of a normative public morality grounded in a puritanical and legalistic interpretation of religious text, a rejection and hatred of the West(…) emerged as potent tools wherein Islam was propagandized to be synonymous with terrorism, Talibanism, rape rooms and toxic masculinity. This could be paralleled to a ‘particular’ form of Islamophobic politics manufactured and disseminated in the post 9/11 world.
Bush’s speech on February 4,2004 unravels this ethnocentric/Islamophobic western conceptions:
‘Because we acted, nations of the middle east no longer need to fear the reckless aggression from a ruthless dictator(…) Saddam Hussein now sits in prison cell, and Iraqi men and women are no longer carried to torture chambers, and rape rooms and dumped in mass graves’. (Bush 2004).
Within the pretext of questioning the gender politics of the fundamentalists’ the Wests’ ‘inferiorizing gaze’ was stuck upon Islam: a threat to modernity, feminism and the gush of ‘liberal/progressive’ values it produces.
West and the ‘exotic’ Orient
As Haideh Moghissi argues, ‘the domesticated, subjugated, unenlightened Other was opposed to the liberated, independent and enlightened Western self and was used as a moral prop to legitimize colonial power relations’ .( Moghissi 15). Thus the Oriental Other was to be ‘tamed’ and ‘enlightened’ by the White man. This cult-image of Western paternal patriarchy has been evident in French/English colonial literature and ‘colonial feminism’, as Leila Ahmed has remarked, was to legitimize Europe’s ‘civilizing mission’. (Colonialism, Culture and Women’s question have always been a matter of contention and have been problematized by post-colonial theoreticians including Partha Chatterjee (‘Nationalism and Women’s question’), Leela Gandhi (Emblematics of Gender and Sexuality), and Gayathri Chakravarthy Spivak (‘Can the Subaltern Speak’?). In Said’s words the ‘imaginative geography’ of the Orient (and eastern women) was disseminated as an Orient of dreams for example Said read Flaubert’s representation of Oriental Muslim woman:
‘Flaubert’s encounter with an Egyptian courtesan produced a widely influential model of the Oriental woman: she never spoke of herself; she never represented her emotions, presence, or history. He spoke for and represented her. He was foreign, comparatively wealthy, male, and these were historical facts of domination that allowed him not only to possess Kuchuk Hanem physically but to speak for her and tell his readers in what way she was ‘typically Oriental’. (Said, 1978)
The Muslim women was thus, ‘far more Oriental than the man’ and ‘La femme Orientale’ represented the impassive, undemanding, and insensate self. The intense preoccupation with the veiled female body as a phantasm* (Barbara Harlow) is scrutinized by Algerian writer Malek Alloula in his The Colonial Harem . The picture post cards unravel the ‘sexual fantasy’ of the colonizer over Algerian women exposing the gendered violence of white European male. Fadwa el Guindi describes the sexual geography this way: ‘harem as the locus of an exotic and abnormal sexuality … a microcosmic Middle East, apotheosizing the two characteristics perceived as essentially Oriental: sensuality and violence.’ (El Guindi, 97). The epistemic violence of colonial semiotics revolved around the ‘veil, polygamy, harem’ trilogy wherein they emerged as signifiers of female enslavement and pinnacle of Islamic misogyny.
Politicizing the ‘Veil’
The material, spatial and religious spaces of Muslim women were defined, asserted and disseminated through a set of fossilized images- through the unquestionable and hegemonic ‘progressive’ paradigms which patronized itself. This involved a monolithic pinning down of the Veil as a sign system conveying oppression and Islamic chauvinism which could only be redeemed through progressive intrusion/civilizing of the West. French feminist intellectual Elizabeth Badinter put it, ‘The veil … is the symbol of the oppression of a sex. Putting on torn jeans, wearing yellow, green, or blue hair, this is an act of freedom with regard to social conventions. Putting a veil on the head, this is an act of submission. It burdens a woman’s whole life’. (quoted in Mahmood 352). Any voluntary act of wearing the veil thus emerged to be predetermined by what feminists regard as a ‘false consciousness’ wherein Muslim women (un)consciously internalize the ‘inherent patriarchy’ of their religion.
A domesticated imagery of Veil pre-dominates the secular imagination which El Guindi argues, was regarded as ‘a material element of clothing almost exclusively embedded in gender, and distorted by ethnocentric accounts, or studied from the perspective of (western) Women’s Studies alone (El Guindi35). This reductionist political vision effaced the pluralistic socio-cultural and historical domains where Veil operated within the dialectics of class, piety, agency and identity. El Guindi in her cultural anthropological study brings in the example of rural Shi’a villages of Bahrain where “each home is locked with a padlock… (and) each woman carried the key to her house tied to her headcloth or to one of her braids’ (El Guindi 56). Key of the house being ‘tied to’ the headcloth of the women marks the veil as a potent signifier. This calls in for a ‘post-secular’ understanding of the Veil- building beyond uni-polar compartmentalization of what is/not ‘progressive’.
