Home Religion & Spirituality Talaq and Current Muslim Society: What Is The Crux of The Issue?

Talaq and Current Muslim Society: What Is The Crux of The Issue?

603
3

The issue of Triple Talaq has of late garnered everyone’s attention. From those who know about it to those who don’t know anything about it, from political who’s who to apolitical saints, from the scholars to the masses, everyone seems to be involved in this controversy to the extent that the essence of Talaq seems to have been lost. The system of conflict resolution in terms of marriage and divorce which  were supposed to be guided by the Qur’anic principles has now become a matter of jurisprudential paradoxes and political gimmicks. Let us analyze the most important stakeholder in this controversy, the Muslim society:

1. The problem before Talaq is that of (un)Islamic marriage. It is an open fact that one or two marriages in a thousand end up at divorce. Before putting effort in analyzing the divorce one would faint at the most (un)Islamic way marriages take place in the Muslim society. Although the marriage ceremony and orchestra are  not advisable, the demand of dowry is growing with each passing day. Is there an iota of doubt on how (us)Islamic and oppressive this demand is? Do the religious pedigree, government, court and society pay any attention towards solving this menace? Is there any other way apart from making aware the youth and society about the dastard effects of dowry?

2. Unlawful handling of Mahr : Even the sermon that takes place during the marriage ceremony, does not educate about the true spirit of Mahr (paid in cash or kind at the time of marriage) in Islam. When it comes to Mahr, it boils down to two things. One, It should either be paid fully at the time of marriage or in two installments, one at the time of marriage and the other at some mutually agreed point in time. Two, the amount of Mahr must be decided by the bride keeping in view the financial status of the groom. But, here comes the twist. Quran in no way entertains the kind of mishandling in order to pay bride her right Islam ensures. In sharp contrast to what we see today, Quran clearly dictates that the only possible way of returning back the amount of Mahr to groom is the divorce and warns groom against any other vicious attempt to snatch this amount from the bride. This makes a strong point that the Mahr is an important part of the Islamic institution of marriage. How come in the world of possibilities mere 5 thousand or 21 thousand or even 51 thousand can be considered vital during the course of divorce that God Almighty had to specifically mention it among the repercussions the groom had to face after the end of marriage! Fact of the matter is that Quran demands a considerable amount to be given as part of Mahr. The example from the life of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and that of his daughters is something to look up to. The amount which the daughter of Prophet Muhammad(pbuh), Bibi Fathima (Razi-allahu-anha) received from Ali (Razi-allahu-anhu) was an estimate of around 96 thousand rupees. Note that Ali was the owner of only a bare minimum sword. Imagine what should be the amount of Mahr for those who earn handsome money per month from 20 Thousand to One Lakh and  that too in installments. Do the Khateeb(sermon givers), Ulema(clergy), and who’s who from the community would stand up and bring back this essence of Mahr back into the fold.

3. Talaq, the issue at the helm of affairs: Although the rate of Talaq among Muslims is relatively less and it is highly unlikely that the triple Talaq at one sitting is in practice given the vehement opposition to this ruling by many schools of thought in Islam. Sadly, most of the deliberations happening over some good amount of time now have been delusional about the complex technicalities of the ruling of Talaq in Islam. The problem faced by Muslim women is not that of triple Talaq or one. Even if all the schools of thought in Islam resort to accepting that triple Talaq is indeed one, yet the problems faced by Muslim women would remain the same. Here’s why. There are two vital things to this.

A) How can we make the process of divorce cleaner and graceful? : Marriage in Islam leads to a new institution of family which fundamentally depends on the mutual agreement between the husband and wife. The agreement also gives right to divorce. Quran and the Sunnat of Muhammad (peace be upon Him) explains the process of divorce in detail. Its essence is to utmost maintain the marriage and god forbid if there is no other way apart from divorce, there must be a series of arbitration which ought to be followed by both the couple before the final call of divorce that is Talaq. So that there is ample amount of time with the couple to rethink over their probable decision of ending the marriage and reconnecting to each other. Any misuse of this Quranic procedure is deemed sinful and also amounts to  punishment . There are two ways in which people misuse this ruling. One, irrespective of the enough reprimand and possible punishment order the groom might eventually utter three Talaq at once and announce the end of marriage.      Another, in an astute yet cunning manner groom might utter one Talaq only but with an intention to never return to marriage whatsoever and thus wait for the stipulated time and end the contract of the marriage which  is again problematic. In either  case the essence of Islamic ruling gets lost thanks to the inconceivable and irreparable act by the miscreants. Former misuse in the aforementioned cases is a clear cut deviation from the Islamic teaching, while the later method voids the essence of Islamic teaching. In both the cases, the Dar-ul-Qaza’ or Islamic court must arbitrate in order to mete out justice to the oppressed. In case there is no proper Dar-ul-Qaza’ or there is no Islamic court available, isn’t it that the responsibility lies on the general court to provide justice to the oppressed with the help of experts in Islamic ruling?  One must note that the oppressed could be  either the wife or even the husband. Wife is at the receiving end when husband unlawfully and unreasonably divorces her or Husband is the victim when wife demands divorce for no apparent reason. Moreover, if ever husband exercises Triple Talaq in one sitting even as an act of vengeance against the wife’s misdeeds, the man would be punished for going against the rule of the book (Quran) only. In the end, even if one utters Triple Talaq in one sitting , he will be punished for going against the rule of the book. Hence, the crux of the matter happens to be the misuse of Quranic ruling not Triple Talaq or even one Talaq.

B) Another issue at hand is the justice to the divorcee: In India while it’s extremely difficult to marry off a girl,  it is almost impossible for a widow or a divorcee to get re-married. Arab societies or for that matter many other societies in the world have not had any such issue. It would be as easy for the second marriage as the first one. Precisely the reason we do not find any proper solution to the problems faced by the women of the subcontinent in the books of Islamic jurisprudence. Mind that there happened to be a complete system of the family constructed on the Islamic principles. Today, neither parents support the widow nor the society has any proper mechanism to help her live a solitary life. One of the efforts in helping the widows was plotted by the Judges of Indian Judiciary which demanded the ex-husband to look after the financial needs. It clearly violates the Islamic ruling. Moreover it does not stand firm on the intellectual prism too. First, not all divorcees are oppressed. Second, sometimes even the woman can demand for separation. Thirdly, in some cases it is difficult to ascertain whether the divorce was legitimate or not. This step by the judicial authority would have been appreciated had it been to the extent where the oppressed from either of the couple be given the fine amount collected from the oppressor. A regular financial dependency between the ex-husband and ex-wife is not just difficult but also may lead to unforeseen complexities.

Nevertheless, what would be the solution to the issues pointed out here? Government must take into consideration their plight and pay them monthly until they get re-married. One of the suggestions stems out from the community is that those enjoying triple Talaq in one sitting must be given harshest physical punishment. They also demand social boycott of such miscreants for they go against the ruling of Quran. But a society which could not even  boycott  the husbands who demand dowry and abuse wives, how could it boycott those who are misusing Talaq?

(This article has been translated from Urdu into English by Muhammad Abdul Mumin .) 

3 COMMENTS

  1. Thanks for translation of an unedited write up which was posted within a limited WhatsApp group. Translation is nice but at places widow has been used instead of divorcee. There are minor gaps also. However, essence is there with good translation for further discussion. By the way, now I have completed the article with necessary editing and some additions. I feel it is the right of the translator to first get the copy of my revised article before publication in Urdu.

    • We’ve received the revised article and the translation is in progress. Would be great if you could give us your email ID to get your nod before publishing. Thanks.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here