An ethical deconstruction of domains pertaining to freedom, public/private space, and autonomy unravels the fissures of Western Enlightenment (which was constructed upon an ‘Other’) and Western history (Its teleological motion which began in the East) which is what Ziauddin Sardar regards as ‘white liberty’ and ‘white secularism’. By maintaining the centrality of individual autonomy liberal/illiberal actions can be ‘tolerated’-this ‘post secular’ location of freedom is pinpointed by Saba Mahmood in Politics of Piety upon discussing political theorist John Christman who articulates that the “desires and values are generated in accordance with the procedural conditions of autonomous preference formation that are constitutive of freedom, then no matter what the ‘content’ of those desires ,the action which they stimulate will be (positively) free”. (Qtd inMahmood 12). This opens up an interstitial domain of freedom and performance where the individual has the right to choose/not to choose her/his actions no matter how ‘illiberal’ are. This subverts the populist feminist historiography foregrounded upon monolithic notions of freedom (the Freedom, the Liberty) and autonomy which is atomistic, individualized, and bounded upon the Self*. Realms of Post-freedom is explained further by Mahmood- ‘in the 1970s, in response to the call by white middle-class feminists to dismantle the institution of the nuclear family, which they believed to be a key source of women’s oppression, Native and African American feminists argued that freedom, for them, consisted in being able to form families, since the long history of slavery, genocide, and racism had operated precisely by breaking up their communities and social networks’ (Qtd in Mahmood 13).
The article at this point would examine the pluralist political discourses pertaining to Islamic Veil – as a radical sign system toppling power structures in/out by drifting between the personal and political. Albert Hourani’s article “The Vanishing Veil a Challenge to the Old Order” (published in 1956) argued on how the Veil would disappear in Middle East by the end of twentieth century. He pinpoints towards “the backwardness” of the Veil and emphasizes the stringent need for the Muslim community to ‘adopt advanced norms and practices of modernity’ (Qtd in Leila Ahmed.). This could be juxtaposed to Qasim Amin’s argument in Liberation of Women wherein he emphasizes the ‘comprehensive superiority of Europe’. He argues,
“That the men of Europe, who have attained such completeness of intellect and feeling that they were able to discover the force of steam and electricity (…) These intellects and souls that we so admire (…) Do you think that such a people would have abandoned veiling after it had been in use among them if they had seen any good in it? (Qtd in Leila Ahmed 46)
Egypt in 1920s, thus witnessed an unveiling, influenced by the political debate of the time wherein European modernity and conviviality was at its pinnacle. The wave produced and emphasized a scholarship of hegemony and superiority. Cromer in his book Modern Egypt asserts the inferiority of the “dark skinned eastern to the fair-skinned western’ and of Islam over Christianity. Leila Ahmed argues that this “unveiling movement of the veil originated not in precolonialist Middle Eastern notions of the meaning of the veil, notions rooted in Islamic, Christian and Jewish local meanings, but rather in Western nineteenth ideas.(Ahmed 94). Unveiling and the subsequent veiling in Egypt could be paralleled with two strands of feminism which emerged in 20th century – the westward looking feminism represented by Qasim Amin and Huda Sharawi and another advocated by Malak Hifni Nasif and Zaynab al Gazzali. Zaynab al Gazzali’s Jama’at al-Sayyidat al-Muslimat played a predominant role in reshaping the role of Muslim women within the domain of public activism and religious mastery.
In the context of an emergent Islamic consciousness of 1970s, Hijab was revived (and that too with a distinct vocabulary and semiotics) in the Arab speaking region, beginning with Egypt. The social space of resurgence was nuanced and political -setting forth an assertion of socio-political, religious and gender identity. The emergence of ‘new Muslim/Egyptian women’ was linked to the political turmoil in Egypt. The renewal of Islamic religiosity marked a crucial turn in University spaces wherein the women activists of 1970s started wearing al-ziyy al- islami. They according to El Guindi, ‘embodied and proclaimed the central importance of a society committed to gender segregation, and they embodied and modeled egalitarian principles and notion of social equality and justice across classes.(El Guindi186 ). The ‘new woman’ El Guindi argues, was ‘knowledgeable in Islamic sources, would lead discussions, and was “serious” in her public behavior. The visual presence / choice of this “this new Egyptian woman” El Guindi wrote, “is liberating herself … by choosing to veil and not to be molested or stopped as she assertively enters the public space”. (El Guindi 201). This was a ‘bottom-up’ movement wherein a synthesis of Islamic ideals and re-assertion of political domains was assumed. This new public appearance rejected Western materialism, consumerism, commercialism and values through re-asserting Islamic notions on egalitarianism, identity, justice and community. Perversely, this movement (of 1970’s) which was intensively grassroot yet inclusive was let out from the chronicles of Egyptian feminism. Feminist scholars deny its existence which was ‘emancipatory’- from imposed, imported identities, consumerist behavior and increasingly materialist culture.
Politicizing the Veil
The agency of the ‘native women’ in the colonial encounter has been a matter of contention. She according to Leela Gandhi was neither a ‘Subject nor Object’ but rather embodied a sign system wherein the culture, tradition and sacredness of the colonized and colonial modernity of the colonizer were inscribed upon. The veil which was more of a cultural and national symbol than religious (in Algeria) became the tool through which the colonial strategy was worked out. Fanon argues in Algeria Unveiled, “Every veil that fell, every body that became liberated from traditional entrance- Algeria was accepting the rape of the colonizer”. (Fanon 42). He adds on how the ‘women who see without being seen frustrate the colonizer’. Colonialism propagandized the veil as ‘fetish’ and the women who ‘hide herself behind the veil’ gained currency among modernists and secular feminists.
Veil, during Algerian freedom struggle emerged as a potent national symbol-a symbol of indigenous culture and tradition- which was aimed at toppling the cultural usurpation of the colonizer. Hal Lehrman of the New York Times Magazine called it the “Battle of veil”. Algerian women resistance is described in this way:
“…scenes … of black-robbed women fleeing razed villages; serving as nurses and even combatants with the FLN (National Liberation Front) … hiding (Algerian fighters) in cellars of the Casbah; … sitting in European dress at fashionable cafes with bombs in their handbags; suffering torture in the hand of French soldiers; marching in demonstrations, (…) and of course just waiting in detention camps …. and in refugee camps”
Post script
This ‘veiling of Algeria’ Pierre Bourdieu states, was ‘traditional traditionalism’ wherein Veil lost its purely traditional dimension. The complexity of meaning and semiotics to which it corresponds moves beyond the dimensions of religion and emerges as a signifier of social class and cultural/regional nuances. For instance veil among Assyrian women was a marker of rank (worn by the upper class women), there was a great difference in the veiling pattern among Palestinian women before and after Intifada wherein as El Guindi argues, “Veil/ dress covering communicated their ‘peasant origins’ and status as ‘camp women’.(El Guindi 121).
The epistemic violence committed by women’s studies group/liberal/secular feminists is revealed as they pin down Veil to a monolithic identity (of Islam-synonymously with women’s invisibility, anonymity and subordination) by selectively forgetting its pivotal socio-political and symbolic roles.Thus every act of decolonizing the narrative (on Muslim women) turns out to be political, involving a radical subversion of the categorical, hegemonic and hierarchical logic operating within feminist epistemology.
References:
1. Adrien K. Wing, “Critical Race Feminism Lifts the Veil?: Muslim Women, France, and the Headscarf Ban”, 39C. Davis Law Review 743 March, 2006
2. CNN Live event/special Bush Compares Churchill’s Challenges to Today’s Transcript, Aired on February 4, 2004 14:33 ET
3. El Guindi, Fadwa ,Veil-Modesty,Privacy and Resistance. New York, 1999. Print
4. Fanon, Frantz. “Algeria Unveiled.” A Dying Colonialism. New York: Grove, 1967
5. Hirschkind, Charles and Saba Mahmood, Feminism, Taiban and the politics of counter- insurgency, Anthropological Quaterly; Spring 2002
6. Mahmood, Saba. Politics of piety The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject. Princeton University Press 2005
7. Moghissi, Haideh, Feminism, and Islamic Fundamentalism: The limits of Postmodern Analysis ZED books, New York 2002.
8. Said, Edward W. Culture and Imperialism. London: Vintage Digital, 2014. Print.



Well written and beautifully argued.
The arguments are not flawed but the fact that so much effort was put into a topic which has little significance proves that the priorities are misplaced. Just because people see women wearing a veil through a lens of hypocrisy does not make the veil is the best thing that has happened to women in Islam.
Veil is a form of restraint that the patriarchal Muslim society designed to prevent women expressing themselves, to control them and to suffocate them to submission.
It does not matter is other societies are patriarchal or not. That is not relevant. Veil has to be eradicated if Muslim women are to progress.
That is where our efforts are to put and not in arguing that others are hippocratic.
Keep writing.
You’re great simi